3 hours ago3 hr 1 hour ago, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said:Mostly May is one of the 90% of the starting pitchers on the Market no one wants to see the Sox signing. How does that sound ?That ONLY leaves Skubal King Peralta Rogers Taira (mixed bag)...not so sure about Holmes.
3 hours ago3 hr 2 hours ago, wegner said:I remember plenty here wanting to trade for Gray before the wrong Sox went on their torrid run and backed off from selling.To finish the year, though.He's going to be 37 and a solid regresion candidate if you look at overall track record over last 3-4 years.Definitely buying high here.
3 hours ago3 hr 40 minutes ago, chitownsportsfan said:Keep going back and forth between giving this like a straight C or just a fail. Is there upside? Yea, he'll be two years off the revision surgery and there's some evidence (like strand rate) he was the victim of some bad luck. But also, you push someone like Sandlin down, who probably could have given you a very similar season basically for free instead of at 17 million.My hope is that he has a Fedde like year, maybe slightly better, for 17 million, even in today's environment, that just seems pretty pedestrian.Again, would feel better out it if we knew Castillo was demoted or was simply never acquired. May and Castillo are a pretty shitty 4th and 5th starter on paper.The betting line would probably be around a 2 fWAR.That's pretty much in line with his salary...but does he stay healthy enough to get there???Pedestrian move, overall.Just like throwing darts against the wall, except Castillo and May aren't exactly at bargain basement prices.Guardians never do this deal in a million years.There's just no way that if Ishbia were coming in as owner it would be any other option than Skubal King Peralta or at least Taira from a marketing/lower cost but fascinating acquisition angle (since Imai Sasaki and Imanaga mixed results push down his value a bit.) Edited 3 hours ago3 hr by caulfield12
3 hours ago3 hr 55 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:It’s ok to not like a move in the moment. Sure, you can’t really trade it until plays out but it’s ok to not like it when it happens.the f*** else we gonna talk about, the lockout or the new stadium? might as well discuss an actual signing.
2 hours ago2 hr https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7789996/2026/11/17/dustin-may-mlb-signing-analysis-white-sox/
2 hours ago2 hr 7 hours ago, Baron said:That's a lazy comparisonPerhaps the worst comparison I have ever seen
2 hours ago2 hr Brewers board is baffled...totally worth a readHow does May keep pulling off these 8 figure deals, All other FA pitchers just gave May a high 5 and thank you. It's the prize behind the puzzle. If you are built like a big leaguer and have the physical tools of a big leaguer ... teams can't help themselves believing they can be the one to unlock you.I'll never forget sitting and talking with a White Sox scout during a TBRays game in the early 2000s. We had a guy on the team named Mike Wilson, outfielder. Built like a middle linebacker. He struggled early season and was striking out a ton, not getting on base. But when he connected with one he hit it over Hwy 41. We had another outfielder on that team named Sebastien Boucher. Canadian kid, centerfielder. I thought he was awesome. Dylan O'Rae type of hitter, not a ton of power but all fields and was always on base. He matched Asdrubal Cabrera's production day in and day out.This guy wasn't giving Boucher a 2nd look because "not a MLB body, he won't make it". But he was salivating over Wilson. "He will be able to withstand the grind" "Major league fastballs won't intimidate him". He could have cared less about the at bat to at bat results ... he was looking for a body that could be put into the machine.May is 6'6 and has a tool bag that should dazzle. Whoever unlocks it has a TOR guy. Can anyone unlock it is the question. Most want to try." Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by caulfield12
2 hours ago2 hr https://brewerfanatic.com/forums/topic/48780-may-to-white-sox-3-yrs-525-m/#comments"A good reminder of why the Brewers don’t sign free agents, especially EARLY in the off season (when the bargains aren't there, and overpays abound). I thought Dustin May would work out for us, at least better than he did. My inkling is that whatever adjustments we tried to make with him just weren’t sticking and he ended up performing worse for us than he did with the Cardinals. I hope he pitches well for the White Sox.""May just got more money than Bauers... Let that one sink in. 😬Yes, he is 2 years younger and Bauers is a risk for regressing... but May doesn't have anything but "potential" (i.e. a big arm) and no real history of results to back him up. The cost of starting pitching... woof" Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by caulfield12
2 hours ago2 hr 8 hours ago, Baron said:Starting market is yuckyNeeded to sign a SP last offseason. Big oversight in my view.
