Harold Baines never had the peak that Dawson had. For my sake, if I were a HOF voter, I would look for two things.
#1 A huge peak where they would be one of the top players at their position (if not THE best) putting up league leading numbers over a period of at least 3 to 5 seasons.
#2 Longevity that puts them into the historic rankings.
Harold never had #1. He never hit 30 homers in a season. He drove in 100 in exactly one season.
I LOVED Harold Baines, but I can't look at him as a HOF with guys like the guys who made it (and didn't) from that era.
I look at Mark Buehrle the same way. Really good peak, not superstar peak. He never led the league in wins, never had a sub 3 era, was a top 10 Cy Young once (5th), and didn't have an especially long career where he racked up a lot of wins or other counting stats.