Chisoxfn

QUOTE (DirtySox @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 06:49 PM) Safe bet is college pitcher at 48. Pierce Johnson, Alex Wood, Brian Johnson Jake Barrett, Chris Beck, Brandon Kline, and Pat Light are some names to consider. Fully expect them to go with a pitcher, probably a guy that profiles to pitch out of the pen (seems to be the Sox MO as they figure they can get a power arm that doesn't project to the rotation but can be a plus reliever). Its a unique MO too. But in theory, they've done a good job identifying pitching (whether its via trade, the draft, or even free agency).

There goes Stroman. Some comps to K-rod and Flash. I still think he can start though. Nice pick by the Jays.

QUOTE (Marty34 @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 06:19 PM) I prefer the pre-TV days of the draft. It takes too long and Mayo, the guy who knows the most about these prospects, can't get a word in edgewise from Reynolds and Hart. Hart may not be as on top of things as he was when he was GM, but he knows a lot more then any of the other guys about talent evaluation. Additionally, Callis is the guy that knows the most on the tv set. Mayo would be next. However, that puts him 3rd as far as I'm concerned.

Love what the Nationals have been doing.

QUOTE (SoxAce @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 05:45 PM) Yikes.. He was the one who advocated KW of trading for Danks (like) but also recommended Broadway, McCulloch and Bopone Logan. (dislike) He is our Texas amateur scout FYI. Logan wasn't a high pick was he? So the fact that he made it was really good. Not so good on Lance/McCulloch.

I was cringing as he did that back flip. Like the fact that he'll have a plus outfield arm. Not sure if he can stay in CF, but I think Mitchell will be there, so hopefully that power continues to develop (obviously he's got good power now and it should only get better) and we see him in RF for a long time. The dude is strong.

I love the comp (Matt Kemp).

I really liked Stroman but I like the Hawkins pick as well. No complaints out of me and look forward to seeing what he can do over the next few years. Hopefully he can continue to develop and we'll have another upside guy to go with Mitchell (who I still think will be a very good player). Not sure what happens with Thompson/Walker but we will see. Either way, those are the only major developmental offensive players we've taken early that I can remember over the past few years and I find it ignorant to write the Sox off based upon there progresses (or lack of progress), especially given how one is in his 1st full minor league season (Walker), the other was a raw highschooler (Thompson) whom you never are going to hit at 100% on, and the 3rd was a guy who did great in the minors, looked great in minor league camp, and then had an awful injury (who is finally, this year, recovered from it).

Only thing I don't like is the Sox historical inability to get these guys to develop. Maybe that is changing though with Mitchell starting to come around and I guess we still have more to see in what happens with Walker and Thompson. Would be unfair to write them off (or the organization) at this point based upon this and really these are the 3 guys most of us think about when it comes to raw upside guys the Sox picked (albeit only one was a high schooler).

QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 05:22 PM) No s***? Seriously...I can live with that.

Sox will have there pick of some guys most of Soxtalk likes.

QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 05:12 PM) What the hell good does he do us in a vacuum? I don't know. I just know if the Sox draft Wacha, we have to hope our organization can help him with his breaking stuff. He has the fastball and change-up to succeed, but needs to really improve his breaking stuff and overall command if he's going to be worth a top 15 pick.

QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 04:42 PM) I don't know that I agree, but if that is true, than I would certainly prefer he stick with it as opposed to whatever he did last year! I believe he mentioned that last year he had changed his approach a bit and tried to do put things in play and that ultimately he ended up over thinking and being caught in between a whole lot.

Heaney off the board. I don't really like Wacha, other then I can make comments like Wacha Wacha. Only bright side is his changeup is nasty and his fastball is solid with a good build. If he can develop the other pitches, I guess I can see why scouts like him, but for a college guy he's not very developed.

Some teams are going to regret passing on this guy. His ceiling is that of a middle rotation starter and the upside is solid. Very strong mechanics, improving secondary stuff, strong velocity on his fastball. Great pick by the Pirates.

Great for the Pirates. Sox might have one of the high school prep players available. I'm back to 100% on Stroman though. Love the stuff and I'll take my chances that his body can take the abuse.

I still love Stroman. Appel would be beautiful. Would be a very tough sign though.

QUOTE (DirtySox @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 04:46 PM) Jim Callis ‏@jimcallisBA Confirmed: #Cubs will take Almora at 6, #Padres take Fried at 7. Think #Pirates & Dahl at 8 are set. Appel to #Athletics at 11? #mlbdraft Expand Reply Retweet Favorite A's were locked in on the OSU lefty so if Appel gets to there we'll see who they go with. I think that is who would prevent him from being there when the Sox pick.

QUOTE (fathom @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 04:42 PM) Let Appel keep dropping to the Sox Cubs probably going after Almora here More likely means that Heaney could slide to the Sox.

Twins went for the more talented guy. Great move for them. I thought they'd take the guy with a high ceiling (not as high) but the lower floor.

Seattle has to be happy. They probably weren't taking him and now they most likely get the guy a lot of people pegged as the top prep player in Bixson. This is assuming the Twins take the Stanford righty (Twins need pitching).

I keep getting a feeling that Florida's catcher will slide.

QUOTE (DirtySox @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 04:17 PM) Wow! Love it. This was my top guy in the draft. When I've seen his video, the dude just screams upside.

Correa is a stud. Didn't expect him to go #1.

QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:19 PM) I like it, as a Sox fan, because Reinsdorf wasn't going to spend either way. But before this deal, there existed a real opportunity for smaller market teams to spend big on the draft where their dollars would go much further than on the free agent market -- and in fact, teams like the Pirates, Blue Jays, and Rays did just that. In a lot of ways, I actually think that this situation favors the big markets by eliminating and opportunity for the others to gain a competitive advantage. It very well could, however, it also ensures that these teams can sign the top players with their picks, vs. letting them drop in the draft due to signability concerns. For example, and I know the decision worked out okay, the Twins could have taken Prior over Mauer. Clearly the Twins lucked out but that isn't always the case.