2 hours ago2 hr 3 minutes ago, nrockway said:Needed to sign a SP last offseason. Big oversight in my view.Overpaid for Castillo and now May.Sox just don't learn to wait out second and third tier markets until the last week or two and even into ST.Did the same with Grandal.Did the same with Robertson/Cabrera.Did the same with LaRoche.Or wait too long and get stuck with "bargain" Dallas Keuchel after his expiration date because they refused to pay for TOR frontline guys.But but but look how being the last one standing for Murakami and the Peters deals worked out so well…patience is a virtue! Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by caulfield12
2 hours ago2 hr 5 hours ago, Colome's Hat said:Only for two more seasons. Much of this will be Ishbia's bill to foot.Hopefully it's only 2 more years.
2 hours ago2 hr 7 hours ago, chw42 said:You can't just look at ERA, but nothing about May's last 2 years says he was overly unlucky. People hit the ball hard off him. He doesn't get a ton of grounders. The stuff is good, but if he hangs a sweeper every start and it gets hit for a homer, is that unlucky? He pitched well for the Cardinals last year, but Busch Stadium is one of the best parks for suppressing homers. He then went to a more neutral park in Milwaukee and gave up 1.72 HR/9 in 10 starts. The stuff is definitely intriguing, but we definitely need the coaching staff to get him to be more consistent. We thought we could fix a guy Seattle couldn't figure out last year. Now we're thinking we know more than the team that just won the World Series.The team that just won the World Series traded for him at the deadline. Clearly there was something they liked about him. Not sure ten or so starts with the Brewers means he is suddenly unfixable.
2 hours ago2 hr 12 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:The team that just won the World Series traded for him at the deadline. Clearly there was something they liked about him. Not sure ten or so starts with the Brewers means he is suddenly unfixable.And gave up solid prospects for him, too.Every Sox decade needs an Alex Rios/Javy V. type player that scouts fall in love with…but actual results on the field inevitably end up leaving fans disappointed. Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by caulfield12
1 hour ago1 hr 3 hours ago, JoshPR said:They won't open the pickets for Skubal but they do this ... Head scratcherSkubal is going to get like 9/$400M…this isn’t in the same stratosphere of comparable options.
1 hour ago1 hr 9 hours ago, southsider2k5 said:It's the eternal Sox debate. They would rather have multiples from Bucket C than one from Bucket A. .Yep. However, the bucket A guys have to want to sign with the Sox, and without some sustained success, that’s not a guarantee.Hopefully the strategy is to improve the roster without trading away assets, and maybe that makes the Sox a better option for bucket A and B guys the rest of the offseason. I’d be fine if they only sign starters this winter.
1 hour ago1 hr SIDustin May’s Deal With the White Sox Is Music to the Ears...May’s three-year deal addresses Chicago’s biggest need and is unlikely to blow up in the team’s face, but it sets a generous precedent for his archetype.Free agent starters and their agents sending thank yous/flowers/gift baskets to Getz for setting market high…lolHe might already be losing his Executive of the Year votes, lol.Noted that Kay Schultz Hagen might be needed for rotation since likely won’t go with five righties.Taira anyone? Edited 1 hour ago1 hr by caulfield12
1 hour ago1 hr 2 hours ago, chitownsportsfan said:Keep going back and forth between giving this like a straight C or just a fail. Is there upside? Yea, he'll be two years off the revision surgery and there's some evidence (like strand rate) he was the victim of some bad luck. But also, you push someone like Sandlin down, who probably could have given you a very similar season basically for free instead of at 17 million.My hope is that he has a Fedde like year, maybe slightly better, for 17 million, even in today's environment, that just seems pretty pedestrian.Again, would feel better out it if we knew Castillo was demoted or was simply never acquired. May and Castillo are a pretty shitty 4th and 5th starter on paper.Fedde put up -0.1 fWAR last year while May put up 2.8 fWAR. Dustin posted the 6th most fWAR amongst all FA SPs last year and more than both King & Peralta. He was 36th overall in fWAR amongst 120 SPs who pitched over 100 innings. I think people aren’t realizing this is what a mid rotation starter looks like. There are certainly red flags here, durability being one, but his peripherals last year imply something much better than a “shitty #4 starter”.
