We haven't even gotten close to the meat of the rebuild yet. Only the tip of the iceberg is here. As you look down the list the Sox had 20 all-stars in their minor league system so far this year, including the two later ones from Charlotte. They are having some big years from unexpected guys, some great follow up years from guys who are top level guys and the youngest at their levels, plus rebound years from others. The minors are on fire right now. Sounds like the scouting staff is doing fine to me in the macro sense.
In the micro sense, sure some specific guys have struggle, mostly at the top levels. I am still not sure why that is a surprise. Am I the only one who remembers a very similar to Moncada in Javy Baez look like absolute trash his first year in the majors, striking out at a 40% rate, and requiring multiple trips to the minors? Anthony Rizzo wasn't exactly a star right off of the bat was he?
Jon Singleton was supposed to be a star, and a fool for taking an extension before even seeing the majors. Jose Altuve was a sub .700 OPS in his three season of major league action. Dallas Keuchel was terrible in his first year and a half at the major league level. Heck I won't even get into the gigantic screw ups the Astros made in the draft.
None of what has happened this year is unusual, or should be a surprise. Most kids struggle when they get to the majors.