1 hour ago1 hr 1 minute ago, Nardiwashere said:I find it funny that the people who hate this trade keep saying "We need pitching and gave up two arms" as if the problem was that the Sox's literally couldn't find enough guys to fill a roster.It would be like if someone had a poorly furnished apartment, needed a good couch in the living room, a dining room table, etc.Are you going to get pissed off that they tossed the beanbag chair and folding card table to make room for the new stuff?Depends, did they spent 25 million dollars on the beanbag chair a few months ago and then throw out the perfectly good new TV to get someone to take the beanbag chair?
1 hour ago1 hr 2 minutes ago, Nardiwashere said:I find it funny that the people who hate this trade keep saying "We need pitching and gave up two arms" as if the problem was that the Sox's literally couldn't find enough guys to fill a roster.It would be like if someone had a poorly furnished apartment, needed a good couch in the living room, a dining room table, etc.Are you going to get pissed off that they tossed the beanbag chair and folding card table to make room for the new stuff?Perfect analogy. I used "clear out dead wood to plant new trees" but yours is better.
1 hour ago1 hr 1 minute ago, chitownsportsfan said:is there gonna be a grace period on the floor too? sounds like there might be. fucking sucks we get relevant just as the cba expires. as sox fans, figures.I would almost think there would have to be some kind of grace period on that but who knows.Hopefully not so some team needs to trade for Benintendi to reach the floor (with no other options available hopefully) Edited 1 hour ago1 hr by Bob Sacamano
1 hour ago1 hr They can agree but it sounds like the QA is still in play but it won't have the draft pick compensation tied to it if both sides agree to get rid of it in next cba. Theres going to be a ton of changes in the next cba that includes tho time its agreed upon that will take affect once its in place unless they push some back to 2028 Edited 1 hour ago1 hr by Whisox05
1 hour ago1 hr 3 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:Depends, did they spent 25 million dollars on the beanbag chair a few months ago and then throw out the perfectly good new TV to get someone to take the beanbag chair?But that has nothing to do with this trade. Are we evaluating Getz? Or are we evaluating this trade?If we are evaluating Getz, then the original Castillo trade absolutely should be discussed as an awful trade. But if we are just evaluating this trade, then saying we gave away two arms when we are short on arms doesn’t make much sense if the two arms we gave away couldn’t even be trusted to start a single playoff game.
1 hour ago1 hr 7 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:Depends, did they spent 25 million dollars on the beanbag chair a few months ago and then throw out the perfectly good new TV to get someone to take the beanbag chair?Davis Martin is more of a side table that just kind of blends into the room. Saying he is a TV is BLASPHEMY.
1 hour ago1 hr Just now, southsider2k5 said:Depends, did they spent 25 million dollars on the beanbag chair a few months ago and then throw out the perfectly good new TV to get someone to take the beanbag chair?If I bought a big heavy ugly bookcase I realized was a mistake and didn't want anymore and someone from Facebook marketplace agreed to come and remove it for free and all I had to do was give them a 32-inch Hisense that I could easily replace whenever I wanted on Amazon for $109 bucks, yeah, why not.
58 minutes ago58 min 2 minutes ago, SoxBlanco said:But that has nothing to do with this trade. Are we evaluating Getz? Or are we evaluating this trade?If we are evaluating Getz, then the original Castillo trade absolutely should be discussed as an awful trade.But if we are just evaluating this trade, then saying we gave away two arms when we are short on arms doesn’t make much sense if the two arms we gave away couldn’t even be trusted to start a single playoff game.Look, by this logic, we should be dumping half of the roster, as a large piece of it was unplayable. Colson Montgomery? Eh, package him with Benny to save some money. He was great the first half, but was one of the worst players in baseball the second half and was basically unplayable, except the Sox had no one to replace him. Sound familiar? Of course a week ago, Davis Martin was going to keep growing and was one of the five starters because he was going to be closer to the first half than the second half by getting through a season. But now that he got traded, he is trash to be thrown out because he will never be good again.
