Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Chisoxfn

Admin
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Chisoxfn

  1. I like seeing the club be willing to take on payroll but this seems like a very strange trade for Sox and by strange it seems stupid. That contract is flat out but bad unless we think there is a minor adjustment needed and his stuff is still well above average. In fairness it is one bad season but he is also on older side.
  2. Is this confirmed - he's going to Tampa or you are just speculating.
  3. Maybe building on this, but if he came over and pitched like he has the past few years down the stretch for the Sox, you could go down the route of a qualifying offer to either retain him or get back a pick (so regain some of that capital). Obviously plenty of scenarios where he isn't worth that qualifying offer - but if was becoming a free agent a year ago, I think he would have gotten that offer.
  4. I definitely think there is likely major risk and he may be more of an eventual AAAA player. I won't pretend to know his dynamics around the tools they see in terms of swing speed, etc.
  5. Them, a Mason Adams, are all in play I think.
  6. Is that a Mets leak...I'd say that is a pretty good deal for the Mets on an expiring starter who has been at best league average and in reality he's been a negative WAR pitcher this year. Club better think they have a way to fix things otherwise I don't see this being that attractive. I don't mind those names being dangled (although I think Boston Smith is going to keep rising).
  7. Chisoxfn replied to BamaDoc's topic in FutureSox Board
    I think he showed when his command was there at the big league level his stuff played just fine, but he still had to tighten that command up a bit more to have sustained success at the big league level. And it isn't that his command was bad, but early on as a rookie I think he had the typically rookie struggle where you over threw a bit and hadn't yet settled. Plus it takes a bit to really learn how to make adjustments against big leaguers as well. I think a healthy Thorpe has a very clear floor as a #3 or #4 starter. Dude is a very solid pitcher. I also don't think he has much chance of being a #1 or #2 to be clear.
  8. Agree with you completely on McDougal.
  9. If I'm giving up someone like Carlson I like this approach far more then the Detmers type of moves. Presuming no one thinks Webb is due for a longer-term regression (ie is his stuff declining). Also make sure he profiles okay at the Rate vs. Oracle.
  10. Schultz clearly has shown sustained periods (in the minors) of elite stuff, with inconsistent mechanics and command. He also is very lengthy which can make repeatability a bit of a challenge early in their careers. These are the exact type of individuals you do not give up on. He's still 22 year's old and has 6 more years of control as well. I would not be surprised if he was one of the better LHP's in all of baseball for a good chunk of that time. Hagen Smith is a bit different, as his sustained periods of elite stuff has been a little more mixed as he really exploded in his final college season and then has flashed it at times in the minors, but with a bit less consistency as he's worked through mechanical issues. I have less conviction here than I do with Noah, but I am still pretty convinced worse case you are talking about a guy who is an elite set-up man and best case he has what it takes to be a front of the rotation pitcher (ie a 1, 2, or #3 pitcher in a rotation). McDougal is close to Schultz in my mind, with the major question here (as with all pitchers) being sustainable health. But I think his floor is the highest of this trio of prospects and I am a bit dissaopinted we couldn't continue to stretch him out so he could build on his 110+ innings last year in the minors, because right now it is pretty clear he's going to see a substantial set back in innings pitched as the club worked to get him stretched out for the rotation. With that said - his stuff is high end - he has the physical build you look for in front of the rotation starters, and as a floor, I think he will be an excellent reliver, but would hate to see him limited there. He has been consistently excellent after whatever adjustments he made from 24 into 25. Note: How they develop and what the right mix of minor league development vs. major league development will be key. I don't know what it is, but I think McDougal is the individual of the trio who will have more immediate sustained MLB success because I think his command and repeatability is best suited mixed with that stuff. Not saying he's going to come out and be an ace right away, but I think he'll be a serviceable big leaguer out of the gate and then grow from there.
  11. Chisoxfn replied to BamaDoc's topic in FutureSox Board
    McDougall is a long term front of the rotation starter if his arm is healthy. Meanwhile he will be able to make an impact in our bullpen down the stretch I think.
  12. That is what my eye test tells me - he is throwing a sinker that is pure lethal. 102 mph sinker is something I’ve never seen thrown.
  13. Will Twins pick up the payroll or pay a bit more on prospect side.
  14. Solid reliever - wonder what the cost was?
  15. I don’t want to see Detmers and Sox. I want to see Sox next to expiring starters who have been good but with big contracts that allow us to give minimal draft capital. If you give elite talent - be like Preller and go get elite talent back (not mediocre guys like Reid Detmer)
  16. I will be so pissed if we trade an elite prospect at a premium for a slightly above average starter because he has control. Would be awful. Ray or Clay Holmes are better than Detmers and either and or both could be had without giving up one of our high upside guys. How stupid could we be if we gave up the better prospect solely to have an extra year of control with a payroll that is as low as this clubs.
  17. Chisoxfn replied to BamaDoc's topic in FutureSox Board
    I think he can very much be a Kyle Hendricks type - which is pretty darn solid and valuable.
  18. I think back in 94 no one got paid but a deal came off the contract…meaning Mune would be a free agent
  19. I am dreaming of Skubal to the Sox for 5yr 250 under the new CBA! Will be like the post lockout Albert Belle 5yr 55M move (but will work way better!)
  20. I’m very excited for the positional talent and what’s coming given what we have seen. I hope we have an ownership group and front office that can supplement it with some free agent pitching. Stick to using some payroll 💪 and not use top 10 prospects to add some expiring pitching depth to help now. Dont pay a premium for mediocre cost control when we have a 50/50 chance that the premium you pay for cost control gets wiped by a lockout.
  21. Well that is awful decision making by the White Sox if they are willing to give up a high upside prospect like Carlson for a pitcher like Detmers. It is paying a premium for cost control vs. eliteness and that is not a trade off this organization should ever make. If you want to move Carlson in a package for Miller - I don't love it, but I get behind the fact you are getting an elite cost controlled player, but at a less premium position. That is an acceptable trade off.
  22. I think the Sox get 2 starting pitchers from the group of (High Contract / Eat Money (Castillo / Ray), and then one of Singer/Mets crew), a catcher, and their splash move is Mason Millers (headlined by one of our SS prospects). The splash move is not one I would like to make but I think Getz is going to go big and maybe than leverages Millers and someone else to swing for a TOR guy later in another year (or they explore developing Miller into that TOR guy).
  23. Not what you want to do - but what do you predict?
  24. I still am probably more bullish on the long-term pitching prognosis, but this season's actual productivity certainly hasn't helped the cause. I still generally believe the following individuals who are close to the big leagues who will have sustained success at the big league level in the long-run (presuming health): In no particular order: Schultz, Hagen, MacDougall, Thorpe, Sandlin; Mason Adams I'm less confident in but could as easily see working out; For sakes of simplicity I'm ignoring the waves at the lower levels (and in fairness I'm also not saying there are waves). I also believe Martin and Burke are long-term big league pitchers (not saying either are aces or sustained TOR guys though). Note: I do think this points out that the Sox have a need, whether now or next year - to go out and acquire a TOR pitcher and I believe they have the system depth to do it - but I also would hope with new ownership and potential changes to CBA, we may actually have the free agent market to tap (new CBA with 5 year max deal for FA pitcher is a big game changer in my mind).

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.