Baseball Gal

Idk how palatable it will be to Jerry to sign FA with the explicit goal of buying prospects with them. There are already rumors that Jerry's takeaway is that rebuilds don't work rather than the FO being putrid at their jobs

It's because they either can't pick top 6 or top 10(not sure) in consecutive seasons.

This. I thought it was just that large market teams couldn't pick top 6 in consecutive years but if it's top 10 it's even worse. This is why tanking isn't a real option.

Yeah and they can't even pick top 6 in consecutive years, which would functionally mean they're unable to pick top 10. They're going to have to draft, internationally sign and develop their way out of this and there's not a lot of hope on that front. Even though Montgomery and Schultz look really promising, Hernandez and Reyes (top international signings) look like a disaster. They also really did a 180 in the draft department, which makes no sense after seeing the early success of Montgomery/Schultz.

Obviously cleaning house in the FO should be the first priority, but how should they move forward from here? I'm at a loss.

Idk I was just spitballing.

I wasn't saying that he was keeping them competitive, but rather keeping a few guys going so that the team wasn't a complete disaster.

Was Abreu holding this team together? Kicking a few guys in the ass so that they weren’t a complete embarrassment?

@wegner resigned is the word you were looking for

the sad thing is they're going to be even worse next year and probably unable to get a top 10 pick.

Yeah and they're not even gonna gwt a top 10 pick out of it.

Yes. Kopech didn't pitch in 2020 but in 2021 his slider was great. I think they tried to fix something that wasn't broken and tried to get both guys to throw a sweeper. Fail. Both Crochet and Kopech came up throwing an 87-89 mph slider with short but sharp break and they missed bats. Sox tried to get both guys to throw a sweeper and they ruined a plus pitch for both.

I think he could have gotten away with 96-98 if he kept the snapdragon slider. Idk what the sox did to his slider grip but his slider is way worse now than it was in 2020.

This.

They never even tried though.

Yeah but lefties that throw 102 with a wicked slider don't grow on trees. Sox player development (or lack thereof) fucked him up. He should have been an Aroldis Chapman level closer at worst. Also the Sox TJS guys are losing significant stuff after surgery. They should re-evaluate their TJS rehab protocol. He always had significant reliever risk, but they didn't even try to start him.

I'm not going to argue against the Crochet pick. It was worth the gamble if the Sox didn't rush him to the Majors and they actually gave him time to build up his arm. MLB draft is a crapshoot. The pick wasn't bad, what happened afterwards was brutal. Another guy that got injured and lost his stuff, just like Kopech.

David Wells?

Reyes and Hernandez have been so disappointing. The top international guys from the last two classes.

That's so confusing to me. Jerry doesn't like to spend on proven talent and he doesn't like to spend on unproven talent. So where you getting talent from, Jerry?

So then is Jerry right? I think it sucks that the Sox aren't really players in FA but that's even more evidence to sink a lot of resources into scouting and player development because that's where the value is.

He was worth it in 2020 and 21. Not in 2022 and 23. That's the point I was making. Grandal was worth 1.6 fwar in 60 games in 2020 and 3.6 in 2021. He keeps up that production and nobody is complaining. This is my point.

Also Grandal was worth it until he got injured. But that is to be expected as a 33 year old C.

Kopech is having a good game but he's clearly not the same guy he was as a prospect. You can say that about way too many of the guys that were supposed to be core pieces. Also this is gonna be unpopular but Cease=a healthy Rich Harden

Agreed.