13 hours ago13 hr 31 minutes ago, chitownsportsfan said:8/10 they don't combine for 5 WAR over the next 4 years. Boston Smith isn't a catcher and at best turns into a platoon OF. Martin, eh, we've been over him.Not really much more to say on this one I guess now that I'm responding. We'll see how the rest of the offseason goes.But can't we say the same exact thing about Prosek that was just drafted this year as Smith?
11 hours ago11 hr 2 hours ago, Chick Mercedes said:Castillo cost him Boston Smith and Martin. FWIWThe sum of it all is it cost you Smith and Martin to dump Dominguez.
11 hours ago11 hr 8 hours ago, southsider2k5 said:WE SHOULDN'T HAVE ONE OF THE LOWEST BUDGETS IN BASEBALL!No matter what our budget is or should be, the fact is, we have a budget. And this trade provides more flexibility against that budget.
11 hours ago11 hr Then came Thursday's deal between the Chicago White Sox and Colorado Rockies. Earlier in the day, general manager Chris Getz sat on the podium in Chicago alongside new free-agent signing Dustin May and fielded questions about whether the White Sox were pursuing more starting pitching. About seven hours later, Getz made a dramatic subtraction from the pitching staff, sending veteran Luis Castillo and recent rotation mainstay Davis Martin to the Rockies, who have probably been having a tough time convincing free-agent pitchers to come to Coors Field. The White Sox landed a pair of prospects in return — left-handed pitcher Sean Sullivan, who debuted in June, and 17-year-old catcher Douglas Veliz — but this deal was money-motivated to offload Castillo's onerous salary (one year left for $22.75 million), perhaps to free up some payroll flexibility to pursue more pitching in free agency. Whatever the intention on either side, it came out of nowhere. For all the time White Sox or Rockies fans may have spent formulating their ideal offseason plans, conjuring up this specific trade would be laughable. Yet there it was, a done deal. yahoo.com/sports
7 hours ago7 hr I hope this doesn't prevent taking risk at the deadline. It also means great things for Castillo. Nothing like rebounding back to former glory to remind is we're Sox fans.
7 hours ago7 hr 20 minutes ago, Texsox said:I hope this doesn't prevent taking risk at the deadline.It also means great things for Castillo. Nothing like rebounding back to former glory to remind is we're Sox fans.In Colorado? Seems the longest of long shots...
7 hours ago7 hr 4 hours ago, Bonemer, I Hardly Know Her said:The sum of it all is it cost you Smith and Martin to dump Dominguez.Of course, but you can't go back a reverse things. But this move is simple. Say you were the Sox GM and JR had no more money to give you and the Rockies offered you $22 million for Martin, would you take it? I think everyone here would, and I'm not a Getz guy.
6 hours ago6 hr 7 hours ago, caulfield12 said:But can't we say the same exact thing about Prosek that was just drafted this year as Smith?Well, they both have two arms and two legs. Prosek is a high profile 19 year old infielder who expressed a willingness to convert to catching. Boston Smith is a 23 year old senior sign who has hit well in a small sample size with the Sox, but who struggled with Seattle and in the AFL. Nothing alike
5 hours ago5 hr Both Boston Smith and Prosek lack one elite defensive future position.Same exact thing that limits Antonacci's ceiling.All three players need to be carried by their offensive profiles. Edited 4 hours ago4 hr by caulfield12
4 hours ago4 hr 11 minutes ago, Whisox05 said:Sullivan has a low ceiling due to his velocity, but there is a path to a solid back of the rotation starter here. We’re talking about a lefty with elite extension and double plus command. Hopefully the Sox have some plan for him to get his velocity back to where it was in college or help improve his secondaries.
4 hours ago4 hr 7 hours ago, Bonemer, I Hardly Know Her said:No matter what our budget is or should be, the fact is, we have a budget. And this trade provides more flexibility against that budget.Correct. We ALL agree that the budget SHOULD be higher than whatever it is, but somehow that remains a focal point of an argument that doesn’t actually exist.
2 hours ago2 hr I think there’s something instructive about the Castillo/Seranthony follies: the Sox don’t eat contracts, so acquiring ANY veteran FAs is essentially risky. They end up paying Boston Smith and Davis Martin just to get rid of Seranthony. That’s why I am lukewarm on getting specifically Peralta. If they are on the hook for $100 mil and his decline in Ks and xFIP is real, they would be stuck with him. At least cheaper guys will be demoted/cut if they suck.
25 minutes ago25 min 1 hour ago, Timmy U said:I think there’s something instructive about the Castillo/Seranthony follies: the Sox don’t eat contracts, so acquiring ANY veteran FAs is essentially risky. They end up paying Boston Smith and Davis Martin just to get rid of Seranthony. That’s why I am lukewarm on getting specifically Peralta. If they are on the hook for $100 mil and his decline in Ks and xFIP is real, they would be stuck with him. At least cheaper guys will be demoted/cut if they suck.Beyond depressing...bring on Ishbia ASAP.Eventually you need to take a risk beyond $75 million.Grandal, Benintendi, Robert, Jr., Dunn Danks, Cabrera, Moncada, Konerko at the end...pretty much every "big" contract they have have ever signed has somehow busted. And Albert Belle they were so incredibly fortunate he opted out. Edited 24 minutes ago24 min by caulfield12
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.