22 minutes ago22 min Idk how anyone can really have a problem with this. Yeah, he fucked up making the first trade. I’m ok with people having a problem with that move. But he found a sucker to dump that mistake on. I for one am happy to never watch him pitch for the Sox again
21 minutes ago21 min 1 minute ago, WhiteSox2023 said:The return is seriously inconsequential. It was a straight salary dump for two guys that will likely never make the majors.Then dump Benintendi instead. Castillo could be redeemable.
21 minutes ago21 min 7 minutes ago, Colome's Hat said:The thing I probably love the most about Getz and Venable is how ruthless they both are.The sign of an elite leader is one that is willing to admit a mistake immediately rather than continue walking the wrong way -- "the Godfather is a man that insists on hearing bad news as soon as possible".Some of the chattering baboons here are happier they were "proven right" about the Castillo deal than that their GM immediately righted a mistake. The castillo deal is done and dusted, it had zero to do with today's move and now, it only hurt them for three months, instead of another season.The Sox aren't "desperate" for 1 WAR 5th and 6th starters. Nobody is. Those guys are literally available every spring for a MiLB invite or are already on your AAA team. That we got rid of a 5th and 6th starter and saved 27 million is BRILIANT WORK. Edited 19 minutes ago19 min by chitownsportsfan
20 minutes ago20 min Just now, JoeC said:The Rockies are pre-empting the salary floor requirement, I see, between the Castillo contract and the Kris Bryant contract.(For reference, see the NHL's crazy trades in the immediate post-lockout salary cap era)Exactly. They get maybe a league average starter in Martin, and some added payroll for a season to possibly clear that hurdle of a salary floor. Edited 19 minutes ago19 min by Bob Sacamano
20 minutes ago20 min Just now, WhiteSox2023 said:The people voted the right way.Glad you think him not winning is a huge knock on the year he put together so you can bring this up forever like you did the Diamondbacks outfielder no one remembers.
19 minutes ago19 min Just now, Bob Sacamano said:Idk how anyone can really have a problem with this. Yeah, he fucked up making the first trade. I’m ok with people having a problem with that move. But he found a sucker to dump that mistake on. I for one am happy to never watch him pitch for the Sox againNo one regrets dumping Castillo. I do think people are underestimating including 4 cheap years of a potential league average starter. He likely won’t have success at Coors, but who does? Getz just likely spent $52 million for a league average starter.
19 minutes ago19 min 1 minute ago, chitownsportsfan said:The sign of an elite leader is one that is willing to admit a mistake immediately rather than continue walking the wrong way -- "the Godfather is a man that insists on hearing bad news as soon as possible".Some of the chattering baboons here are happier they were "proven right" about the Castillo deal then that their GM immediately righted a mistake. The castillo deal is done and dusted, it had zero to do with today's move and now, it only hurt them for three months, instead of another season.Yeah hopefully use that bad trade as a learning experience
19 minutes ago19 min 1 minute ago, Bob Sacamano said:Exactly. They get maybe a league average starter in Martin, and some added payroll for a season to possibly clear that hurdle of a floor.The odds that Martin is league average at coors are close to 10%. There's a greater chance he's unpitchable imo. Martin was arguably the worst pitcher in MLB in the 2nd half.
18 minutes ago18 min 1 minute ago, PaleAleSox said:Glad you think him not winning is a huge knock on the year he put together so you can bring this up forever like you did the Diamondbacks outfielder no one remembers.Bad trades are bad trades. Everyone and their grandmother knew the Sox needed 2 starters at the trade deadline to win the division and go deep in the playoffs. He got one and he chose poorly. If you want to forget that, it’s your prerogative. Edited 18 minutes ago18 min by WhiteSox2023
18 minutes ago18 min Just now, chitownsportsfan said:The odds that Martin is league average at coors are close to 10%. There's a greater chance he's unpitchable imo. Martin was arguably the worst pitcher in MLB in the 2nd half.Agree. No argument here. Definitely a weird trade for them but I’m not complaining. They like Davis Martin they can have him and Luis Castillo’s salary lol
17 minutes ago17 min 1 minute ago, chitownsportsfan said:The odds that Martin is league average at coors are close to 10%. There's a greater chance he's unpitchable imo. Martin was arguably the worst pitcher in MLB in the 2nd half.I already said this. But throw May in Coors and see what happens as well.
