4 minutes ago, vilehoopster said:

You mean similar to how Vargas ended his 1st season with the Sox with a batting average of something like .093?

Seriously, Vargas’s average was something like that with the Sox in 2024.

I understand my take is a stretch, but the idea that it’s impossible that Acuna can/ will improve and become a quality centerfielder for the Sox for years, thinking that he can’t improve with his athletic ability, you’re just being silly.

Problem is he has already been relegated to the bench by Venable so it will be tough for him to get enough playing time to prove himself, unless more injuries occur. Meanwhile, both Peters and Kelenic are producing. You also have Grichuk and Hays sill eventually be back.

1 minute ago, WhiteSox2023 said:

Problem is he has already been relegated to the bench by Venable so it will be tough for him to get enough playing time to prove himself, unless more injuries occur. Meanwhile, both Peters and Kelenic are producing. You also have Grichuk and Hays sill eventually be back.

These are good points, plus if he becomes solid by next year, he’ll also have to compete with Brooks Baldwin and B. Montgomery. But still, with his speed, he could become the everyday Sox CF. I don’t think you can give up on him.

2 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:

Problem is he has already been relegated to the bench by Venable so it will be tough for him to get enough playing time to prove himself, unless more injuries occur. Meanwhile, both Peters and Kelenic are producing. You also have Grichuk and Hays sill eventually be back.

Yeah, as this group of guys comes off the IL, I can't see Acuña surviving that. If Kelenic gets hot as the plate, I could see Ant, Pereira and Kelenic being the starters. Hays, Peters, Hill on the bench. The only thing saving Acuña right now is he's the only backup IF.

6 hours ago, Timmy U said:

Also, Shelton and Bonemer.

Can't believe I forgot these two, especially Bonemer.

17 minutes ago, vilehoopster said:

You mean similar to how Vargas ended his 1st season with the Sox with a batting average of something like .093?

Seriously, Vargas’s average was something like that with the Sox in 2024.

I understand my take is a stretch, but the idea that it’s impossible that Acuna can/ will improve and become a quality centerfielder for the Sox for years, thinking that he can’t improve with his athletic ability, you’re just being silly.

The massive, massive difference being that Vargas didn't have to compete with dudes for playing time and the Sox were horrendous enough they could let him play through it.

If they want to make the playoffs, that ain't happening with Acuna.

12 minutes ago, Quin said:

Can't believe I forgot these two, especially Bonemer.

The massive, massive difference being that Vargas didn't have to compete with dudes for playing time and the Sox were horrendous enough they could let him play through it.

If they want to make the playoffs, that ain't happening with Acuna.

I think the Sox have crossed over. They still have gaps in their depth where somebody can come in and get playing time if they pick up and produce, like Kelenic. But the days of letting a guy fester with a .453 OPS for months of at-bats are behind us.

4 minutes ago, WestEddy said:

I think the Sox have crossed over. They still have gaps in their depth where somebody can come in and get playing time if they pick up and produce, like Kelenic. But the days of letting a guy fester with a .453 OPS for months of at-bats are behind us.

Indeed.

Edgar Quero is the prime example. Dude is going through hell right now and not hitting remotely like he's shown he can in the past, but they need him up so he's on the roster. But Romo is out performing him, so now Quero is sitting on the bench and we know is getting sent down once Teel comes up.

Over the last two years, Quero is getting the reps. This year he's sitting until they can send him down.

I think things would be different if Acuna had options.

15 hours ago, vilehoopster said:

You mean similar to how Vargas ended his 1st season with the Sox with a batting average of something like .093?

Seriously, Vargas’s average was something like that with the Sox in 2024.

I understand my take is a stretch, but the idea that it’s impossible that Acuna can/ will improve and become a quality centerfielder for the Sox for years, thinking that he can’t improve with his athletic ability, you’re just being silly.

Just because Vargas looks like he figured it out, doesn't mean anyone else will or won't. If their only similarity is that they struggled in their initial debuts, then buckle up because most guys who do that, end up out of baseball more often than the do as a good hitter.

15 hours ago, Quin said:

Indeed.

Edgar Quero is the prime example. Dude is going through hell right now and not hitting remotely like he's shown he can in the past, but they need him up so he's on the roster. But Romo is out performing him, so now Quero is sitting on the bench and we know is getting sent down once Teel comes up.

Over the last two years, Quero is getting the reps. This year he's sitting until they can send him down.

