Palehose, interesting argument here. I'm a duke fan and I'll tell you what I agree with you 100 percent that JJ is an overrated player but I don't think he's an overrated shooter. Both McCants and JJ are absolutely great shooters but obviously Rashaad is the much better player. The reason I think more people think of JJ are because of the absolutely beautiful stroke he possess. If I had to take one guy to shoot a 3 I am taking JJ. The reason I say this, is because Redick is constantly getting pressured around the 3 point stripe because defenses know the only thing he can do is shoot, while with Rashaad can create his own shot that can give him a bit more room to get a clean shot off. Either way I don't think you can go wrong but IMO I still think Redick is the better shooter, just my 2 cents.