QUOTE(CWSGuy406 @ Jul 29, 2005 -> 08:47 PM)
For a guy who's going to pitch, at most, 40 innings down the stretch?
Again... I'm not so sure. BTW, though Marte is still struggling, he's still striking out over ten per nine IP. He's been wild, but for the most part, has been able to overcome his wildness by his stuff.
It's a tough call. I'm glad I'm not the GM. Personally, I'd rather overpay for a bat -- someone who's going to effect this team every day, rather than once every three nights...
Marte has been able to overcome his wildness because another reliever cleans his mess up for him.
Trading McCarthy doesn't mean we can't get another trade for a bat. If the Phillies are willing to do this deal, I'd run with it in a heartbeat.