ChiSox59

Thankfully there are several RF of note, and that will likely be our only position of need at that point, assuming we sign a SP to a multiyear deal yet this offseason.

Yah, don't get your hopes up. Moncada isn't moving to the OF, so you move him back to 2B, and then trade Madrigal for a SP/RF. And if its for SP, you still have a hole in RF. And if its for a RF, you still have a SP hole and $250M+ less to fix it. Your plan sounds great if this were a video game. But its not. Like I said, I'd love to see it - but it just doesn't seem even remotely possible.

So we just spend a quarter billion dollars on 1 player and didn't even fill a hole? Which is exactly this scenario is never going to happen for this organization, among other reasons. Look, I'd love to have Rendon play for the White Sox. But this isn't MLB the Show. They aren't moving Moncada again (especially to a position he's never played), they aren't trading Madrigal just to create a hole at 2B to fill one elsewhere, and Rendon isn't going to sign somewhere to play somewhere other than 3B. The guy is good, but based on where we sit today, its just not a great use of limited funds. That being said, if the Sox actually did it - I certainly wouldn't complain - I just don't see it as every remotely realistic.

I think the White Sox young pitching staff is going to be in much better shape if we have a RF that we don't need to wish/hope improves to merely "serviceable". Eloy is our LF, and he isn't going to be a good one. We really need at worst a slightly above average defensive RF, or this team isn't going to be very good. As Hawk always said, rule #1 in baseball is to catch the ball. And the man is right.

Man, time flies. Can't believe Chris Sale has been in the league for 10 fuckin years.

I am so excited to watch our young, developing pitching staff get absolutely destroyed by the worst OF defense in the league in this scenario. Sounds like so much fun - where do I sign up?

I mean, at that price, what's the harm? The FutureSox article posted a few weeks ago about this cat suggested 2-4 year commitment at $8-10M AAV. If this guy could play some D, I'd be significantly more interested. I suppose if he's dirt cheap, it can't hurt to add him to the mix. But at $8-10M AAV, he's just going to make this roster even more inflexible.

25% K rate in Japan last season is alarming.

https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/mlb-hot-stove-japanese-slugger-yoshitomo-tsutsugo-will-be-posted-for-mlb-teams-this-offseason/

Hmmm this guys isn't really an option in the OF everyday, so I guess if the Sox are serious about this guy, Collins is likely on his way out. Anyone have a ballpark estimate of what he'd cost?

Right, something has to give there. May not involve the Sox, but they're going to trade one of those guys.

I would hammer the under on 4/$110M for Ryu, and I have seen no one of note suggest anything remotely close to that figure for Ryu. If that what he is looking for, and eventually gets, then ya - re categorize me in the hard pass category. I think 3/$60-65M sounds about right for Ryu.

Colome is the Sox 2nd best reliever. Sure he's paid what he's worth, but its not like we have a laundry list of guys ready to replace him. We traded a light hitting DH that tries to catch for a closer that did very well in 2019 - despite outperforming his peripherals - and is under control again in 2020 at market price for a decent closer. The Narvaez trade isn't going to appear in any 'best trades of the decade" lists, but it was a need for need trade. The fact that the M's turned around and traded the guys less than 12 months later for a minimal return is fairly telling.

Yah, I love the people that say hard pass to Ryu, but were all for Wheeler. They've both been in the league since 2013 - Ryu 740 IP; Wheeler 749 IP. They've literally been hurt the same amount. Ryu has been a considerably better pitcher to date. Sure, he's a bit older, and maybe a little less "upside", but he's also going to come at somewhere between 50-60% of the cost of Wheeler, which definitely makes up the difference, and then some. Ryu should be priority #1 at this point.

Yah, I think its primarily a reflection that Omar Narvaez isn't good.

Hill is very uninteresting. Will be 23 in ST and hasn't pitched above A ball. Comp pick (#71) is nice, but I think we did better in this deal than Seattle did.

Sox Twitter is a dark place. Bumgarner would be fine at a realistic AAV ($15M or so), but it doesn’t sound like he’s going to anywhere near there. Would love to see the Twins overpay for him. Keuchel is the guy that worries me the most. Just really don’t want to give Keuchel $15M+ a year. Just don’t see that aging well. Will definitely be interesting to see where the Sox go from here. Would be super fun if this convinced them to pony up for the one of the big 2, but I’ll believe it when I see it. Tough day for us Sox fans, but it’s super encouraging to see the Sox put 5/$125M on the table even if they weren’t able to convert.

At least I try? I’m a generally optimistic and positive fan as well, but I at least try to contribute to topics and provide insight to a game I happen to know quite a bit about. Definitely am not as knowledgeable as some here (which Is the main reason I love this place), and I love the hear other knowledgeable fans opinions, glean info and learn to look at the game in new ways. You just continually spam every thread with blank thoughts. I’m sure you’re a fantastic guy, but your bit I am sure has run thin on a lot regular posters, not just me. 4,000 posts since February is insane! But this is an open forum, so you do you, man. Go Sox!

Its the lack of analysis that comes along with the blind faith that comes off as silly.

Yes. He’s definitely not my first choice, but he’s definitely a better fit than Castellanos.

I’ve laid out what I’d do countless times. Top of my list would be guys on expiring contracts like David Peralta or Joc Pederson. If those didn’t work I’d explore what it would take to acquire a Nimmo or Gregory Polonco. If those didn’t pan out I’d circle back to free agents on a 1 year deal.

Just so puzzled how so many Sox fans can think Castellanos is a good fit based on where we stand today. RF the one position that makes sense for a 2021 free agency splash and Castellanos defense combined with long term presence of Jose just clogs this lineup long term. I don’t deny that the 2020 lineup would be drastically improved, but it’s a short sighted move. You have to analyze the overall impact of a deal for an organization. Paying Castellanos $16-18M AAV over the next 4-5 years, and committing to poor team defense during his tenure is not what good teams do.

3/$60M, give or take a few million.

Leury with some Engel sprinkled in. Both hit LHP well.

At this point, my plan A would be to pivot to Cole and Strasburg, understanding that is likely a pipedream. Plan B: Get Ryu on a reasonable 3 year deal, and find a 1 year stop gap for the other spot. Overpaying MadBum ($100M+ for him is insanity), or trading from our elite prospects to add pitching isn't the answer.