May 8, 20187 yr · 5h Dane Dunning was caught by Seby Zavala today, but went out of his way to compliment Zack Collins’ framing. Dunning said Collins has greatly improved his ability to stick strikes on the corners
May 9, 20187 yr 1 hour ago, Tony said: Everyone in this thread needs to read this. https://www.milb.com/milb/news/toolshed-zack-collins-clicking-again-at-plate/c-275805192?tcid=tw_article_275805192 It also makes me question what the Sox minor league team was doing with Collins early on in the season, when all those stories came out about "They know what's wrong with my swing, it's a hitch we're going to fix in the offseason." I would have to hear from the coaching staff but it is alarming that Collins had to do the research himself in order to fix his issues.
May 9, 20187 yr 1 hour ago, Tony said: Everyone in this thread needs to read this. https://www.milb.com/milb/news/toolshed-zack-collins-clicking-again-at-plate/c-275805192?tcid=tw_article_275805192 It also makes me question what the Sox minor league team was doing with Collins early on in the season, when all those stories came out about "They know what's wrong with my swing, it's a hitch we're going to fix in the offseason." This article is really telling, if the Sox want sustained success and develop kids throught the draft then this stuff is completely unacceptable.
May 9, 20187 yr Quote "When I step in the box, I'm looking for a fastball down the middle," Collins said. "If it's not there, I don't swing. Sometimes, that means I'll be behind in the count, but I can handle that OK. A lot of people ask me why I take so many walks, and it is kinda crazy. But I really just want my pitch." Something Jim Thome would say
May 9, 20187 yr 36 minutes ago, reiks12 said: Something Jim Thome would say If the Sox can get a Jim Thome level hitter that can catch, that will be a huge boon going forward.
May 9, 20187 yr 5 hours ago, Tony said: Everyone in this thread needs to read this. https://www.milb.com/milb/news/toolshed-zack-collins-clicking-again-at-plate/c-275805192?tcid=tw_article_275805192 It also makes me question what the Sox minor league team was doing with Collins early on in the season, when all those stories came out about "They know what's wrong with my swing, it's a hitch we're going to fix in the offseason." So did he go back to his old swing, or just his old stance? Whatever it is, it is working. Collins has been my fav player in our system and I am super excited to see him mashin!
May 10, 20187 yr 7 hours ago, reiks12 said: I would have to hear from the coaching staff but it is alarming that Collins had to do the research himself in order to fix his issues. I agree, but just to play devil's advocate - we have no clue what the Sox staff had suggested to Collins so far this season, nor Collin's willingness to listen. For all we know that old swing may also be exploitable once the league gets more looks at him (though I hope not). Could the Sox perhaps push certain guys in the system to figure out their own adjustments as part of the development process? As a sidenote: Collins' splits are pretty drastic so far this year. He's hitting .288 against RHP while only sporting a .091 BA against southpaws (though both small sample sizes). Over his entire minor league career, he's now at .251/.182 vs. RHP/LHP. So he definitely appears to be at least average matchup against RHP and the strong side of a platoon role. I could easily live with that.
May 10, 20187 yr The Sox have never seemed to be overly prescriptive in pushing swing changes or pitching mechanics changes before they become a hurdle and Getz himself has talked about letting players figure it out. the “Sox demanded he changed his swing to suck!” is probably much more “Sox and Collins worked together on how to accomplish a path in his swing he wanted, but it ended up being counterproductive and also is part of development”
May 10, 20187 yr 1 hour ago, CWSpalehoseCWS said: For all we know that old swing may also be exploitable once the league gets more looks at him (though I hope not). That's the only thing I can think of. His swing in college is what made him a first round draft pick... why in God's name did ANYBODY think it would be a good idea to change it? unless... (this was my argument back on page 1 of this thread) Maybe somebody at FS can ask Getz or Hostetler about this?
May 10, 20187 yr I'm glad they at least didn't tinker with Eloy's swing when he got here from the Cubs system. Geez, very telling. Edited May 10, 20187 yr by SoxAce
May 10, 20187 yr 2 hours ago, SoxAce said: I'm glad they at least didn't tinker with Eloy's swing when he got here from the Cubs system. Geez, very telling. How do you know they didn't? Afterall, he was only hitting .271 with 11 extra base hits with the Cubs prior to the trade. After the trade, in only a few more games, he hit about .350 with 28 extra base hits and an OPS almost 200 points higher, while also moving up a level to AA. Eloy has put up much better numbers since he came over to the Sox. Maybe he did tweak his swing/stance, I honestly never watched him in the Cubs system.
