Everything posted by southsider2k5
-
The Democrat Thread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 7, 2013 -> 09:46 AM) Ok. So where is the argument against allowing them to be paid or from signing outside endorsement deals? Some will sign lucrative deals, some won't. This is no different than the NFL, NBA, MLB, etc. I'm impressed you are so worried about rewarding the elite athletes of America.
-
The Democrat Thread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 7, 2013 -> 09:41 AM) Please note what I said: Athletes are often 'encouraged' to take easy majors and easy classes in order to keep eligibility, as playing their sport is a full-time job. Graduation rates at many programs are abysmal. If they get injured, they can lose their scholarship. I've still yet to hear a reason why colleges shouldn't be able to pay athletes if they want to or why athletes shouldn't be allowed to profit off of their own name and likeness and why they should be frozen out of the multi-billion dollar revenue stream they generate. What is it about the multi-billion dollar college sports industry that makes it necessary that the bulk of their labor force go unpaid? Why should thousands of NCAA athletes be completely barred from negotiating for pay or from signing endorsement deals? The schools, media companies, apparel companies, etc. certainly aren't barred from profiting off of them. Even if we accepted a parity argument as a legitimate reason, it doesn't seem like the current model serves that end goal very well. I've been told in this thread that, really, it's the coaches and AD's and trainers and facilities and media deals that are the most important parts of the program and, really, the athletes are just incidental, easily replaceable. The NCAA doesn't limit schools from spending huge sums of money on any of those things. The same schools typically dominate year after year after year. The professional sports, with free agency and, in the case of baseball, no salary caps seem to do a much better job at producing parity than the NCAA. Many cases? No. Not even close. A few anecdotal cases, yes. The vast majority of these people would never see a dime from their likeness, nor do they generate money for their schools. We are talking about an elite group, within an elite group.
-
The Democrat Thread
QUOTE (Tex @ Oct 7, 2013 -> 09:29 AM) On the other side of the coin are the rstrictions that are placed on scholarship athletes which are different than on other scholarship students. For example, a music major who is attending a university on a music scholarship may also earn money playing music. The restrictions on athletes earning money makes them getting part time jobs almost impossible. These restrictions came about because boosters would offer star recruits $$$$ for doing basically nothing, or to make appearances. We didn't like that so various measures were imposed. I agree with everything SS is saying here, there is great value, but there needs to be a way for a kid to have enough pocket money to go out on a date or fly back home in case of a family emergency. Plus there is also the fact that they don't have to go to the NCAA if they want to get paid. They can strike out on their own, or they can go places that will pay them, like Europe or a semi-pro league.
-
NBA Thread 2013-2014
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Oct 6, 2013 -> 03:54 PM) "Yawn". After last year, this is so anti-climatic.
-
College Team Fandom
Having gone to a small college I follow teams more for the players on the teams that I saw play in HS and liked, versus any other reason. There are a few teams I root against because of fan bases, but that is about it.
-
The Democrat Thread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 6, 2013 -> 08:49 PM) I did not make as broad a statement as "college degrees have minimal worth." lol, ok. Go ahead and backtrack now that you got called on how absurd your statement was. At the surface, it is a $25,000, or more, per year payment. That is the equivalent of a $12.50/hr job, given to you. That price goes up depending on if you got to a good school. That isn't counting interest not paid on student loans either. Then add to that the million dollar of extra lifetime earnings that are out there for the 99.9% of players who never do go pro. Handwaving away the value of the education here is silly.
-
Miley Cyrus on SNL
I'm more impressed that someone watched SNL, than that the thread police showed up.
-
White Sox outright 3
QUOTE (Soxfest @ Oct 6, 2013 -> 05:04 PM) Brian Omogrosso has elected free agency. The 29-year-old right-hander appeared in just 12 games for the White Sox in 2013, turning in a disappointing 9.37 ERA, 2.27 WHIP and 16/9 K/BB ratio before succumbing to an elbow injury. He'll look to latch on elsewhere and compete for a bullpen spot in 2014. Per Rotoworld As a righty at his age, with his level of "success" he'll be lucky to get a minor league deal that includes a spring training invite.
-
Sox to Make Hard Push for Granderson
QUOTE (Dunt @ Oct 7, 2013 -> 08:08 AM) If Hahn thinks Granderson is a step towards "long term, sustainable success" this franchise is more screwed than I thought. It is the step that tells everyone you are looking at being respectable ASAP. It is the type of step took when the Tigers were offering insane amounts of money to guys like Magglio and Gonzalez to try to make the statement that Detroit was a place worth going to after years of horrible teams.
-
Sox to Make Hard Push for Granderson
QUOTE (flavum @ Oct 7, 2013 -> 08:10 AM) Nobody would miss De Aza. Nobody. He may be an idiot, but he wouldn't be easy to replace. I have we forgotten the Mark Kotsay and Rob Mackowiaks of the world?
-
College Team Fandom
QUOTE (Rowand44 @ Oct 6, 2013 -> 09:51 AM) I always found it hilarious how Lebron was a Bulls, Cowboys and Yankees fan growing up, front runner much? Somethings never change apparently.
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 6, 2013 -> 10:42 AM) And guess which one has demonstrated he has a clue at the plate. And can make contact regularly. Oh, wait, that's definitely NOT Viciedo. MLB Averages: O-Swing = 31.0%, Z-Swing = 65.5%, Z-Contact = 87.0% Anthony Rizzo: O-Swing = 30.0%, Z-Swing = 66.5%, Z-Contact = 89.1% (102 wRC+) Dayan Viciedo: O-Swing = 42.5%, Z-Swing = 73.5%, Z-Contact = 82.9% (96 wRC+) One of those lines looks like a Major League hitter, the other looks like a minor leaguer being challenged by stuff way above his skill level. Yet Viciedo is still out producing the golden boy.