I think things would be different if Acuna had options.

I think the only reason they have Acuna on the roster is he's the primary backup at CF and SS. Honestly as the 26th man you can do worse. Just don't play him more than once a week.

10 minutes ago, chitownsportsfan said:

I think the only reason they have Acuna on the roster is he's the primary backup at CF and SS. Honestly as the 26th man you can do worse. Just don't play him more than once a week.

And only when absolutely necessary. Rather see see Sam move back into the IF with Chase over to SS if Colson is off.

16 hours ago, vilehoopster said:

These are good points, plus if he becomes solid by next year, he’ll also have to compete with Brooks Baldwin and B. Montgomery. But still, with his speed, he could become the everyday Sox CF. I don’t think you can give up on him.

The development window of this team at the MLB level is closing. There are still going to be guys who come up and need to adjust to the league and whatnot, but the team as a whole is past that stage. They're starting to take the next step to being a competitive team on a daily basis, and there's no time or room at this point to let someone "figure it out". If Acuna wants to prove he can be a viable everyday player then he needs to start showing that when he gets playing time.

1 minute ago, Bonerko4Konerko said:

The development window of this team at the MLB level is closing. There are still going to be guys who come up and need to adjust to the league and whatnot, but the team as a whole is past that stage. They're starting to take the next step to being a competitive team on a daily basis, and there's no time or room at this point to let someone "figure it out". If Acuna wants to prove he can be a viable everyday player then he needs to start showing that when he gets playing time.

Yep and it's obvious both Getz and Will are on the same page here. Wouldn't surprise me to see the same lineup again today as previous two. We are trying to win, development for a guy like Acuna doesn't really matter a hoot at this point. He's clearly a backup at best without a massive true talent jump and in his mid 20s unlikely. Same with Kelenic but Kelenic has caught some lighting in a bottle and we can just ride it until it fades.

5 minutes ago, chitownsportsfan said:

Wouldn't surprise me to see the same lineup again today as previous two.

Sorry

1 hour ago, chitownsportsfan said:

I think the only reason they have Acuna on the roster is he's the primary backup at CF and SS. Honestly as the 26th man you can do worse. Just don't play him more than once a week.

He's in at SS today

9 hours ago, Chick Mercedes said:

What a stud…

30 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:

What a stud…

The k/ip is insane for that high an ERA.

6 minutes ago, caulfield12 said:

The k/ip is insane for that high an ERA.

Yep, his stuff must be good but he has zero control. 27 walks in 29.2 innings. All opposing batters have to do is not swing. He won’t make the majors like that.

Edited May 16May 16 by WhiteSox2023

On 5/13/2026 at 6:50 AM, Quin said:

Acuna

Will be on the DFA train sooner than later

April 30: "What they're telling us is this should be a short stint on the IL," Mendoza said. Hopefully a little after the 10 days we'll get him back, but we just got to wait and see how he responds to the epidural."

May 26:

27 minutes ago, DoUEvenShift said:

April 30: "What they're telling us is this should be a short stint on the IL," Mendoza said. Hopefully a little after the 10 days we'll get him back, but we just got to wait and see how he responds to the epidural."

May 26:

Oh no that’s too bad. Who could have possibly seen this coming.

Edited Wednesday at 12:41 AM4 days by Bob Sacamano

Acuna sucks but would we really have preferred to gamble on Robert only for him to sit out half the season and not move anywhere?

1 hour ago, Bob Sacamano said:

Acuna sucks but would we really have preferred to gamble on Robert only for him to sit out half the season and not move anywhere?

The only win in the trade is the freeing up of money. Acuna and Pauley both suck but $19 million and a $2 million buyout is a good pile of cash.

2 hours ago, Bob Sacamano said:

Acuna sucks but would we really have preferred to gamble on Robert only for him to sit out half the season and not move anywhere?

I'm so done with worrying about Yoan, Eloy and Robert. There's another option in that contract. Seriously, we'd be doing this again next winter. Dude, buy a sailboat.

4 hours ago, WestEddy said:

I'm so done with worrying about Yoan, Eloy and Robert. There's another option in that contract. Seriously, we'd be doing this again next winter. Dude, buy a sailboat.

Yeah I’m glad to be off that ride

I don't think there was anyone who didn't see that coming. Looks like a bad trade for both parties. The Sox at least dumped the salary and have a maybe in Pauley.