15 hours ago15 hr Am I the only one that thinks Getz saying “other teams in the division wanted him” could easily be him falling for May’s agent’s negotiating tactics?
15 hours ago15 hr 2 hours ago, Baron said:Or you know...he liked the team? Not posssible thoughThat is possible and the Sox are more of a destination now than they used to be as a result of the 2026 season. But May must have felt like he won the lottery when his agent told him what the White Sox offered because I highly doubt any other team would have given him that much.
14 hours ago14 hr 35 minutes ago, fathom said:Am I the only one that thinks Getz saying “other teams in the division wanted him” could easily be him falling for May’s agent’s negotiating tactics?I am more inclined to believe Getz jumped to sign May because they liked him while also knowing that other free agent starters would ultimately be outside of their price range comfort, not that the Sox couldn’t afford those other better options if they truly wanted to.
14 hours ago14 hr 37 minutes ago, ChiSoxFanMike said:That is possible and the Sox are more of a destination now than they used to be as a result of the 2026 season. But May must have felt like he won the lottery when his agent told him what the White Sox offered because I highly doubt any other team would have given him that much.Well yeah. That’s how free agency basically works.
14 hours ago14 hr 1 hour ago, fathom said:Am I the only one that thinks Getz saying “other teams in the division wanted him” could easily be him falling for May’s agent’s negotiating tactics?Definitely not CLE.Minnesota or Detroit could have been sending out feelers and pulled back after Gray.DET could go anywhere from the Big 3 FA pitchers to value guys like Mize/Mahle/Holmes/Gausman.
14 hours ago14 hr 40 minutes ago, Lukakke Appling said:Well yeah. That’s how free agency basically works.The history of the White Sox never giving the most money to free agents who are actually good and desirable kind of proves my whole point here.
14 hours ago14 hr Just now, ChiSoxFanMike said:The history of the White Sox never giving the most money to free agents who are actually good and desirable kind of proves my whole point here.Bingo. As long as Jerry is in charge, which is still the case. We’ve seen this dog and pony show offseason after offseason, and yet people still think this is the year that the Sox will spend on top tier free agents, yet it never happens. Low payroll does not mean top free agents, it means a bunch of money spread out amongst middle and lower tier players. That’s how the Sox operate.The hope is that Ishbia will be more willing to play with the big boys. Edited 14 hours ago14 hr by WhiteSox2023
14 hours ago14 hr https://chicago.suntimes.com/white-sox/2026/11/19/white-sox-banking-on-dustin-mays-untapped-upside-and-still-hunting-for-more-additions
13 hours ago13 hr 3 minutes ago, Lip Man 1 said:https://chicago.suntimes.com/white-sox/2026/11/19/white-sox-banking-on-dustin-mays-untapped-upside-and-still-hunting-for-more-additionsThe title of Fegan’s article tells the entire story — “White Sox banking on Dustin May's untapped upside, and still hunting for more additions”Just like with the Castillo acquisition, rather than just acquiring a guy that is currently a TOR starter, the Sox will always choose to spend less money and simply hope they can manufacture or luck into a TOR starter. Edited 13 hours ago13 hr by WhiteSox2023
13 hours ago13 hr 46 minutes ago, caulfield12 said:Definitely not CLE.Minnesota or Detroit could have been sending out feelers and pulled back after Gray.DET could go anywhere from the Big 3 FA pitchers to value guys like Mize/Mahle/Holmes/Gausman.Detroit could easily bounce back and take the division by storm next season...or whenever the next season is played. They fix their pitching, they should be right up there with us and Cleveland, if not better.
13 hours ago13 hr 39 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Bingo. As long as Jerry is in charge, which is still the case. We’ve seen this dog and pony show offseason after offseason, and yet people still think this is the year that the Sox will spend on top tier free agents, yet it never happens. Low payroll does not mean top free agents, it means a bunch of money spread out amongst middle and lower tier players. That’s how the Sox operate.The hope is that Ishbia will be more willing to play with the big boys.Problem is Ishbia isn't taking over still for a long time....
13 hours ago13 hr 4 hours ago, Baron said:Or you know...he liked the team? Not posssible thoughI was told that only applies to those who don't want to ne here.
12 hours ago12 hr 1 hour ago, AntMan26 said:Problem is Ishbia isn't taking over still for a long time....2029 at the earliest I believe.
12 hours ago12 hr 1 hour ago, southsider2k5 said:I was told that only applies to those who don't want to ne here.There are insiders on this board. I read here that Gray wouldn’t have signed with the Sox over the Twins unless they overpaid him. Who needs Ken Rosenthal?
