-
Posts
17,967 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
57
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by ChiSox59
-
Rodon almost equal to 4/5th’s of Sox starting rotation in fWAR
ChiSox59 replied to caulfield12's topic in Pale Hose Talk
Any chance he gets. -
Just say no to Carlos "I'm the Product Here" Correa
ChiSox59 replied to caulfield12's topic in Pale Hose Talk
Great "analysis"! -
Just say no to Carlos "I'm the Product Here" Correa
ChiSox59 replied to caulfield12's topic in Pale Hose Talk
Yeah, I don't think you're right here at all, but time will tell. -
Just say no to Carlos "I'm the Product Here" Correa
ChiSox59 replied to caulfield12's topic in Pale Hose Talk
The history you're suggesting is a wildly limited sample size. Ignoring half the league based on some stupid thought that any NL player will fail in Chicago is well....stupid. -
Just say no to Carlos "I'm the Product Here" Correa
ChiSox59 replied to caulfield12's topic in Pale Hose Talk
I actually don't hate the trade TA idea. It just depends on what the offers look like. TA should have a good bit of value, he's not a good SS, and I am speculating here, but the whole ASG announcement thing and clear lack of leadership in clubhouse this season makes me think he may not be favorite in the clubhouse. If you can get a nice return for him, I'd be open to it...he only has 2 years of control. That being said, my price to move TA would be very high, I am not just moving him to the highest bidder. You also need to find a SS now in that scenarioideally one that can field their position. We all know the Sox won't be in the running for the high end FAs. Also, your avoid all NL players take continues to be just an awful one. -
Just say no to Carlos "I'm the Product Here" Correa
ChiSox59 replied to caulfield12's topic in Pale Hose Talk
Opt out of Anderson? My lord, what a terrible take. -
Just say no to Carlos "I'm the Product Here" Correa
ChiSox59 replied to caulfield12's topic in Pale Hose Talk
And will likely sign something like 5/$150M. Wise choice, if you ask me. -
Will "core" players be traded before Spring Training?
ChiSox59 replied to joejoesox's topic in Pale Hose Talk
But you'd rather go through a protracted rebuild lasting at least 3-4 seasons when there is still a nucleus of a talented team intact, in a poor division? Also, the only guys on the Sox worth a damn at the moment are Cease, TA, Robert, AV and Kopech. All are controlled beyond 2023. Trading the rest (Lynn, Giolito, Moncada, Eloy, Hendriks, Bummer, Graveman, Lopez) are going to make the 2023 team much worse, while not measurably impacting the future. It doesn't make any sense. -
Just say no to Carlos "I'm the Product Here" Correa
ChiSox59 replied to caulfield12's topic in Pale Hose Talk
He is 100% correct. And good for him for saying it. -
We both know there is 0% chance they go that direction.
-
He was awful. No argument there. He also has a career OPS, including this season, of .762. It’s unlikely he forgot how to hit at age 27. He’s also an elite defender. Not a perfect player and definitely not what we hoped he would be, but he’s still very useful and has the ability to bounce back to his career norms making himself a well above average player.
-
Will "core" players be traded before Spring Training?
ChiSox59 replied to joejoesox's topic in Pale Hose Talk
You also cannot continue to play two 1B in the OF. So something has to give... -
9/29/22 Sox vs Twins 12:10 Wanna Get Away Day
ChiSox59 replied to wegner's topic in 2022 Season in Review
Also at about 15-20% of the cost. He won't have an options which is unfortunate, so he may not survive the offseason on the 40 man. But yes, Engel should be non-tendered. -
9/29/22 Sox vs Twins 12:10 Wanna Get Away Day
ChiSox59 replied to wegner's topic in 2022 Season in Review
Interesting. -
9/29/22 Sox vs Twins 12:10 Wanna Get Away Day
ChiSox59 replied to wegner's topic in 2022 Season in Review
Why in the world would they not bring in their closer in a close situation? -
9/29/22 Sox vs Twins 12:10 Wanna Get Away Day
ChiSox59 replied to wegner's topic in 2022 Season in Review
I doubt he's done here. -
9/29/22 Sox vs Twins 12:10 Wanna Get Away Day
ChiSox59 replied to wegner's topic in 2022 Season in Review
Best at bat I've seen in months from the Sox there from Payton. And he gets rewarded with the error, and guess what..he ends at 2B on an infield popup because he hustled. Dude needs to play every day rest of the way. -
Its not going to drop to $170M. What happens if the entire Sox team suddenly all pass away this offseason? Then what!?! Is $170M going to be this off-season's version of your argument last offseason that the luxury tax won't increase above $210M that you stated everyday all last offseason as if it was fact?