-
Make your arguments why Ventura isn't like Baker?
QUOTE (caulfield12 @ Oct 6, 2013 -> 09:00 AM) "The talent in this organization will do all the convincing that we need," Epstein contends. Until his firing, Sveum was under the impression he would get to manage that talent and planned to attend a few Arizona Fall League games to take more than a peek at the Cubs' top prospects. But that illustrates the commitment that will be needed to teach players as much, if not more, than manage a game. Despite the scouting reports, spray charts, videotape and the early work of Sveum and his staff, the Cubs still lost 96 games in 2013. More preparation is essential to help the development of Starlin Castro, Anthony Rizzo, Jeff Samardzija and Travis Wood. "There has to be a systematic approach," a veteran advance scout said. "You have to get across to the manager to buy into that 'Cubs Way' they preached. "The game has changed, but you don't stop teaching at the major league level. You can make players better defensively and make them better baserunners. Those are ways you teach players to win." But what about working deeper counts in hopes of getting a better pitch to hit, even if it means taking borderline pitches? "The difference between a borderline pitch and a good pitch to hit is two inches," the scout added. "It's easy to say that if you're not in the batter's box." And therein lies the juggling act of the next Cubs' manager — striking a balance in which young players improve, demonstrating strong teaching habits and leadership traits and executing the message of the front office. mgonzales@tribune.com Looks like they have been buying into the Cub Way just fine. 105 years and counting, plus a general manager who is intentionally throwing entire seasons.
-
Your Realistic 2014 Lineup
QUOTE (caulfield12 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 08:59 PM) Except we're not talking a Top 3 draft pick with millions invested in him. Don Cooper's not going to be fired because of him. Cooper couldn't work any magic with Francisco Liriano and nobody blinked an eye...the "legend" continued. I've been a huge Santiago fan from the very beginning, and, if anything, I'm sure he will likely be much more successful with another organization and make us look stupid when we undersell on him. lol.
-
2013-2014 NHL thread
SOG Chicago 11 TB 0
-
Make your arguments why Ventura isn't like Baker?
QUOTE (scs787 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 10:57 AM) I like what I heard from Joe Maddon, "I just pick the matchups and let the athletes do the work". I think that's really the only mentality the manager needs to have, and it's really just as simple as that. I really do believe the whole thing Hawk said about managers not really mattering....I could have "managed" a team like the Tigers to the playoffs. Just gotta have the right athletes and the Sox simply didn't have that. IF anyone on the Sox ever said that, there would be meltdowns galore.
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
QUOTE (caulfield12 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 09:48 AM) Everyone knows Ramirez and Viciedo are 2-3 years older than their "official" ages... It all goes to the same perception gap. Because it is a Cubs prospect, everyone is all googly eyed, despite reality.
-
Shooting at the Capitol
QUOTE (Tex @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 09:44 AM) +2 Tie goes to the cops. We've had some instances here that clearly law enforcement / military went too far and tried to cover it up. This seems to me, from the early reports, more a failure of our mental health systems than our law enforcement system. And this isn't the regular cops, and a regular person type of situation. This is someone attacking the White House, and then attacking the capital building. At that point you don't know if they have a bomb, a biological agent, a mental illness, or what. But at that point your priority is different. You are protect Presidents, Senators, etc.
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
QUOTE (Chicago White Sox @ Oct 4, 2013 -> 10:37 PM) And guess who has the higher career OPS yet is considered a bust. And is five months younger.
-
Official 2013-2014 NCAA Football Thread
QUOTE (gatnom @ Oct 4, 2013 -> 08:02 PM) Did you just call Illinois insignificant while defending NU haha? I mean it's great that they've gotten better and all, but that just doesn't make any sense... I can't believe people would care enough about NW to root against them.
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
QUOTE (Chicago White Sox @ Oct 4, 2013 -> 06:19 PM) Lol...of course they will as prospects never flop! For perspective sake, Rizzo has 24 less MLB PAs than Dayan Viciedo. (1235 vs 1211)
-
Sox Sign Jose Abreu - 6/$68 million
QUOTE (Quinarvy @ Oct 4, 2013 -> 04:51 PM) Yup. The Sox had the top ranked farm system in baseball when Kenny ran it. I like having him involved in this. Some people can't get past petty imagined grudges to remember their history.
-
The Democrat Thread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 4, 2013 -> 04:38 PM) In many cases it has minimal worth. In many cases its worth is vastly disproportionate to the value they could otherwise get. Why is it okay to not pay these athletes with the billions of dollars in revenue they generate, but it's okay to make millionaires out of their coaches? A college degree has minimal worth? Now I know you are just trolling. In no way, shape, or form, does a college degree have minimal worth. If that is the case, dismantle all college funding.
-
The Democrat Thread
how come a free college scholarship isn't considered as having any value here?
-
Sox Sign Jose Abreu - 6/$68 million
QUOTE (Soxfest @ Oct 4, 2013 -> 03:51 PM) KW being involved should scare everyone. I wish he would just move on. If you remember back to pre-GM Kenny Williams, this IS what he is really good at. When he was in charge of just the minor league system, it was tops in baseball.