Man...really? This is the stance you are gonna take? Of all the holes in this team, it is the "Gordon Beckham was an awful draft pick" stance?

 

Going into that draft, there is no way, NO WAY you were saying that. Hell, I venture to guess that 80-85% of the pundits thought that was a great pick.

 

 

It is easy to second guess now, when you get to see stats 2 years later, and say "SEE!! I knew we made a mistake!!!11"

 

I didn't say that. I liked the pick at the time. But what I like or don't like doesn't matter. This team can't produce a f***ing thing internally. It's pathetic. I can hindsight all I want. I don't get paid to scout, draft and develop major league talent. This team has no future whatsoever going forward. Save your '05 DVDs. That's all you're going to be able to hold on to until Ozzie, KW and hopefully JR are gone.

Edited June 16, 201114 yr by Jordan4life

Man...really? This is the stance you are gonna take? Of all the holes in this team, it is the "Gordon Beckham was an awful draft pick" stance?

 

Going into that draft, there is no way, NO WAY you were saying that. Hell, I venture to guess that 80-85% of the pundits thought that was a great pick.

 

 

It is easy to second guess now, when you get to see stats 2 years later, and say "SEE!! I knew we made a mistake!!!11"

Yea, I'll agree here. Becks was thought of as a great pick then, we just didn't develop him well (not knowing how to handle a slump is a large part of why young players spend time in the minors).

 

It's the picks after him though (or after the first round) that we have been still pretty bad at.

Sox record will be 0-4 have been outscored 8-2 and have had 15 hits in 35 innings against one of the worst teams in baseball this year.

 

The average length of a game is 2:15 (that part I guessed )

I didn't say that. I liked the pick at the time. But what I like or don't like doesn't matter. This team can't produce a f***ing thing internally. It's pathetic. I can hindsight all I want. I don't get paid to scout, draft and develop major league talent. This team has no future whatsoever going forward. Save your '05 DVDs. That's all you're going to be able to hold on to until Ozzie, KW and hopefully JR are gone.

And this is why everyone thinks you're just emotional and ridiculous.

I didn't say that. I liked the pick at the time. But what I like or don't like doesn't matter. This team can't produce a f***ing thing internally. It's pathetic. I can hindsight all I want. I don't get paid to scout, draft and develop major league talent. This team has no future whatsoever going forward. Save your '05 DVDs. That's all you're going to be able to hold on to until Ozzie, KW and hopefully JR are gone.

 

Greg Walker's biggest weakness as a hitting coach is his inability to help his young players adjust to the league after the league adjusts to them. Happened with Josh Fields, and now it's happening with Beckham. As for the Beckham pick, I'm fine with it. I wanted Smoak first, Beckham second...and not Wallace or Castro.

Haha you're right, I think Stoney or Hawk said "hold em' here" and I went with it. Hold stats are for tie games.

 

Hold stats are when you come into the game in a save situation and leave with the lead in tact and the game not yet over.

That was nearly two years ago. When I see Andrew McCutchen, Mike Stanton, Buster Posey (before he got hurt), Logan Morrison, Gaby Sanchez and Eric Hosmer making their marks on this game, and Gordon Beckham doing his best '92 Steve Sax impersonation for a year and a half, yes, it was a bust of a pick.

 

 

And who do you suggest should be playing 2B for the White Sox instead? And how will they possibly acquire said player?

 

Should they just waive him?

 

I don't think it's fair to compare Eric Hosmer to Gordon Beckham, but go ahead.

 

What about all those teams that didn't give Mark Buerhle a chance? Should their scouting departments be fired, too?

 

The Sox drafts have absolutely sucked, but there are numerous organizations that have had terrible drafts....cherrypicking is too easy to do.

 

 

Sox scouting department sucks completetly in ALL aspects.

the problem is the lack of money spent on the draft

The question that needs to be asked, IMO, is how many managers or coaches in any sport would catch so little heat or even survive being so consistently futile and impotent against a team's primary rival, for so long, as we've been against the Twins, regardless of who they pitch or hit?

