Everything posted by caulfield12
-
Dan johnson
QUOTE (kitekrazy @ Oct 5, 2012 -> 12:15 AM) This might be the reason why they can't get the job done after ASB. The bench is always beyond bad. By that theory, Kotsay and Jones should have worked over Thome, but it didn't. All depends on the quality of the players in the platoon. Assuming Wise and/or Johnson would have excelled with 350 or so at-bats, and that Viciedo would still have crushed LH'ers with just limited plate appearances, that's a guessing game at best.
-
Floyd adjustments came from Parent
We don't play them until July. So we should keep Peavy, then trade him before we face the Tigers again, haha.
-
The David Wright and Jake Peavy Thread
QUOTE (DukeNukeEm @ Oct 4, 2012 -> 11:23 PM) We have the trade pieces. Quintana + change could easily get it done if the Mets are convinced Wright is leaving after 2013. They'll undoubtedly pick up the option before moving him, so we'll have to make room for $16 million. Quintana and change? That would get laughed at...half of SoxTalk doesn't think he's (Quintana) going to last for all of 2013 as a starter again, and yet the Mets will accept making him the centerpiece of a trade for their best player? Keep in mind, the Yankees gave him up for nothing...they didn't even protect him. There's just no way the Mets could sell a move like this to their fanbase.
-
Steve Stone NOT leaving
QUOTE (greg775 @ Oct 4, 2012 -> 10:37 PM) Now that is one helluva post. I don't get White Sox fans. They just seem to WANT to be bored. First they want Ozzie out, colorful Ozzie. They get their wish with very very dull Robin. Now they want Hawk out. It'd serve you Hawk haters right to get the Royals' Steve Physioc. Mr. Enunciation. AWFUL. What's with this desire for dullishness???? I just don't get it. Keep Hawk. Let Ozzie be his color man 20 games since he's getting the boot in Miami; Big Hurt 20 games; DJ 20 games, Wimpy 20 games, etc. It's obvious Stoney is gone after that interview. I'm in the middle about Harrelson leaving or staying. Personally, I like him. For the future of the organization (and for expanding the fanbase again), a new voice has to be groomed, though. Rotating broadcasters in and out of the booth is complicated, it hurts the chemistry between PBP and color guy, you don't develop a rhythm as much and it's a bit confusing to viewers at home. When you turn on a Dodgers' game, you know Scully, Cardinals with Jack Buck, Tigers with Harwell, etc. There's something to be said for that. Hawk is that voice, for now. But he's getting more and more polarizing, just like Harry Caray at the end of his broadcasting career, or Ron Santo.
-
222 K's
QUOTE (HickoryHuskers @ Oct 4, 2012 -> 10:43 AM) Scoring 713 at the Oakland Colosseum is a far better offensive performance than scoring 748 at US Cellular Field. Most importantly, Oakland had better starting pitching, and a MUCH better bullpen, especially the 2nd half of the season.
-
Worst collapse in franchise history?
QUOTE (kitekrazy @ Oct 4, 2012 -> 09:22 PM) Worst collapse this season belongs to the Rangers. If they lose in the WC game, sure. But look at 2006, the Twins chased down the Tigers and the Tigers "collapsed" down the stretch, except the Tigers were the ones in the end close to winning the World Series if not for all those errors. Do you think any Tigers' fan looking back on 2006 cares they didn't win the AL Central? Or that Twins fans, having watched their team decimate baseball for 2 1/2 months, feels satisfied how that season ended in the playoffs for them? If the Rangers advance and finally win the World Series, none of their fans will care at all. In fact, it will add to the legend, like the Red Sox coming from way back against the Yankees. It would make a World Series win all the sweeter...just like how in 2005, we very nearly didn't make it, then ended up winning it all. None of us will forget that feeling of dread and forboding in September...which made the elation of winning it all that much more poignant and memorable, to go through the highs and lows of that entire season.
-
The David Wright and Jake Peavy Thread
QUOTE (2nd_city_saint787 @ Oct 4, 2012 -> 09:45 PM) This How does Tank/Q/Jones or Reed sound as a package sound? They don't need more starting pitching, Clayton Richard has proven that almost anyone can have success in the NL West as a starter, especially with half the home games at PetCo. Heck, you can add Eric Stults to that list, too. That makes the trade essentially a reliever (also not the first piece you add in a rebuilding effort) and Viciedo for Headley. If Viciedo could play 3B, it would be a no-brainer for the Padres. Unfortunately, he can't. Denorfia and Venable both put up better numbers than Viciedo...then they have Quentin and Maybin (signed an extension). Reed's value is far from clear...maybe more than Santos, simply because of his contract status. But anyone who watched the last four months or scouted the White Sox would have serious qualms about bringing in Reed. The main plus would be bringing him "back home" since he played for SD State. Headley had a monster year. He's getting more expensive, but you simply don't trade a player like that if you want to retain your fanbase. I'll agree Viciedo has a LOT more upside than either Denorfia or Venable, but it wouldn't be worth Headley to get that upside...because there are so few slugging 3B in MLB today. As far as Peavy goes, we need players who are not afraid of the Tigers, like Jose Quintana. No thanks, he had a VERY good 2012, but that's where it ends. A pat on the back for putting himself in a position to finally contribute like he was expected to way back in 2009, but he's not enough to put us over the top in 2013...3B should be more of a priority, especially since they can bring back Floyd. And Jake had a ton of wear and tear on him this year.