56 minutes ago56 min 2 minutes ago, Nardiwashere said:If I bought a big heavy ugly bookcase I realized was a mistake and didn't want anymore and someone from Facebook marketplace agreed to come and remove it for free and all I had to do was give them a 32-inch Hisense that I could easily replace whenever I wanted on Amazon for $109 bucks, yeah, why not.Communist!!!Just joking. We don't allow my 11 year old son to even watch TV simply by not having one.That said, PUBG Delta Force Minecraft and Miniworld on the iPad have entirely rewired his brain.
55 minutes ago55 min 5 minutes ago, Nardiwashere said:If I bought a big heavy ugly bookcase I realized was a mistake and didn't want anymore and someone from Facebook marketplace agreed to come and remove it for free and all I had to do was give them a 32-inch Hisense that I could easily replace whenever I wanted on Amazon for $109 bucks, yeah, why not.Eh, put that piece of s%*# on the curb and call the city to come get it, like a normal person.
53 minutes ago53 min 4 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:Look, by this logic, we should be dumping half of the roster, as a large piece of it was unplayable. Colson Montgomery? Eh, package him with Benny to save some money. He was great the first half, but was one of the worst players in baseball the second half and was basically unplayable, except the Sox had no one to replace him. Sound familiar? Of course a week ago, Davis Martin was going to keep growing and was one of the five starters because he was going to be closer to the first half than the second half by getting through a season. But now that he got traded, he is trash to be thrown out because he will never be good again.You think Davis Martin and Colson Montgomery have the same value right now?
51 minutes ago51 min 1 minute ago, Nardiwashere said:You think Davis Martin and Colson Montgomery have the same value right now?You think Davis Martin can't help this team next year?
50 minutes ago50 min 13 minutes ago, PaleAleSox said:Davis Martin is more of a side table that just kind of blends into the room. Saying he is a TV is BLASPHEMY.I mean, he really tied the room together, did he not??
47 minutes ago47 min Don't forget the blister and then his knee tweak down the stretch as well...Or maybe the soon to be franchise record holder for futility wants 60% White Sox starters in their rotation and are now genuinely headed in the right direction under Moneyball 3/Broncos' (non Monfort) leadership...?
42 minutes ago42 min 1 minute ago, southsider2k5 said:You think Davis Martin can't help this team next year?I think he'd be a #4-5 starter and far from irreplaceable. You can find guys who can do what he'd do.Sounds like you think he's much better than that. Getz and JR have higher standards than you, I guess.
40 minutes ago40 min 1 minute ago, Nardiwashere said:I think he'd be a #4-5 starter and far from irreplaceable. You can find guys who can do what he'd do.Sounds like you think he's much better than that. Getz and JR have higher standards than you, I guess.Well, the concern would be that May may be no better than a #4/#5 and Getz just spent $17.5 million a year on him. Hopefully he is a solid #3 going forward.
37 minutes ago37 min 4 minutes ago, Nardiwashere said:I think he'd be a #4-5 starter and far from irreplaceable. You can find guys who can do what he'd do.Sounds like you think he's much better than that. Getz and JR have higher standards than you, I guess.Just a few days ago, I had someone tell me that Dustin May's deal was the going rate for a backend/5th starter. We are probably talking $50 million in pitching contracts (per year) to find a front line AND another 5th starter at market rates. Do you believe they are actually going to do this? I sure don't.
35 minutes ago35 min 3 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Well, the concern would be that May may be no better than a #4/#5 and Getz just spent $17.5 million a year on him. Hopefully he is a solid #3 going forward.You think if Davis Martin was a free agent, he would get the same contract as Dustin May?
27 minutes ago27 min 2 hours ago, Dick Allen said:The question will be is the next pitcher they sign better than MartinDamn well better be.
27 minutes ago27 min 4 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:Just a few days ago, I had someone tell me that Dustin May's deal was the going rate for a backend/5th starter. We are probably talking $50 million in pitching contracts (per year) to find a front line AND another 5th starter at market rates. Do you believe they are actually going to do this? I sure don't.Yeah, not sure what that guy was talking about. Maybe I missed the trend, but I don't think 5th starter types sign for $18 mil/year for 3 years. Edited 10 minutes ago10 min by Nardiwashere
19 minutes ago19 min 15 minutes ago, Nardiwashere said:You think if Davis Martin was a free agent, he would get the same contract as Dustin May?May is better but I don’t think the difference is as huge as you are making it. And Martin is making peanuts for the next 4 years.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.