 

His attempts to motivate this team have completely backfired.

 

And it's reason #1 he needs to go

I just logged on here and I have to say that Pierre bunt was hilarious. It actually was a decent bunt (not great) and he was thrown out by like 3 steps. LOL. f*** YOU OZZIE!

That is just beyond ridiculous that you are attempting to make this argument right now. Even for you.

It's one thing to be upset about not having the #1 or #2 overall pick that went on to have a great career (would rather not be in that position), but giving excuse after excuse for not drafting and developing talent that wasn't in the first round has been tiresome for the past 5+ years.

How Nishioka did not get into 3B is beyond me.

what is the point of bringing Crain in?

 

does ole oz think he is winning this game, I mean does he think the Sox are actually winning this game currently

a throwing error on pick off with 2 outs is not helpful Mr Crain

I didn't say that. I liked the pick at the time. But what I like or don't like doesn't matter. This team can't produce a f***ing thing internally. It's pathetic. I can hindsight all I want. I don't get paid to scout, draft and develop major league talent. This team has no future whatsoever going forward. Save your '05 DVDs. That's all you're going to be able to hold on to until Ozzie, KW and hopefully JR are gone.

 

That's a different argument altogether and you're absolutely right about it.

 

But when you even say you liked the pick and when almost everyone, if not everyone, liked the pick at the time it is ridiculous to ridicule that pick 3 years later when viewing it in hindsight compared to other players.

the problem is the lack of money spent on the draft

And the fact that for 5 years we were supporting a guy's house-flipping business instead of international signings.

Greg Walker's biggest weakness as a hitting coach is his inability to help his young players adjust to the league after the league adjusts to them. Happened with Josh Fields, and now it's happening with Beckham. As for the Beckham pick, I'm fine with it. I wanted Smoak first, Beckham second...and not Wallace or Castro.

Not one young hitter has progressed under Walker.

And this is why everyone thinks you're just emotional and ridiculous.

 

So when are we allowed to critique our drafting? The standard excuse pre-2007 was that we're competitive all the time and we never have a top 10 pick. I bring up the Rays or another team and you all say it's only because they were bad and had top 5-10 picks. We finally get one in '07 and he's sucked for a year and a half. And there's no reason to believe he's going to snap out of it. His batting mechanics suck. He can't hit a fastball. You can't be good in this league and not hit fastballs.

OK. I have agood feeling now. Comeback time. In games past that 2 out error by Crain would have led to a big inning for the bad guys. Let's RALLY boys!

Lilli better PH here

And the fact that for 5 years we were supporting a guy's house-flipping business instead of international signings.

Sox scouting or lack there of was and is a joke aroung MLB.

I think i've finally jumped on board with firing Ozzie.

If konerko is benched for dunn this weekend i may join you. by the way baked cheetos are terrible

And the fact that for 5 years we were supporting a guy's house-flipping business instead of international signings.

Loyal to a fault. Obviously you need to trust your employees, but for something like that to happen to KW from one of his best friends, it goes to show you how this organization can so easily be blinded by their loyalty and stubborness.

You could make a lot of money betting on the favorite between these two teams, because its such a guarantee the Sox will lose

So when are we allowed to critique our drafting? The standard excuse pre-2007 was that we're competitive all the time and we never have a top 10 pick. I bring up the Rays or another team and you all say it's only because they were bad and had top 5-10 picks. We finally get one in '07 and he's sucked for a year and a half. And there's no reason to believe he's going to snap out of it. His batting mechanics suck. He can't hit a fastball. You can't be good in this league and not hit fastballs.

No one ever argues that our drafting has sucked.

 

It's when you argue that perfectly well-reasoned and intelligently made decisions at the time, that failed to turn out well due to circumstances beyond our control, are signs of incompetence on the part of our front office - that's when people find your stance to be untenable.