WhiteSox2023

Reylo DID develop here. Madrigal is what he is but he actually hit well here, better here than with the Cubs. Eloy is always injured so we have never found out if he has a 40 HR season in him.

Sure they have. I never argued that it isn’t possible. But we sure haven’t seen this from Flexen, Soroka, and Fedde in the MLB. So there is no data supporting what you are saying, specific to the three pitchers that you cited. You are speaking in hypotheticals and these three starters have done nothing to support your argument. They do not have any recent track record of success like you stated.

That’s called a track record of success in the MLB, didn’t you know? ?

So once again, you provide no data to prove your terribly weak point and resort to your same shtick of asking why people are a fan of this team and name-calling how someone must be horrible at a party. Did you miss public speaking / debate class in high school? Your arguments are pathetic. You stated that Flexen, Soroka, and Fedde do indeed have a track record of success. Show it to me.

Flexen has had more bad years than good. Soroka has been ruined by injury. Fedde has one year of success in a different league and a 5.40 ERA in the MLB. Where are you seeing this track record of success for these guys?

I think he will either be the closer or a very high leverage reliever.

You would be correct. Sport Guy made an appearance to s%*# in everyone.

Yes. He cares about money more than winning. He only wants to win his way, by spending what he thinks is appropriate.

And they were replaced with more MLB proven suck. All they have is more potential than the guys you mentioned, but no track records of success. Also, one of the guys you mentioned (Kopech) is still in the rotation, and he hasn’t shown any signs of improving as a starting pitcher.

No one wants Lorenzen on a 2-year deal, which is what he wants.

Your comps are simply lazy and not even close to being similar to Thorpe. You just threw out the names of two highly drafted Sox prospects that you remembered had lower velocity fastballs and busted out. Lance Broadway had a 5.01 ERA, 1.54 WHIP, 10.32 H/9, and 6.29 K/9 in the minors. Kyle McCulloch had a 4.64 ERA, 1.49 WHIP, 10.54 H/9, and 5.00 K/9 in the minors. Basically, they were never even good in the minors and were destined for failure in the majors. The Sox overdrafted these guys because JR preferred drafting college pitchers that were supposedly more of a finished product, more projectable to make the rotation, and had no signability issues. He always preferred being safe in the draft and taking backend rotation guys over pitchers with the best pure stuff. Meanwhile, Drew Thorpe currently has a 2.52 ERA, 0.98 WHIP, 6.39 H/9, and 11.76 K/9 in the minors. Not even close to the bums you mentioned.

If you watch the video at this link, JJ Cooper of BA seems to disregard AJP’s report of Thorpe throwing 88 MPH as no big deal due to it being Spring Training and he’s likely not going at full force yet. Cooper says he normally sits at 91-92.

Now that he’s probably the third best starter left after Snell and Montgomery, with Cease traded, and a much cheaper option than the other two free agents, he’s probably trying to see the max dollars he can get on a 1-2 year contract with the other teams that need a starter (Yankees, Rangers, Giants).

Maybe, but he’s neither very young (27) nor are his minor league numbers very good. And I know I am a broken record with this but why the hell didn’t the Sox claim Canaan Smith-Njigba instead? A 24 year old lefty corner outfielder with very good minor league numbers. He also had an .860 OPS this spring with 3 homers and 2 stolen bases. Brutal decision making by Getz there.

That has been going on for a lot longer than 4 years, just not always consecutively.

Of course Robert is one, a very good piece. But you couldn’t salary dump Eloy and Moncada right now. Like most Sox fans, even Eloy’s mom probably gets pissed at his “HI MOM!” antics when he’s sucking at the plate or when he’s been on the IR for half the season. And when you have to say “a healthy Yoan” instead of just “Yoan”, you prove the point that the guy is injured too much.

That goes two ways though — it proves that not all of Baltimore’s prospects will pan out but it also will make their trade for Burnes look better.

I think that is the difference between this rebuild and the first one. We had some top prospects in the top 50 overall of baseball but we didn’t have much of a quantity of lesser but still quality prospects. It seems like we have more options now, but I guess we will have to see if this batch pans out.

Go to hell. ?

Garland threw around 92. Sinkerballs were his game. But I remember him throwing 95-96 during his playoff starts in 2005, after he had gotten additional rest I believe.

He hated Hahn and has been hyping Getz ever since he was rumored to be in line for the new GM spot. I understand he likes Getz but it almost feels like he went so all in on Getz that he can’t change his tune now and has to claim that every move he makes is great one. I can’t buy it if someone can’t admit that many of Getz’s dumpster diving acquisitions this offseason were an absolute joke. I don’t buy the never-ending leadership benefits and “showing the young guys the right way to play” BS. Most of these over-the-hill scrubs will be gone in a year. Does their leadership magically stay with the team once they are gone?

Make this dude the closer, give him every save opportunity possible, and see what prospect(s) you can deal him for. Add that to the return on this trade. “Padres Rookie Right-Hander Steven Wilson Has a Captivating Pitch Profile“

Exactly, and if anyone actually bought what Jerry was selling in that media conference to announce Getz as the new GM, they need to have their head checked.

Shouldn’t you be more worried about your team’s injuries and your new starter acquisition looking like a tee ball stand this spring?