This is going to need its own thread. Meatheads enjoyed it for what reason?

It tells you why AJ wasn't back this year

This is going to need its own thread. Meatheads enjoyed it for what reason?

 

Meatheads disliked it for what reason? Did you observe the Reed/AJP relationship in the clubhouse? Maybe there is a legit reason?

Meatheads disliked it for what reason? Did you observe the Reed/AJP relationship in the clubhouse? Maybe there is a legit reason?

 

I don't like the timing of it in that situation, but the legend of AJ grows. It was funny seeing Konerko laughing at 1B.

It tells you why AJ wasn't back this year

 

Well that's sure working out well for us right?....

Merge into one thread, por favor.

Maybe Reed and Pierzysnki didn't get along?

 

 

Is there evidence that any human gets along with AJ?

This is going to need its own thread. Meatheads enjoyed it for what reason?

He's an asshole, hot head and bully?

 

I'd bet good money no more than 5 White Sox actually liked the guy.

Look at all these people, all the sudden hating AJ because he wears a different uniform. Flip the script and a Rangers pitcher hits AJ in his first AB vs. w/ the Sox against the Rangers, and a lot of these Sox fans wouldn't be calling AJ an asshole for chirping.

 

It was a good situation to a hit a guy, and it could make a lot of sense if AJ and Reed didn't get along for whatever reason, I don't blame AJ for chirping, we don't know their history.

I was always open about disliking AJ.

I liked AJ and didn't see this.

 

So all I would say is "interesting."

I was indifferent. I loved AJ, he never wronged me. He brought us a title and a pretty good ballclub in general while he was here.

White Sox are totally classless. There was no legit reason to throw at AJ there. And the meatheads love it because they never appreciated AJ when he was here. No AJ, no White Sox World Series.

 

AJ is better off with a real contender and the Sox are stuck with Flowers who not only can't hit but doesn't handle the pitching staff as well as AJ did and hasn't been any better throwing runners out. I'd say AJ gets the last laugh and the Sox just showed why they are the pathetic losers they have become.

 

 

Haha pretty upset I missed this.

 

 

But for the is AJ a Sox legend or not...

 

 

AJ is a Sox legend in my book......Just a part of way too many GREAT moments.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_BIzRdpsL-4

 

White Sox are totally classless. There was no legit reason to throw at AJ there. And the meatheads love it because they never appreciated AJ when he was here. No AJ, no White Sox World Series.

 

AJ is better off with a real contender and the Sox are stuck with Flowers who not only can't hit but doesn't handle the pitching staff as well as AJ did and hasn't been any better throwing runners out. I'd say AJ gets the last laugh and the Sox just showed why they are the pathetic losers they have become.

 

That's a bit of a stretch. If AJ was still in San Fran or some other team in 2005, I think the Sox still could have won.

If people are going to choose the name over the jersey, can they at least do it for somebody who was really good?

That's a bit of a stretch. If AJ was still in San Fran or some other team in 2005, I think the Sox still could have won.

Sox wouldn't have even made the playoffs with Jamie Burke or Ben Davis along with Widger as their catchers.

Sox wouldn't have even made the playoffs with Jamie Burke or Ben Davis along with Widger as their catchers.

Uribe/Crede>2005 AJ

 

It's a dumb argument anyway. AJ's teammates didn't like him. Retaliation was due from last night. Shut up and take your base, AJ.

White Sox are totally classless. There was no legit reason to throw at AJ there. And the meatheads love it because they never appreciated AJ when he was here. No AJ, no White Sox World Series.

 

AJ is better off with a real contender and the Sox are stuck with Flowers who not only can't hit but doesn't handle the pitching staff as well as AJ did and hasn't been any better throwing runners out. I'd say AJ gets the last laugh and the Sox just showed why they are the pathetic losers they have become.

 

I need my baseball classy.

White Sox are totally classless. There was no legit reason to throw at AJ there. And the meatheads love it because they never appreciated AJ when he was here. No AJ, no White Sox World Series.

 

AJ is better off with a real contender and the Sox are stuck with Flowers who not only can't hit but doesn't handle the pitching staff as well as AJ did and hasn't been any better throwing runners out. I'd say AJ gets the last laugh and the Sox just showed why they are the pathetic losers they have become.

 

Not pulling any punches tonight...

 

Sox wouldn't have even made the playoffs with Jamie Burke or Ben Davis along with Widger as their catchers.

 

2005 was statistically probably AJ's worst with the Sox.

 

He was great in the playoffs however, but really that was a TEAM effort. It wasn't like basketball where you have that dominant superstar to carry you.

 

But I think the Sox could have won without AJ. Glad they had him, still an asshole haha

Uribe, Everett, AJ, Rowand, Contreras, El Duque... these were the heart and soul of a winning baseball team. These players were winners, brought a championship to this miserable city and there are a great many "Sox fans" who ridiculed these players and were happy when they left.

 

 

The hero worship of the 2005 team makes me laugh sometimes.

 

f*** YES I'm glad these guys came together and won a title. It will probably be the greatest sports moment of my life, but s***, you gotta let it go. People age, players get less effective in the field. Happens to EVERYONE. I swear there are people on this message board who would take the entire 2005 team as they are in 2013 for the current Sox Roster. Old age, retirement and all...

Uribe, Everett, AJ, Rowand, Contreras, El Duque... these were the heart and soul of a winning baseball team. These players were winners, brought a championship to this miserable city and there are a great many "Sox fans" who ridiculed these players and were happy when they left.

 

Yes, they were. Outside of Everett, they were all really nice guys too. Even Everett was said to be a great teammate while on the Sox. I don't think they were plunked after leaving. That should tell you something.

 

 

It'd be pretty lol if Reed wasn't even trying to hit him.

Ok, saying AJ could be replaced in '05 is asinine. He was just as big a part of that team as anyone.