As much as i want Rowand back, we need Bmac more.

 

What are your thoughts???

Make it stop God, make it stop.

Anderson likely will be as good if not better than Rowand and is our future in center.

how exactly did this trade idea even come up?

Pitching is more important than hitting and Anderson is a better defensive player, and possibly offensive one day, than Rowand. Stop this crap.

Dumbest thread ever!

I think we would also have to include an OF prospect like Sweeney...

 

Get it done Kenny!

Rowand? Hell no! The only way I'd trade BMAC is if we got Jon Lieber in return. The ball is in the Phillies' court.

No chance in hell, and I'm a Rowand fan.

I'm glad to see 0 votes in the "yes" column.

there have been more and more pointless and baseless threads lately... its kinda getting a bit out of hand... oh well.

Oh f*** No.

 

Maybe if they tossed in Ryan Howard.

Who voted yes?

Rowand? Hell no! The only way I'd trade BMAC is if we got Jon Lieber in return. The ball is in the Phillies' court.

I seriously hope you are joking, that guy cant keep the ball in the park hes old washed up and is an ex cub, should i keep going.

 

Also if you wouldnt do the trade then dont post it, seriously, as much as all of us love arow we have to cope with anderson and lately i have gotta say that anderson is starting to hit better.

I seriously hope you are joking, that guy cant keep the ball in the park hes old washed up and is an ex cub, should i keep going.

I'm rather certain he was joking. It was laid on pretty heavy there.

I'm rather certain he was joking. It was laid on pretty heavy there.

 

I didn't think I needed the green for that one. lol.

I didn't think I needed the green for that one. lol.

I guess not

I'm sorry, I must have missed the "Are you out of your f@#$ing mind" category...

Guys this trade is not happening. Our main focus should be getting one more arm for that pen.

I love ARow but would rather have Anderson...you can see he is a possible future all-star...he may not become a superstar but he has a much higher ceiling than ARow. So no way I would trade BMac to replace Anderson in center, its counterintuitive.

When I saw this thread, a famous Jack Buck quote came to mind ... "I can't believe what I just saw."

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

OOOOOOOOO

A bigger question...Why?

Rowand? Hell no! The only way I'd trade BMAC is if we got Jon Lieber in return. The ball is in the Phillies' court.

 

 

BMAC's dung >>>>>>>>>> Jon Lieber

Topic title should be changed from Big question to Bad question.