9 hours ago9 hr On 11/18/2026 at 10:41 AM, caulfield12 said:4. The Sox pitching Lab will have a lot more time to work with May and tweak some things. Getting a player in season and trying to get more on the fly is a difficult proposition even if you are the Brewers.See Peralta, Fastball FreddieOr Mahle with the Braves?The best teams can make in season changes.Didn't work out for MIL, although he did provide them valuable double digit post season innings at least.Remember Matt Thornton getting pretty much immediate fixes from Cooper?No the best teams do their best to make in season changes . That's why you have analytics and consult those guys before pulling the trigger. It's still not an easy process, while you're still pitching, to just up and say oh sure I can switch my arm angle . Some things take time and a player can reject it all, or only accept minor tweaks. Kopech didn't want to listen. And a lot of pitching acquired at the TDL didn't do so well. Crochet added the cutter only after he started getting hit hard even though they had him working on it in ST.
9 hours ago9 hr 4 hours ago, WhiteSox2023 said:The title of Fegan’s article tells the entire story — “White Sox banking on Dustin May's untapped upside, and still hunting for more additions”Just like with the Castillo acquisition, rather than just acquiring a guy that is currently a TOR starter, the Sox will always choose to spend less money and simply hope they can manufacture or luck into a TOR starter.Neither of those constitute a successful philosophy in my opinion.
8 hours ago8 hr 8 hours ago, southsider2k5 said:Who is going to pay full price for Colson Montgomery when they just watched what we watched last year?What if today’s price is as good as it gets?
7 hours ago7 hr 10 hours ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:The primary difference between fWAR and bWAR is that fWAR uses FIP and bWAR uses ERA.FIP is more predictive of ERA, but that doesn't mean it is a better reflection of what has happened. Also, Mays FIP was an outlier among the predictive stats so that WAR value is pretty misleading. Saying he had similar seasons to others because of the fWAR is a reach.The issue with May too is that innings and health have almost always been an issue in his career.Calling May a #3 doesn't align with his profile and health history.How was it an outlier? 3.63 FIP, 3.96 xFIP, 3.99 SIERA, 4.43 xERA. Three of those four metrics are below 4.00. Ultimately, there is nothing more predictive than Ray Ray saying a guy “stinks”. We got into the same exact debate about Sean Burke last offseason and we all saw how that one turned out.
7 hours ago7 hr 7 hours ago, ChiSoxFanMike said:That is possible and the Sox are more of a destination now than they used to be as a result of the 2026 season. But May must have felt like he won the lottery when his agent told him what the White Sox offered because I highly doubt any other team would have given him that much.Fangraphs literally predicted a 3/$48M contract for him.
7 hours ago7 hr 6 hours ago, WhiteSox2023 said:The title of Fegan’s article tells the entire story — “White Sox banking on Dustin May's untapped upside, and still hunting for more additions”Just like with the Castillo acquisition, rather than just acquiring a guy that is currently a TOR starter, the Sox will always choose to spend less money and simply hope they can manufacture or luck into a TOR starter.Every single organization looks for guys with untapped potential. It’s fine to rip the Sox for being cheap, but seeking undervalued players is what smart clubs do.
7 hours ago7 hr 2 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:Every single organization looks for guys with untapped potential. It’s fine to rip the Sox for being cheap, but seeking undervalued players is what smart clubs do.Meet Peters, Tristan or Meidroth, Chaseor even Murakami... Edited 7 hours ago7 hr by caulfield12
6 hours ago6 hr 49 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:Every single organization looks for guys with untapped potential. It’s fine to rip the Sox for being cheap, but seeking undervalued players is what smart clubs do.I’m fine with the signing if they sign a true #1/#2 FA starter next. But the fact that they had to dump additionally salary to seemingly do so is pathetic as f***. Edited 6 hours ago6 hr by WhiteSox2023
6 hours ago6 hr https://www.fangraphs.com/roster-resource/breakdowns/payrollWhite Sox current projected payroll at $96 million, 25thGuardians at $103 million, 23rd
28 minutes ago28 min 7 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said:How was it an outlier? 3.63 FIP, 3.96 xFIP, 3.99 SIERA, 4.43 xERA. Three of those four metrics are below 4.00. Ultimately, there is nothing more predictive than Ray Ray saying a guy “stinks”. We got into the same exact debate about Sean Burke last offseason and we all saw how that one turned out.Yes, I'm only ever wrong about pitching calls. You're right.Also, how is it an outlier? Well, it's 10% better than every other predictive analytic. Maybe that's how?I was also one of the first guys on Sean Burke, for the record. Been SAD watching you become a schill for every move. Edited 27 minutes ago27 min by Look at Ray Ray Run
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.