I never said JM was worthless. However, motivation was not not his strong point. If he "got the best out of his players" why did the team not live up to preseason expectations the last 3 years? Several thought the Sox were World Seies bound after acquiring Colon, yet once again, we couldn't even win the division.
I didn't have problems with JM, but this team desparately needed a change. They had grown stale.