1. a difference of opinion, and that makes conversations interetsing
2. that is unfair - we are as biased as you, and we are looking at it objectively as you do in your own self. The circus act that is sam-me is very destructive to team. We don't want that one-man attitude on any of our players. That is an objective judgment we make as Sox fans. We are not wrongly biased because we disagree with her. Back to #1 - difference of opinion.
3. Sure. A clown show is a clown show in whatever city the circus sets up the 3 ring tent.
4. Not when measured against all the negatives. Numbers are not the whole solution to baseball; it is an art, not a science. The numbers that sam-me puts up include a number of 90 loss seasons for his team. The numbers our post sam-me team has put up are three division champiosnships (93,94,00). Thise numbers mean more than a 90 loss season and one player running gaudy numbers.
So we differ. That is what makes the conversations fun!