Everything posted by Chisoxfn
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Dec 3, 2017 -> 11:15 AM) In hindsight, Jimmy G looks like he would have been a better pick than Ego Ferguson. I still think in my ideal scenario, we would have done what the Niners did. On paper, what an oustanding off-season, from getting a head coach I like, to buying a bunch of picks to getting your QB for a 2nd rounder (Jimmy G). No one could have predicted that would happen but job well done by Lynch (on paper). I still have zero problem with what Pace did (in regards to Trubisky) but I still think the smarter move would have been overpaying for Alshon to ensure you have at least one real pass catcher (and it wasn't like we were tight on cap space). Then again, I legit don't think the Bears expected Trubisky to play this year.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Dec 2, 2017 -> 12:44 PM) They have been saying he didn’t want to be in Chicago past his rookie deal since 2014. They have had plenty of time to deal him if that is the case, and it certainly seems to be the case. At this point even a 7th rounder would have been better than the Nothing the bears received Yes, Alshon was horribly mismanaged. So was the Robbie Gould fiasco. I said both all at the time of the deal and couldn't be more right. I was okay if you were going to move away for Gould and invest in the future, but Barth was none of those things and Gould's contract was never going to get in the way of making a signing. The only way dumping Gould made sense was if you went looking for a young kicker or you went out and got a better / as good vet for a similar price. By the way, even though I defend Fox, etc and don't think he's the reason we stink...I'm not going to be upset if the franchise goes another direction with the head coach. There are enough things I see on the field that I don't like, but I think everyone had blinders on when it came to Trubisky and just young QB's in general. He has a huge off-season ahead of him and I think this will be Pace's defining off-season. You need to show how you build / invest around a young QB, from the coaching staff to personell, etc. Look at the Eagles and what they did. They have put a lot of things around Wentz to put him in the best position to succeed (and that includes an excellent defense and strong rushing attack...plus weapons at the wideout).
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Nov 30, 2017 -> 03:20 PM) Conservative doesn’t always mean “throw 20 or less times, run the ball as much as possible”. Fox makes decisions that hamper his offenses ability to score often. Yes, Barkley and Hoyer threw more, for more yards. But yet, they didn’t put the ball in the end zone either. Why? Because when Fox gets in the red zone he tries to run it in, way more often than he should. With Mitch it has been exacerbated by becoming so predictable run run pass that his “leash” actually hurts Mitch by putting him into 3rd and long almost every time. Opposing defenses know what’s coming, you can see it. Yes, the wide receivers are a disaster right now but that doesn’t mean you abandon throwing it completely and forget both play action and rolling out are two of the things that Mitch does well. Defenses are pinning their ears back on third and long and Mitch knows it. I’m not asking for air coryell but give the offense a different look here and then and keep the guy upright. Perfect example is the first two drives against Detroit, which was all scripted. Multiple play actions and roll outs and they scored twice. Then they have to start calling plays and it all goes to s*** The Detroit game is an example where they actually opened things up a bit (and that is what they should do as Mitch gets ready). What they didn't want to have happen is you go to Trubisky and have a Nathan Pearlman 5 pick game where you destroy a kids confidence. While 3rd and long doesn't put him in a great position and is obviously not the intent, the reality is our players have committed egrigous penalties (and we've had just too many negative plays). If you run twice and then pass, you really shouldn't be in a ton of 3rd and "long" type situations because it should be pretty hard to have a "negative" play when you are running the football (especially with a unit like the Bears have). Unfortunately we've gotten too cute and shot ourselves in the foot too often and that has put us in even tigheter predicaments. All that said, I don't like the run run pass playcalling and loved that first half of the Detroit game where we were a bit more innovative (but again, I expect as Trubisky gets experienced, it will actually allow the playcalling to get more innovative). With a limited playbook (and that is what they started with for Mitch), there is only so much you can do.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Nov 30, 2017 -> 03:20 PM) Conservative doesn’t always mean “throw 20 or less times, run the ball as much as possible”. Fox makes decisions that hamper his offenses ability to score often. Yes, Barkley and Hoyer threw more, for more yards. But yet, they didn’t put the ball in the end zone either. Why? Because when Fox gets in the red zone he tries to run it in, way more often than he should. With Mitch it has been exacerbated by becoming so predictable run run pass that his “leash” actually hurts Mitch by putting him into 3rd and long almost every time. Opposing defenses know what’s coming, you can see it. Yes, the wide receivers are a disaster right now but that doesn’t mean you abandon throwing it completely and forget both play action and rolling out are two of the things that Mitch does well. The interesting thing to me is, Trubisky has not been that good out of playaction/rolling out. That is despite having a good rushing unit. The reality is we don't have guys who get open down the field / period and with it, the defenses are compressed and will remain compressed until we can prove otherwise. This unit is just stuck with a lack of talent and an extremely inexperienced/raw QB. The reality is we don't have playmakers who can spread the field (this is the worst receiving / playmaker corps I've ever seen on a football field). I also would say the reason we didn't convert yards to TD's last year goes back to Hoyer/Barkley being the QB's and our playmakers on offense (outside of Howard being weak...not counting Alshon who was suspended for part of last season). Its easy to just blame everything on coaching. Talent matters and the Bears have none of it at the downfield playmaking positions. None. We also have a QB who when you split the field in have, is actually having a harder time making plays (partly because the D only has half the field to cover on a roll-out and we have guys who just flat out are crappy route-runners, untalented hacks, or both).