1 hour ago1 hr 7 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:Fedde put up -0.1 fWAR last year while May put up 2.8 fWAR. Dustin posted the 6th most fWAR amongst all FA SPs last year and more than both King & Peralta. He was 36th overall in fWAR amongst 120 SPs who pitched over 100 innings. I think people aren’t realizing this is what a mid rotation starter looks like. There are certainly red flags here, durability being one, but his peripherals last year imply something much better than a “shitty #4 starter”.But how would you feel if May was the top starter acquired this offseason?
1 hour ago1 hr 11 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:Fedde put up -0.1 fWAR last year while May put up 2.8 fWAR. Dustin posted the 6th most fWAR amongst all FA SPs last year and more than both King & Peralta. He was 36th overall in fWAR amongst 120 SPs who pitched over 100 innings. I think people aren’t realizing this is what a mid rotation starter looks like. There are certainly red flags here, durability being one, but his peripherals last year imply something much better than a “shitty #4 starter”.Recency bias…everyone remembers Fedde down the stretch and in the playoffs on a $1.5 million spec salary.
1 hour ago1 hr 18 minutes ago, Middle Buffalo said:Yep. However, the bucket A guys have to want to sign with the Sox, and without some sustained success, that’s not a guarantee.Hopefully the strategy is to improve the roster without trading away assets, and maybe that makes the Sox a better option for bucket A and B guys the rest of the offseason. I’d be fine if they only sign starters this winter.A guys sign for A contracts.
1 hour ago1 hr 1 minute ago, WhiteSox2023 said:But how would you feel if May was the top starter acquired this offseason?I’ll be pissed. The Sox need a legit starter to anchor the top of the rotation and it needs to come from free agency. King or Peralta are the obvious targets. I really don’t think this move precludes them from doing that. I always felt they’d add two SPs this offseason (one top & one mid) and it’s not like the A & B tier arms have signed yet. Might as well lock someone up from the tier C tier while you wait on the more premium options to get serious about signing.And by no means am I in love with the May move, but I’d rather gamble on the ceiling of a 29 year old former top 25 prospect who has missed a considerable amount of major league development time than the high floor alternative in this price range. If May is competing with another high risk, high reward guy in Taylor for the #3 spot, then I am very content with this as the secondary move.
1 hour ago1 hr 5 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:I’ll be pissed. The Sox need a legit starter to anchor the top of the rotation and it needs to come from free agency. King or Peralta are the obvious targets. I really don’t think this move precludes them from doing that. I always felt they’d add two SPs this offseason (one top & one mid) and it’s not like the A & B tier arms have signed yet. Might as well lock someone up from the tier C tier while you wait on the more premium options to get serious about signing.And by no means am I in love with the May move, but I’d rather gamble on the ceiling of a 29 year old former top 25 prospect who has missed a considerable amount of major league development time than the high floor alternative in this price range. If May is competing with another high risk, high reward guy in Taylor for the #3 spot, then I am very content with this as the secondary move.If they don’t land King or Peralta I wouldn’t mind Holmes
1 hour ago1 hr King and Peralta are going to be way above a price they’re comfortable with. I think they add one more starter in the same range as May.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.