How often each team has made the playoffs since being in their current city

[knightni]

 

[Snopek]

Yeah but think of all those big contracts the spending teams have regretted.

[CWSpalehoseCWS]

But we’ve been told no one wants to win more than Jerry!

Pathetic. 

[Quin]

On 12/9/2022 at 3:07 PM, Quin said:

This stat annoys me because until 1969, there wasn't even an LCS. We're all aware of the World Series drought, but this is "I am very smart" people trying to present it differently. It's basically ragging on the 50s and 60s White Sox for being worse than Mickey Mantle's Yankees during the regular season. 5 times they finished 2nd in the AL, 5 times they finished 3rd.

That being said, 53 years of playoff failure is also fucking abysmal, and Jerry has been in charge for 41 of those.

Have some respect for the Sox teams that had the misfortune of running into a dynastic buzzsaw. And we can get credit Comiskey's cheapness (sound familiar?) leading to the Sox being uncompetitive for decades.

Basically: Charles Comiskey and Jerry Reinsdorf suck, but don't lump the teams that tried to compete in with this.

[The Mighty Mite]

So sad.

[bmags]

21 playoff bids for cubs is that right? Is bid each playoff series?

[The Mighty Mite]

1 hour ago, bmags said:

21 playoff bids for cubs is that right? Is bid each playoff series?

The Cubs won 3 NL Pennants in the 30s and again in 1945 besides a few in the early 20th century. It is  WS wins that they have come up short, tied with us with 3 but we win the tie breaker for beating them in 1906 in the WS. I'm pretty sure they've  been in 11 WS to our 5.

Edited December 14, 2022 by The Mighty Mite

[A-Train to 35th]

The Sox suck is all I can say.  At least I can say I was frustrated with this team for a reason.

Time to move on and wait for a new owner.  The Met's never thought it would happen with the Wilpon family, and low and behold they now have Steve Cohen.

One can only hope.

[The Grinder]

Dead ass last. Depressing 

[Tnetennba]

3 hours ago, Quin said:

Have some respect for the Sox teams that had the misfortune of running into a dynastic buzzsaw. And we can get credit Comiskey's cheapness (sound familiar?) leading to the Sox being uncompetitive for decades.

Basically: Charles Comiskey and Jerry Reinsdorf suck, but don't lump the teams that tried to compete in with this.

Those 50s & 60s Sox teams would have made the post season most of those years if Division & Wild Card play existed back then.  The Sox while having a horrid history on paper get penalized for being around for so long under those old rules.  Those Yankees teams were loaded with all time greats.  Hard to hold that against other AL teams of that day for not stacking up. 

[Balta1701]

9 minutes ago, Tnetennba said:

Those 50s & 60s Sox teams would have made the post season most of those years if Division & Wild Card play existed back then.  The Sox while having a horrid history on paper get penalized for being around for so long under those old rules.  Those Yankees teams were loaded with all time greats.  Hard to hold that against other AL teams of that day for not stacking up. 

This is also why teams like the Red Sox, Guardians, and Tigers are in the bottom 5. 

[Tnetennba]

Don’t get me wrong, the Sox since expansion have been pretty awful at reaching the post season.  I’m definitely not letting them off the hook for their failures in the modern era, especially during JR’s tenure, but it’s unfortunate that their best era was played under different playoff rules.  

[ShoeLessRob]

This organization blows. 

[reiks12]

Sox fans will continue to be Jerry's pay pig, why change?

[CaliSoxFanViaSWside]

Technically there was no playoffs for a very long time.  There was just the World Series . The modern term "playoffs" means a series of steps to get you to the final series for a championship. One round like the World Series is a playoff.  But I doubt anyone used the word playoff very often. It was just the World Series. 2 rounds or more is playoffs.

The Sox are in last place because they had a long (sad) history before 1969 and the Yankees dominated in the AL and maybe the Cardinals in the NL.

Of course they haven't done much better since the modern playoffs started either.

[The Mighty Mite]

12 hours ago, Balta1701 said:

This is also why teams like the Red Sox, Guardians, and Tigers are in the bottom 5. 

I think you meant the Reds, the Red Sox are #11.

The Phillies have also been bad, just ahead of us of the original 16 franchises.

 

Edited December 15, 2022 by The Mighty Mite

[Balta1701]

51 minutes ago, The Mighty Mite said:

I think you meant the Reds, the Red Sox are #11.

The Phillies have also been bad, just ahead of us of the original 16 franchises.

 

[South Side Hit Men]

On 12/14/2022 at 2:29 PM, bmags said:

21 playoff bids for cubs is that right? Is bid each playoff series?

Chicago Cubs 21 Playoff Bids

• World Series (3) 1907, 1908, 2016
• NL Pennant (8) 1906, 1910, 1918, 1929, 1932, 1935, 1938, 1945
• NL East (2) 1984, 1989
• NL Central (5) 2003, 2007, 2008, 2017, 2020
• Wild Card (3) 1998, 2015, 2018

Not counted (6) (Pre 1903 National League Pennants 1876, 1880, 1881, 1882, 1885, 1886)

Chicago White Sox 11 Playoff Bids

• World Series (3) 1906, 1917, 2005
• AL Pennant (2) 1919, 1959
• AL West (2) 1983, 1993
• AL Central (3) 2000, 2008, 2021
• Wildcard (1) 2020

Edited December 15, 2022 by South Side Hit Men

[knightni]

Cubs was 2016, iirc.

[South Side Hit Men]

20 hours ago, Tnetennba said:

Don’t get me wrong, the Sox since expansion have been pretty awful at reaching the post season.  I’m definitely not letting them off the hook for their failures in the modern era, especially during JR’s tenure, but it’s unfortunate that their best era was played under different playoff rules.  

I’d argue the best generation (20 years) of White Sox baseball was 1901-1920, and would have gone much longer, possibly the best American League team in history, if Landis didn’t ban the eight acquitted White Sox players for life.

The White Sox were a juggernaut between 1917-1920, within 1/2 game of the 1920 Pennant until the accused players were suspended by Comiskey for their final series. They had a solid core and the team could have very well been competing for World Series into the 1920s and beyond if their substantial core wasn’t gutted. They were within 2.0 lost 1920 bWAR than Hahn entire 2022 team.

• Joe Jackson (7.5 Age 32)
• Happy Felsch (5.6 Age 28)
• Eddie Cicotte (5.1 Age 36)
• Buck Weaver (3.5 Age 29)
• Lefty Williams (3.5 Age 27)
• Swede Risberg (1.5 Age 25)
• Fred McMullin (-0.5 Age 28)

Net 1920 bWAR lost 26.2

Net 2022 bWAR 28.0 (11.2 H & 16.8 P)

Best White Sox Decades:

(Games +/- .500)

1. 1900s +169
2. 1950s + 154
3. 1910s +106
4. 1960s +102
5. 2000s +92
6. 1990s +81
7. 2020s +34
8. 1980s -44
9. 1920s -73
10. 1970s -101
11. 1940s -112
12. 2010s -135
13. 1930s -171

Net +102

• Comiskey Era (1900s - 1920s) +202
• Reinsdorf Era (1980s - 2020s) +28
• Allyn Era (1960s-1970s) +1
• Comiskey Descendants (1930s-1950s) -129