17 minutes ago17 min Also non-tender deadline is tomorrow so there should be at least a few minor deals across the league.
16 minutes ago16 min Just now, Bob Sacamano said:Also non-tender deadline is tomorrow so there should be at least a few minor deals across the league.Rule 5 is incoming too. Lotta good comes out of opening 40 man spots. Not that I think the Sox will draft anybody, but if their scouts see someone they like, now they can potentially make a move.
16 minutes ago16 min 1 minute ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Bad trades are bad trades. Everyone and their grandmother knew the Sox needed 2 starters at the trade deadline to win the division and go deep in the playoffs. He got one and he chose poorly. If you want to forget that, it’s your prerogative.Who said I’m forgetting it? Yeah he didn’t have a good trade deadline, he also has this team way ahead of where anyone else thought they’d be. Both can be true.
16 minutes ago16 min Just now, WhiteSox2023 said:I already said this. But throw May in Coors and see what happens as well.So are you arguing that this trade in a vacuum was bad? Or are you just arguing that Getz sucks?
15 minutes ago15 min Just now, chitownsportsfan said:Rule 5 is incoming too. Lotta good comes out of opening 40 man spots. Not that I think the Sox will draft anybody, but if their scouts see someone they like, now they can potentially make a move.Is it? That’s scheduled for during the Lockout, unless I missed that it was moved up.
14 minutes ago14 min Just now, SoxBlanco said:So are you arguing that this trade in a vacuum was bad? Or are you just arguing that Getz sucks?I guess I’m not looking at it in a vacuum. The trade deadline wasn’t even 4 months ago. The reason Getz had to make this salary dump is because of a move he literally just made 3.5 months ago. It’s all related.
13 minutes ago13 min 1 minute ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Bad trades are bad trades. Everyone and their grandmother knew the Sox needed 2 starters at the trade deadline to win the division and go deep in the playoffs. He got one and he chose poorly. If you want to forget that, it’s your prerogative.Dude we’ve already been over this. There were two pitchers worth a damn traded at the deadline. Skubal and Mahle. The rest were bad to horrific. The Sox didn’t have the bullets for Skubal and Mahle was a guy the Braves had been after for a while because they thought they had a fix for his struggles - turns out they did.
13 minutes ago13 min 1 minute ago, Bonemer, I Hardly Know Her said:Getz calling Jerry to tell him he traded Castillo.Gotta love the fast forward montages in 80’s movies.
13 minutes ago13 min 1 minute ago, Bob Sacamano said:Is it? That’s scheduled for during the Lockout, unless I missed that it was moved up.I honestly have no clue what league biz will and won't be done under the lockout. Any or all, I have no idea. Isn't Rule 5 usually 2nd week of Dec? Are we officially locked out at start of new league calendar in two weeks?
13 minutes ago13 min 5 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:No one regrets dumping Castillo. I do think people are underestimating including 4 cheap years of a potential league average starter. He likely won’t have success at Coors, but who does? Getz just likely spent $52 million for a league average starter.Rockies took all the Castillo contract?The only reason would be meeting a salary floor...that makes any sense.They will get better results from Mason Adams than either of these two guys.
13 minutes ago13 min Just now, almagest said:Dude we’ve already been over this. There were two pitchers worth a damn traded at the deadline. Skubal and Mahle. The rest were bad to horrific. The Sox didn’t have the bullets for Skubal and Mahle was a guy the Braves had been after for a while because they thought they had a fix for his struggles - turns out they did.Freddy Peralta was a pretty damn good get for the Rays
13 minutes ago13 min Just now, chitownsportsfan said:I honestly have no clue what league biz will and won't be done under the lockout. Any or all, I have no idea. Isn't Rule 5 usually 2nd week of Dec? Are we officially locked out at start of new league calendar in two weeks?Rule 5 won't happen
12 minutes ago12 min Just now, WhiteSox2023 said:I guess I’m not looking at it in a vacuum. The trade deadline wasn’t even 4 months ago. The reason Getz had to make this salary dump is because of a move he literally just made 3.5 months ago. It’s all related.So you’re just judging Getz, not this specific trade. If a brand new GM came in and this was his first move to clean up Getz’ mess, how would you feel about the trade?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.