caulfield12

Rays acquiring Peralta

And Benintendi's

You mean Castillo as 4/5...?

https://www.freep.com/story/sports/mlb/tigers/2026/08/02/tarik-skubla-trade-detroit-tigers-los-angeles-tigrs-mlb-trade-deadline/91139054007/

None of the prospects the Dodgers gave up was viewed as crucial to the team’s future. It was hard to figure out how Hope was going to ever play in Los Angeles—he was considered the third-best outfield prospect on his own Double-A Tulsa team, behind Josue De Paula and Mike Sirota (and Quintero as well). Ryan has shown front-of-the-rotation stuff at his best, but he’s topped 50 innings in a season only once since he was drafted in 2022, and he’ll turn 28 this month. Smith has MLB-quality stuff, but he’s a Class A pitcher who has already missed significant time with an elbow injury. The Tigers got a normal level of return for Skubal, but if Skubal dominates teams in the postseason, it will leave many wondering if would it have been wise for someone else to overpay a bit in prospects to keep the team that has everything from adding one of the best pitchers in baseball? https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/tigers-land-zyhir-hope-river-ryan-brady-smith-in-tarik-skubal-trade/

They do think that he can stick in CFA (for now)...but there's a considerable difference of opinion about how true that will be down the line as he fills out. At the very least, adding Max Clark and Greene into the mix make for a very nice outfield trio. Now the big question shifts to whether the Tigers will eventually have enough pitching if you also trade Mize? https://www.espn.com.sg/mlb/story/_/id/49469642/mlb-trade-deadline-grades-2026-tarik-skubal-los-angeles-dodgers-detroit-tigers-blockbuster A=Dodgers D=Tigers F=the rest of baseball fans

They are...unless you mean Dominguez and his buyout. No way JR was taking on all that money without an offset somewhere... Boston Smith was essentially the "JR cost" of sending Dominguez out.

Skubal Yamamoto Ohtani??? Snell Glasnow Sheehan Wrobleski All Star Sasaki back to pen for postseason...averaging 99.5 fb in recent starts Detroit is also likely to trade Mize as well...opening two rotation spots B- "The Tigers got a solid return, but they failed to land Josue De Paula, Mike Sirota or Eduardo Quintero, who are L.A.’s top outfield prospects. It’s also worth noting that they didn’t need to be here. Detroit severely lowballed him during discussions about a long-term extension. And this offseason, it only offered him $19 million in arbitration, which was, frankly, insulting. In the end, Skubal won his arbitration case for a record $32 million. There was no coming back. They should have traded him at that point instead of waiting for the deadline and taking a smaller return. The franchise put itself in this position by not locking up its star player and accepted a package that is below his market value." https://www.si.com/mlb/tarik-skubal-trade-grades-how-tigers-dodgers-did-in-deal-for-cy-young-winner

Not even going to get their best prospect for a two month rental unless he's willing to sign an extension like Freddy Garcia did with the Sox. (Unless you're dealing with a river boat gambler like AJ Preller...)

Ryan/all about health the hitter is an acknowledged great prospect (so was Torkelson) with a questionable body who ends up at a corner or DH...Yordan Lite

Yet still had the clear #1 farm system and basically got Sasaki for a pittance...well, because they're the Dodgers.

https://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/article/the-dodgers-with-tarik-skubal-now-in-the-fold-become-even-more-imposing-infuriating-and-inevitable-044401640.html "Remember, the current collective bargaining agreement is set to expire in December. A messy labor war between the league and union is hurtling down the pike. A lengthy work stoppage is expected. The economic system that emerges from that mess might not involve a salary cap, but it also might. Skubal should get a Brinks truck on the open market regardless, but there's a chance that a deal from Los Angeles under the current system proves more lucrative than the alternative. It's unclear as of now how preexisting contracts would be handled under a new structure, but Los Angeles almost certainly could spend more on Skubal today than in a few months' time. Of course, that's a tomorrow problem, a flashpoint for our future selves. The here and now involves Skubal in Dodger blue. That alone won't determine the outcome of this baseball season. But it feels like it could. For many, that's enough to feel overwhelmed with despondence. The Dodgers and their fans? They shouldn't care one bit."