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Nov 30, 2017 -> 01:28 PM) I will admit i was completely unaware of how painfully conservative he was Were we conservative last year with Barkley / Hoyer? I think it is evident we are conservative because we have a QB and personell who are not capable of being effective in an air-it-out offense. You have to coach to your personell and dropping back 40 times with Truibsky and this WR corps would be an epic disaster. Fox told us Trubiksy wasn't ready and he's actually prevented him from having major disaster of games by keeping the leash shorter and being more guarded. Everyone acts as if thats a negative, but I view that as a plus relative to what I saw Buffalo do earlier this year with Perlman and definitely with what the Browns have done. Not saying the run run pass / complete vanilla was right...but this season is about Trubiksy's and the teams development, not wins/losses. Trubisky wasn't ready (and isn't ready) to run a full offense and they are trying to be careful, while still managing / keeping games close (so they have a chance to win). Is it exciting, no, but it is measured and there is a purpose behind it. Over the past few weeks, we've seen them slowly take the reigns off of Trubisky and in the grand scheme of things, a measured approach makes sense (nothing about Trubisky's track-record screamed that we should have just dropped him back and opened up the offense...he flat out didn't have the experience / wasn't ready to do that). Period. It's not fun or sexy but I'd rather do run, run pass then do what a ton of the fans have been asking for, which in my opinion, would have just created bad habits and put Trubisky in a worse spot. There actually seems to be a strategy behind what we are / aren't letting Trubisky do.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (ptatc @ Nov 30, 2017 -> 01:05 PM) This is always where my mind goes. Remember the quotes about a good solid coach. He will turn the franchise around because he did it with the other teams. I don't think there were any detractors. some said they would have preferred an offensive coach but that was the only complaint. he had his issues. Remember that 5 year stint in cleveland? Yuck. Coaches can only deal with the roster they have dealt. At no point have I ever said, man, we should be multiple wins better then we are. Maybe we should have won that Green Bay game, but that is about the only game where I really think we should have won and didn't with Fox. We have won some that we had no business winning though. And when you have as little offensive talent as this team has (at key positions), you are going to have some games that you just flat lose because guys are not ready for primetime. Now if we get pants by the Browns...that is another story. Fox was given zero opportunity to win in this role. None. Anyone who claims otherwise is full of s***, imo.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Nov 30, 2017 -> 12:59 PM) He's either going to awesome or horrible. I just remember how happy so many were when the Bears brought in Fox. Now I watch TV and look on the internet, and the Bears were hoodwinked hiring him. Where were these people 3 years ago? The fact is, Bellicheck could coach this current roster and they aren't winning more than they are losing. I think either Pace needs to go, or needs some help. I agree with your assessment entirely and I think it is hillarious how everyone blames Fox for everything. Trubisky needs to be unleashed...we unleash him and he shows that he is really raw...etc. Making superbowls with 2 different teams isn't easy. Fox may not be the best coach of all time, but he has absolutely proven to be a good head coach. So for people to just assume removing Fox fixes some massive problem is just crazy talk. There was so much rot in this organization from the Trestman / Emery era (magnified by the fact that we really didn't get much talent late in the Lovie / Angelo era) that it just took a long time to truly clense. Pace has done nothing to put Fox in a position to win early, whether it was waiting on the QB or not being willing to overspend in FA. No one could do much with this roster...no one and it is unfortunate everyone just uses Fox as the scapegoat. Fox has actually done a lot of good things; he brought in some excellent coaches (Fangio / Gase) and really turned / enhanced the culture. Sure we've had mistakes and yes we got smoked by the Eagles, but I look at this much less then the Trestman era, where it was driven by guys quitting, etc., and more the fact that with the lack of talent we have, we have very little margin for error (especially offensively where we do not have the personell to even attempt a shootout). Basically Fox has been right on a lot of things this off-season. He stuck with Glennon for a while and kept saying Trubisky wasn't ready. When he turned the corner to Trubisky, he tried to protect him and it was apparent that Mitch needed that protecting (and it is even still apperent as he hasn't lit the world on fire as we have slowly opened things up). We have seen steady development and I think that is a testament to the coaching staff. Guys have gotten better under Fox and he built that defense in Denver. Denver has went straight to hell with Elway and more and more is coming out in Denver that make it sound like Fox was right all along in what he wanted to do (vs. Elway).
