I understand this, but I wasn't making an argument, I was putting out a hypothetical question based on previous history of his here. Hypothetically had he been brought back, he may have very well come into the season fully healthy and posted the same numbers. Or he may not have. It's something we'll never know. And like I said in my original post, I'm glad he's doing well and it sucks he couldn't do it here more often, but it seemed to be time to move on for both parties. You don't need to agree with that view, it's just how I see the situation. Everything on a message board isn't about winning arguments per se, it can be about posing questions for discussion purposes.