No Smith or McDougal in immediate future.

Balta?

"On This Day in Sports History: July 31, 2009, Jake Peavy Was Traded After Cementing Himself as One of the Greatest Pitchers in Padres History. The Padres traded 2007 NL Cy Young Award winner Jake Peavy to the White Sox in exchange for Aaron Poreda, Clayton Richard, Adam Russell, and minor leaguer Dexter Carter." C.Richard had a longer career than many expected...but a nothing burger overall in terms of prospect cost, except wasting picks on Poreda and Ring.

With age/overuse usually goes the crispness on pitches. Certainly saw it with Shields...who was even less velocity-reliant than Castillo.

He's actively trying to devalue the team in order to buy even cheaper shares than @ $1.8 billion valuation?

Kind of like Benintendi is "only" that amount but still keeps sticking around year after year...

Loiaza in 2003 was an accident. Getting F.Garcia and Contreras were going for the jugular.

If they can even make it that far. Not much of a vote of confidence in all the young pitchers contributing...

What make/model? Did you get a discount from the Sox adjacent scouting department...or zero interest financing at least?

Who was the last big "name" starting pitcher they added at a deadline prior to James Shields? (Yes, that was May 2016.) Francisco Liriano?

baseballsavant.comLuis Castillo Stats: Statcast, Visuals & Advanced Metrics(2026) Avg Exit Velocity: 90.2, Hard Hit %: 41.7, wOBA: .340, xwOBA: .337, Barrel %: 9.7.

North-Westeros The only Castillo fan lol "I'll admit my bias. Yes he was traded for but he agreed to an extension here. He actually WANTED to be here, so because of that again, I understand, I'm biased. With that out of the way, tell me again about the MLB wanting a salary cap to make things fair? Because last year, the most Googled team in baseball, which drew great ratings and revenue, just dumped the pitcher that basically kept your unit together through injuries LAST year, for all that and a bag of chips."

LOOKOUT LANDING Bret Boones Nutritionist 11m (edited) I give it a T for ”Thank you for your service Luis” really enjoyed watching him pitch for us from 2022-24, but it was already starting to be a watch-through-your-fingers experience last year. I hadn’t expected another team to be willing to take all of his remaining salary; on top of that Dominguez can hopefully still be a decent reliever and we got a couple other players too. Hard to be too mad about this. 1Reply Share G Gonzo 4 Haniger 13m Assuming there's nothing else in play here, this is an A for me. I was fully prepared for them to part with a semi-noteworthy prospect to get someone to take his contract. Frankly I'm pretty floored right now. 0Reply Share D Dominic Snyder 15m (edited) First, I love Luis and I will miss him. When we traded for him, it was the sign we were starting to go in on building a ball club for a new era of contention. He had a fantastic rest of that season and was solid each of the next few years. When he was on, he was fun to watch and carried a cool-headed confidence that I admire. We rode him about as far as we could. This is the first year it just really wasn’t working. I have been dreading having his contract hanging around our necks next season considering where he’s at. The fact the Sox are taking on all of that money is a huge win for us already. Taking on Seranthony Domínguez’s money for this and next year offsets that a little, but it still frees up a bunch. Nolan Jones is a warm body outfielder. Boston Smith is actually a sleeper prospect that I’m astounded we got included in the deal. This is his first year of pro ball, and he’s done nothing but crush in the minors. He’s not ranked that highly, and he’s already 23, but he’s a "catcher" who has been mashing and walking constantly. 2Reply Share Suburban Shocker 23m If it means they're going to reinvest the money they save on Castillo? That gets an A. I'll reserve judgment until then. 1Reply Share B BP82titan 25m (edited) Suppose this saves us from trading Hancock who has a lot of control at much lower cost, so that should factor into the grade. Saving Luis’s $$$ could be big for alternate use next year or perhaps still here at this deadline to re-allocate. (They also get to insert Logan Evans/Logan Gilbert and Kade Anderson/Sloan piggybacks into the rotation.)