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Da_Goob @ Nov 30, 2017 -> 11:31 AM) This would be the most devastating pick of my life. I would be so upset. I'll go with Jim Bob. Why? Shaw is a very charismatic, high character, proven head football coach (at college) but he also has extensive experience at the pro level (as an assistant). His overall style fits the Bears legacy well and likely resonates with the McCaskeys (to go along with his character). Hard nosed football, runs a pro offense at stanford, strong defense...overall an offensive mind whose overall style should resonate with the general Bears fan base. Not only does it resonate, I think it fits with the weather we play in and the direction of the type of team we've built. Pound and ground football leveraging a lot of playaction, roll-outs, etc, so not totally boring. Leveraged McCaffrey as a RB who could do a ton in the screen game (so some dynamics to the offense) but someone who is going to flat out lead and drive a physical football team (which plays with discipline). I also think his level-headedness fits in well as the head coach.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
Kevin White officially out for the season as Bears designate Demps to be the other player eligible to return from IR.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
Saw this quote in an article from Loggains. Makes you wonder how inaccurate Trubisky was (vs. just how bad / sloppy the wideouts were). Should be no shock that McBride is gone. I still think Mitch was inaccurate, but those are the things that are always hard to tell as a fan.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
So let's play a game. The Bears next head coach will be: David Shaw (is my pick).
-
Abreu trade "unlikely"
QUOTE (Jose Abreu @ Nov 30, 2017 -> 10:16 AM) So it sounds like we asked for Devers or Benintendi and the talks are off for the time being. Heyman Would JBJ qualify as a young player on their major league roster?
-
Abreu trade "unlikely"
QUOTE (OmarComing25 @ Nov 29, 2017 -> 11:45 AM) JBJ has more trade value than Abreu so we're not getting him plus another guy. There are a lot of first basemen on the market too and Abreu isn't going to be super cheap the next two years either. I think the best we could hope for is Groome/Chavis and given that I'd rather just keep him. I agree with you. I don't think we are going to get an offer that makes sense for the White Sox.
-
Abreu trade "unlikely"
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Nov 29, 2017 -> 09:13 AM) JBJ is a guy controlled for an extra season who also could be extended, and since he is younger, maybe a better candidate for that. Premium GG quality defender up the middle. If you could get a good prospect or 2 with him, I have liked Abreu as much as anyone, but I'd make that deal in a heartbeat. Jose could come back in 2 years and DH. I agree with you. Premium position, spot where we don't necessarily have a top prospect who can slide in, and a guy you are more okay extending a couple years down the road given his age. We don't know exactly what type of player he can be...he could be as valuable (from a WAR perspective) as Abreu and it is easier to find a 1B then it is a CF.
-
Abreu trade "unlikely"
QUOTE (RockRaines @ Nov 29, 2017 -> 08:42 AM) They dont have the chips. Bradley Jr + is not a bad place to start.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Nov 28, 2017 -> 04:22 PM) I heard there is no way Fangio will be the Bears interim HC. Supposedly there are some higher ups, and I don't know who, who feel like Fangio doesn't like them. They are counting the days until he is gone. Yeah, Gabriel and Lemming have both indicated Fangio is not on Pace's list of potential head coaching candidates. Gabriel went on to say that Pace wouldn't want to ax Fox and give it to Fangio because if he does well, there would be more pressure to hire a guy he doesn't want.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Nov 28, 2017 -> 02:30 PM) Eh. Belicheck was a DC and his team has been one of the best offensively for years. Mora (DC) was the HC when Manning came into the league. Kevin Gillbride (OC) was Leaf's HC. Its more important to find the best HC, irrespective of whether they are offensive or defensive. Probably some truth in that, but If all things are equal, with the young QB, I'm going with an offensive guy. If we hired Toub though or someone who we thought was just a fantastic guy, then so be it.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Nov 28, 2017 -> 02:30 PM) Eh. Belicheck was a DC and his team has been one of the best offensively for years. Mora (DC) was the HC when Manning came into the league. Kevin Gillbride (OC) was Leaf's HC. Its more important to find the best HC, irrespective of whether they are offensive or defensive. At the time Belicheck was hired they had an outstanding defense and a veteran QB. He happened to get lucky and get Tom Brady and the rest is history, but it wasn't like he was hired to take over a team with a young QB who you had invested a ton in. I'm not opposed to hiring defensive coaches. I think for teams who are investing in a young QB, hiring a bright offensive mind to ensure you have a consistent offensive strategy is critical. If you go defensive, you are essentially dependent on your OC sticking around (since you yourself don't have your own "scheme").