-
AJ may have played last game for Sox
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Oct 4, 2012 -> 02:38 PM) Outside of resigning Peavy we are not signing another starting pitcher. Or Floyd (although technically that's exercising an option, not a signing). But I wouldn't be so sure about keeping Gavin when they've gotten "very reasonable" production out of Quintana and Santiago on the cheap. Of course, the problem is the left-handedness of that rotation...the main mitigating factor forcing Gavin back into the rotation. And the fact that while they were quite fortunate with Quintana's development, it doesn't automatically mean the same thing would happen were they to stick Axelrod, Rienzo, Castro or Molina out there in the rotation as well for 2013. If they let Peavy AND Floyd both go, they're definitely going to have to sign someone like a Liriano, Guthrie, Haren, etc.
-
Steve Stone NOT leaving
It's reminiscent of Billy Packer/Vitale with the NCAA's or Pat Summerall/Ken Venturi with golf. Eventually, at some point, you need to move on with a younger broadcaster who will attract a different demographic of fans and try something new and fresh. Let's think of Stone as Jim Nantz or Bryant Gumbel here, for argument's sake.
-
Dan johnson
QUOTE (fathom @ Oct 4, 2012 -> 10:15 AM) ADA was a diamond in the rough Carlos Quentin, AJ, Jermaine Dye, Jim Thome (considering he was coming off a major injury), Alexei Ramirez certainly qualifies...Viciedo, to a lesser extent. Even Wise, Flowers and Johnson the final 2 months this year. It's just that we didn't get what we needed out of Konerko, Dunn, Liriano, Peavy...the list goes on and on for the final 4-6 week disappearing act. Alexei and Dayan both struggled quite a bit down the stretch. AJ. Rios was one of our few consistent threats. YOUK against the Tigers or on the road was a disaster. Everyone knows the Beckham story, second verse, same as the first.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
That's the furthest Gimenez has ever hit a ball. He makes Corky Miller look like Ichiro. Great defender, though.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
Another ex-Royal strikes again, lol. Bailey for Reddick one of the worst offseason moves in recent years.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
Cincy over STL is putting the Dodgers back in play...but they need 2 wins and 2 Cardinals losses. Would be a crazy ending for the Cardinals after last season's charge, but the Dodgers haven't shown themselves capable of sustaining anything since the first 2 months of the year.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
QUOTE (flavum @ Oct 2, 2012 -> 07:54 PM) They should just call off the vote, and let Showalter and Melvin split it. How can you pick one over the other? It was like that BS in 2005 when Shapiro won Executive of the Year over KW. How can you pick the 2nd place team there that didn't even make the playoffs and collapsed the final week?
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
Same thing with AL West, which would be even more amazing. Who do you go with, Showalter or Melvin? Both were totally improbable playoff teams. Which team had the highest LV odds at the beginning of the year?
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
QUOTE (fathom @ Oct 2, 2012 -> 07:40 PM) To save him for a save situation tonight? I can't wait to hear this whole offseason has Viciedo's overall numbers are skewed by the final week of games where the stats became meaningless except for the back of the baseball card. 24 and 77, that's not too far off most projections, problems against RHP notwithstanding. Maybe some were calling for 30 and 90 RBI's, but that was a bit too optimistic. LOL at the Royals finally taking the lead over DET after losing 5 in a row to them.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
QUOTE (BigSqwert @ Oct 2, 2012 -> 07:36 PM) With anything somewhat resembling offensive support and Peavy would have 16+ wins this year. 3 runs in 8 innings is a QS last I checked. An ERA under 3.40 on the season is pretty damn good in the AL. The guy hasn't pitched a full season in who knows how many years and here he is in October throwing another QS. But when we've needed him not to give up the lead, or give up 1-2 runs instead of 3, he just hasn't gotten it done. Consistently in the 2nd half, and always against the Tigers. Golf clap, to quote Marty, but don't let the door hit you on the way out. Down the stretch, when we need him to be the ace and take some of the pressure of Chris Sale, he hasn't delivered.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
QUOTE (fathom @ Oct 2, 2012 -> 07:37 PM) Huh? Not a closing situation Why do we care at all what Myers does here? Unless they just want to rest Reed and get him to the offseason.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
Alexei way too lackadaisical on that one. Had to be more aggressive there and charge it.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
51 saves for Johnson. So Reed's out of the picture as closer in 2013? His confidence couldn't be any lower going into the offseason.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
Saw the score and thought it was Reed that blew, only to find out it was Jake-meister. Figures. Right now, 2nd's locked up and 84 wins is going to put us in better draft position probably... Didn't realize Johnson had 50 saves already. He and Rodney are having quite the seasons in that AL East. With how bad the AL Central has been this season, you wonder if the Tigers can just turn it on when they face some tougher competition. Verlander will be fine, but you don't know about Scherzer's health.
-
"Nobody Cares About the Sox"
I really believe the Sox are content with 25,000 and slightly more profit rather than 28-30,000 per game and posting any bottom-line numbers due to decreased prices for parking/tickets/concessions that are less than what they're currently getting at 25K per game. The problem with losing out on those 5,000 fans per game is that you're not developing the fanbase for the future...you're maximizing (or squeezing) the revenue in current terms, but probably "penny wise/pound foolish" long term IMO.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
QUOTE (pettie4sox @ Oct 2, 2012 -> 07:18 PM) Was the HBP intentional? Probably, he should have been warned after the first one. Ventura and Harrelson and Cooper probably don't have the energy to argue anymore about umpiring in 2012.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
QUOTE (fathom @ Oct 2, 2012 -> 07:14 PM) It's not like they hit the ball well tonight. Indians also aren't trying at all this series since they know they can't play spoiler. Just wait until Reed comes in, lol. The only game worth watching now is NY/BOS or Balt/TB. Rooting hard for the Yankees to lose 2 in a row, but unlikely with Dice-K vs. Kuroda tmrw.
-
Sox vs Indians game 161 thread
Saw the replay, 94 MPH fastball out over the heart of the plate. That was a good 430 or 440, maybe 450. A blast, in this September weather.