tray

If this happened to the White Sox at our park and Tony pussy-ed out and did nothing in response most of you would be apoplectic.

Answer the question .

LMFAO !!!

What would you have done if you were Baldelli? Nothing?

The issue was not what Yermin did. It was what Baldelli did in response.

So this is how it breaks down: 1. Should Yermin have teed off on the pitch to increase the lead in the 9th inning to 12 runs? You can agree or disagree. but set that aside, because it happened and some consequence should have been expected. 2. Should Baldelli have had his pitcher throw a softball message pitch (not a bean ball at his head) to support his players who felt that they were being shown up in front of their fans in their own stadium? So this was a multiple choice question for Baldelli : a. You think that a slow pitch not intended to bean Mercedes was appropriate. b. You think that kind of pitch was not enough to send a meaasge and it should have been the typical old school Don Drysdale 90+ mph high heat at the bill of Yermin's helmet? c. You think that a soft"purpose pitch" was totally inappropriate because: 1. Managers should never use a purpose pitch like that to make a point. 2. The matter was concluded after Yermin trotted around the bases to score the 16th run . Thus it would have been better to simply let the controversy simmer and possibly blow up in a brawl) Forget what Baldelli did or maybe LaRussa or another Manager would have done. What would you have done?

OK cub fan.

Stop saying that they threw at Yermin. They didn't. The ball was thrown low and slow bouncing in behind his feet. That wasn't bean ball . None of the White Sox took it that way, not even Yermin. It was simply made as a counterpoint to what was kind of an @hole in-yo-face move by Yermin, No harm, no foul but they made a point. Don't show us up at our own ballpark with shenanigans like that. And they did it without endangering Yermin or causing a bench clearing brawl. That is precisely how it should have been handled. My only difference with LaRussa's decisions in that game was deciding to allow Bummer to pitch to Sano with first base open....after he hit 2 home runs. LaRussa played it by the book, - don't walk and allow the winning run to come to the plate. But again, I would have gone against the book on that one. Tony probably feels the same way in hindsight. I also am starting to get concerned about our bullpen and Andrew Vaughn. Vaughn is starting to look like easy pickings for pitchers with decent sliders. Vaughn does not seem to be effective with two strikes and has disappointed in numerous clutch situations.

Tony sends Lamb and picks up another run !

Tony has the Sox up one run by putting Lamb in the line-up ...and he still has a challenge card in his pocket. Sometimes you teach, sometimes you learn, and sometimes you get taught.

Yoan is GG D at third. Some here claimed that he should stay at second base claiming that second base was his "natural position."

Half truth! Words matter!

A thing...LOL!

Tie goes to the runner Irrefutable evidence is required to overturn the call on the field If you lose the challenge , you don't have another one for the rest of the game. All things considered in the few seconds after looking at the replay, I understand the decision.

Alternating RH and LH hitters in the line-up can aggravated some pitchers. No matter what Tony does, he will never be given credit. However, once the team goes into an inevitable slump/ losing streak it will all be blamed on him. I have felt like that at times...no credit for anything but oh boy, should I make a mistake..

If Lamb doesn't start hitting and Burger keeps raking, do you think the Sox would DFA Lamb and bring up Jake? I was just imagining an outfield of Burger, Hamilton and Vaughn...and how crazy that would be. Tony likes to experiment with the players/line-ups and would probably try it.

I think we will be set in the outfield without acquiring any outfielders after this season Robert, Eloy and Engel returning plus Cespy, Colas, and Vaughn who is even showing he could play RF.

The Twins are toast. So are Hinch the Cheat's Tigers. I want to see the Sox beat some of the better teams now, starting with the Yankees.

I never said it was a clear picture. I said I am not writing KC and Cleveland off in the middle of May. I have seen a lot of baseball this season and in years past on which to base that opinion.

I watched their games with the Sox and am not writing KC or Cleveland off in the middle of May.

The ump looked down on it from a few feet away and saw air between the catcher's mitt and Abreu. He had a better angle to make the call than the cameras could provide. I am still worried about Cleveland and KC. They both look better than I thought they were. You are right though, if you continue beating them even this early in the season , that makes a Division win more likely.

Corey Seager out with fractured hand.. https://www.mlb.com/news/corey-seager-hand-injury

If you look at his short sleeve on the runners shirt you could see it flapped when Collins tagged him. He was out.

The worst criticism a sports media personality can levy against a pro athlete is that he isn't trying. Stone just did that. I am tired of Stone and Bennetti for a variety of reasons, this being the latest, but I don't want to get into that, beyond responding to this outrageous comment. Perhaps Stone needs to take off another week to visit his dogs, or perhaps, he should consider retirement.

Brother Tony. I watched every game in the Twins series and I am certain that some ("inexcusable"?) decisions that LaRussa made could be questioned and tallied on some score card, but to what end? The Sox swept the series, I am ecstatic, and I don't want to hear constant whining about LaRussa. It is beginning to look petty and distracts from discussing the main topics here. As a mod, you should be trying to keep the flow of the discussion and encouraging fan dialogue, , not accusing posters of trolling. Listen, if LaRussa deserves to be fired, the Chicago sports media will be all over that. However, he is no where near that threshold right now. It's just not an issue at this time. Maybe save your bullets as the saying goes, and attack him if and when it looks like he deserves to go.