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Nov 28, 2017 -> 01:59 PM) I dont think the HC matters that much. If anything it may be better to have a HC that isnt as involved in the offense and have an OC who is very established. Too many times HC's who are also OC's can lose focus. I think it is more that the OC can always be hired away, so you want someone with a philosphy and approach that is your head coach and has that building block / program for the QB. He doesn't need to be the OC, etc, but with a young QB, you need stability and if you hire a defensive guy as your HC and hire a top assistant at OC and in one year Trubisky makes progress, that guy might be a HC somewhere else and now Trubisky is onto his 3rd system. That is just not a risk I'm willing to take.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Nov 28, 2017 -> 12:27 PM) Bears Insider @bears_insider 14m14 minutes ago Sources: #Bears already have list of names to replace John Fox potential head-coaching candidates and Vic Fangio isn’t one of them To be honest, this shouldn't surprise us. If we are hiring someone, given we invested in a QB, we should be hiring the person we think is going to maximize Trubisky and that inevitably will be an offensive mind.
-
Giancarlo Stanton traded to Yankees
QUOTE (Jose Abreu @ Nov 20, 2017 -> 10:06 AM) There's an interesting team at #1 here... ESPN: Finding the best spot for Giancarlo Stanton I've long agreed with this logic (as long as the price was in terms of $'s and not high-end prospects).
-
2017-18 official NBA discussion thread
QUOTE (raBBit @ Nov 27, 2017 -> 12:44 PM) $8M a year for that. I know the money is changing in the NBA but it's unbelievable. They guy was a nobody prospect who was decent in a small role in an injury riddled team. I just couldn't see him getting $20 million on the free market. Unbelievable. I wouldn't be so quick to trop Porter out of 1-2 with his health in mind. I actually think on the open market he probably gets something close to what the Bulls offered (if not better). He wasn't that bad in past years. It looks to me that he just isn't comfortable with the new system / players or he didn't put in the work after getting the contract. He's worse at all levels and much less active too. Not that he was ever uber talented. Contracts now a days are just brutal.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (ptatc @ Nov 27, 2017 -> 09:55 AM) This is the real issue. Even with the poor talent at WR, he wasn't accurate enough to give them the chance to drop the ball. His accuracy was supposed to be the thing that separated him from the others. He hasn't shown it so far. Maybe he can't read it soon enough or is pressured too much. There are a variety of reasons but he hasn't shown much yet. I agree with you completely. His footwork has been awful as he just hasn't been comfortable. If you aren't ready to read defenses, you aren't really going to be natural in your throwing motions, etc. Eyes are head of the feet / rest of the body and he's really learning (and in an uphill battle). It goes back to what Fox and company were saying originally...he wasn't ready to play. But at some point, glennon was so bad that they decided they'd push it and give Trubisky reps sooner.
-
2017-2018 NFL Thread
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Nov 27, 2017 -> 10:01 AM) It is tough to blame this all or even mostly on coaching. This roster lacks premium talent, and they completely lack depth. If everything went right and no one at the top of the roster got hurt, it was a borderline playoff team. But with any injuries to key guys, this roster was f***ed. They need players and they need stars badly. The things I blame on coaching (or put more on coaching) go back to the fact that we make a lot of unforced errors / mistakes. Too many penalties, etc. That said, I don't think we are a playoff team with Belicheck either. The roster just has too many issues, especially after the injuries. The rot ran deep on the roster and throughout the organization and there has been a cultural shift / improvement under Fox...but the reality is, he has his issues, but you really can't pin it all on him and we very well could take steps backwards if we go to someone else (as Fox has proven he can win with good talent...that isn't / shouldn't be a question). He's a better coach then most coaches the Bears have had over the last 30 years. Is he an elite coach, probably not, but he's a good to very good coach. That said, he might not be the right coach to bring the Bears on the next step of the journey. What he isn't awesome at is game planning though. The lack of penalties is another bad thing that ultimately falls on him, but certainly doesn't give me the warm and fuzzies (in regards to Loggains). That said, lots of injuries / personnel issue impact things too (and players are also responsible).
-
2017-18 official NBA discussion thread
Felicio has been flat out awful this year.