May 10, 20187 yr 15 hours ago, Tony said: Everyone in this thread needs to read this. https://www.milb.com/milb/news/toolshed-zack-collins-clicking-again-at-plate/c-275805192?tcid=tw_article_275805192 It also makes me question what the Sox minor league team was doing with Collins early on in the season, when all those stories came out about "They know what's wrong with my swing, it's a hitch we're going to fix in the offseason." Since April 24th you say?? Hmmm... You're welcome. ?
May 10, 20187 yr 2 hours ago, ChiliIrishHammock24 said: I honestly never watched him in the Cubs system. I did a couple of times (notice I said swing btw.) Edited May 10, 20187 yr by SoxAce
May 10, 20187 yr In the most successful offensive start for prospects in a sox Minor league system I can remember, I’m glad we have diagnosed that clearly Getz is a problem and ruining our prospects.
May 10, 20187 yr 18 hours ago, bmags said: The Sox have never seemed to be overly prescriptive in pushing swing changes or pitching mechanics changes before they become a hurdle and Getz himself has talked about letting players figure it out. the “Sox demanded he changed his swing to suck!” is probably much more “Sox and Collins worked together on how to accomplish a path in his swing he wanted, but it ended up being counterproductive and also is part of development” Hooray for the voice of reason.
May 13, 20187 yr On 5/9/2018 at 8:33 PM, CWSpalehoseCWS said: I agree, but just to play devil's advocate - we have no clue what the Sox staff had suggested to Collins so far this season, nor Collin's willingness to listen. For all we know that old swing may also be exploitable once the league gets more looks at him (though I hope not). Could the Sox perhaps push certain guys in the system to figure out their own adjustments as part of the development process? As a sidenote: Collins' splits are pretty drastic so far this year. He's hitting .288 against RHP while only sporting a .091 BA against southpaws (though both small sample sizes). Over his entire minor league career, he's now at .251/.182 vs. RHP/LHP. So he definitely appears to be at least average matchup against RHP and the strong side of a platoon role. I could easily live with that. Considering Zavala crushes LHP at a much better clip than righties, these two could form a very very good platoon here in a year or two.
May 16, 20187 yr This is a question and not a comment, but in the Comments section for the fangraphs mock draft, someone mentioned they read that some site has Collins listed as the worst framer in all of AA, AAA and MLB. Anyone familiar with this site?
May 16, 20187 yr I think he might never hit for average but he walks a ton. If he can improve his power and contact rate a little bit he maybe could become a Carlos Santana although he likely won't be as good of a contact hitter and thus more a 240 instead of 270 hitter. But if he hits 240/350/460 that would be pretty nice but the question is whether he can catch.
May 17, 20187 yr 21 hours ago, fathom said: This is a question and not a comment, but in the Comments section for the fangraphs mock draft, someone mentioned they read that some site has Collins listed as the worst framer in all of AA, AAA and MLB. Anyone familiar with this site? I think Fegan mentioned something along these lines in his Athletic article about Collins and Zavala.
May 17, 20187 yr He is merely 3rd worst in AA https://legacy.baseballprospectus.com/sortable/index.php?cid=2569650
May 17, 20187 yr On 5/15/2018 at 10:33 PM, fathom said: This is a question and not a comment, but in the Comments section for the fangraphs mock draft, someone mentioned they read that some site has Collins listed as the worst framer in all of AA, AAA and MLB. Anyone familiar with this site? Do you go out of your way to find negative things ? I mean look at that comment of yours . It reads like a friend of a friend said that a friend of a friend said this while just a few comments ago Fegan's twitter said Collins has greatly improved his ability to stick strikes on the corners Edited May 17, 20187 yr by CaliSoxFanViaSWside left out a word
May 17, 20187 yr 48 minutes ago, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said: Do you go out of your way to find negative things ? I mean look at that comment of yours . It reads like a friend of a friend said that a friend of a friend said this while just a few comments ago Fegan's twitter said Collins has greatly improved his ability to stick strikes on the corners Actually tried to word it as carefully as I could, as I had never heard that and you never know what to trust in a comments section
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.