Well, first of all I don't only go by numbers, especially of last guys on a roster.
But a player I think sucks?
I tend to rate players who start a significant amount of games in that category.
Off the top of my head ...
I thought Erstad really sucked the year he was with the Sox.
I also hate to say I truly thought Swisher sucked.
This is going by what they did for the Sox. I don't even know the numbers they put up or their numbers compared to Wise.
I certainly can say I felt both truly sucked.
Others? I think Linebrink and Randy Williams truly suck.
I dont like Teahen but I won't say he sucks.
But generally I don't care that much about last guys on a roster. Though I admit Wise did start the season as a starter. But this argument is about worth of even being on a roster. I think Wise is worthy of that; many disagree.