OmarComing25

That did not hit him.

Wow Wolters of all hitters comes through.

He’s clearly not completely healthy.

Bullshit.

Ottavino has been a stud this year, I would have gone to him too. I don’t get Heyward over Schwarber.

Freeland is on 3 days rest though.

Sunday and today, that’s 2 days rest. Gray was never in consideration.

Why steal there?

Guy really should win MVP running away. He won’t, but he’s easily been the best player in the NL. What a season.

Its main purpose is to avoid having your backend starters facing the top of the lineup a third time through the order when they're probably going to get hammered.

Bringing the heat that inning.

https://www.fangraphs.com/scoutboard.aspx?draft=2018updated&type=0&pos=all&team=all&page=1_100 Eloy - #3 Madrigal - #19 Kopech - #24 Robert - #27 Collins - #66 Basabe - #83 Adolfo - #87 Cease - #95 Dunning - #96 Burdi - #116 Hansen - #130

It seems like the Sox are taking more heat for keeping down Eloy than the Blue Jays are for keeping down Vlad, or does it just seem that way because of local coverage?

I honestly think the vast majority of players take the $350 million offer, $20 million is still a lot of money to turn down.

The Red Sox fans were gushing over Gio’s 2 seamer in that gamethread. It’s also amusing seeing all the usual negative gamethread comments you see here even for a team that is 50 games over .500.

Giolito looked as good as I’ve ever seen him that inning against three great hitters.

Statcast supports this too. He’s 4th among all OF this year in Outs Above Average and was third last year. Statcast doesn’t account for the arm though, and it’s clearly a big weakness.

To further bring home the point, only 4 teams have a 5th starter in that range, and 2 of them (Red Sox and Cardinals) should barely count because they haven't had a dedicated 5th starter all year, it's a spot that has been shared by various guys throughout the season. Also Eduardo Rodriguez hasn't pitched in nearly 2 months and Porcello's ERA is just barely in that range so I'm hesitant to even include them. Very few teams are even going to end up with a 5th starter pitching over 100 innings.

That would make him a top 60 starting pitcher going by the 2018 season. Might be a bit much of an ask for the 5th starter.

Outliers go in both directions. Also it’s not like there’s only a couple really bad hitters significantly dragging down the averages. The true outliers aren’t affecting the average as much as you think.

For your average baseline you can’t just ignore everyone at the bottom, then it’s no longer an average.

That doesn’t make sense. You’re separating relief pitchers and starters when their jobs are FAR more similar than position players’ are. The job of a catcher or SS is significantly different than a 1B or LF. You also continue to argue against yourself. You admitted yourself that good hitting middle IF or catchers are very rare. Good hitting first basemen are a dime a dozen. Hence the big difference in value.

LOL so defense and positions don’t matter but somehow relief pitchers get a pass?

Got to love it when OP debunks his own argument.

Yeah I believe you want either very low or very high levels of spin, being in the middle is the least desirable.