Because I have too much time on my hands at work i was looking at Boston's roster heavily and trying to come up with a package not centered around Moncada for Sale that would be realistic for both sides. Would anybody actually do the following deal? That was the best deal I could come up with that I think Boston would realistically do.

 

Travis Shaw

Eduardo Rodriguez

Rafael Devers

Andrew Benintendi

Michael Kopech

Michael Chavis

Oh f*** that. They are giving up Moncada. Sale and Q are worth Moncada headlined package. Sale has even more value than Q (not sure how much) so Moncada has to be in it. I've been saying he needs to headline the Q one. He should. Qs track record, contract and age speak for itself. If Hahn can't get Moncada that's a failure IMO.

Here's a Sherman article Urias is available for Sale

 

http://nypost.com/2016/07/25/dodgers-would...ris-sale-talks/

Oh f*** that. They are giving up Moncada. Sale and Q are worth Moncada headlined package. Sale has even more value than Q (not sure how much) so Moncada has to be in it. I've been saying he needs to headline the Q one. He should. Qs track record, contract and age speak for itself. If Hahn can't get Moncada that's a failure IMO.

 

Easy pal lol, I definitely want Moncada too. I'm just throwing the hypothetical out there of if Boston takes Moncada off the table are they even in the running? Would a package like the 1 I threw out even get them in the door compared to what other teams will offer? Or is it Moncada or don't even answer Boston's call?

Oh f*** that. They are giving up Moncada. Sale and Q are worth Moncada headlined package. Sale has even more value than Q (not sure how much) so Moncada has to be in it. I've been saying he needs to headline the Q one. He should. Qs track record, contract and age speak for itself. If Hahn can't get Moncada that's a failure IMO.

Reading the online reports from the "experts" most don't think as highly of Quintana because while he produces good numbers, he doesn't have the high end skill set to net that type of package.

 

My 2 cents:

 

I don't think Boston is going to give up what most here think it will take to get Sale.

 

That being said, if they don't, dig in your heels. Don't take a lesser offer when you don't have to.

http://espn.go.com/blog/mlb/rumors/post/_/..._medium=twitter

Here's a Sherman article Urias is available for Sale

 

http://nypost.com/2016/07/25/dodgers-would...ris-sale-talks/

They need to seriously look at this one.

My 2 cents:

 

I don't think Boston is going to give up what most here think it will take to get Sale.

 

That being said, if they don't, dig in your heels. Don't take a lesser offer when you don't have to.

 

 

Exactly. The only 2 scenarios are they deal one or the other for a haul (s) or we keep both and try to reload this offseason.

I don't like Hahn for personal reasons that go all the way back to how he treated people at Harvard Law...but mostly because he has done a pretty lousy job.

 

I don't think Ventura is the best manager for the future of this organization.

 

I have never underrated Sale or Q.

 

The Q package would include Robertson and return Moncada, Benitendi, Kopech, Eduardo Rodriguez and Rusney Castillo with huge cash susidy for remaining dollars on that deal.

QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Mar 6, 2015 -> 09:05 AM) *

Why? Are you not happy with Hahn's tenure?

 

Haber is much more similar to Hahn than KW.

 

You need your contract negotiators, and your talent evaluators in equal measure, and, on rare occasions, you have front office guys proficient at both.

 

To be disappointed in much beyond the smaller moves fizzling (like Keppinger) is pretty much an impossible argument to make given where this organization was 18 months ago.

 

This post has been edited by caulfield12: Mar 6, 2015 -> 10:12 AM

The Dodgers would include Urias in a Sale deal

 

http://nypost.com/2016/07/25/dodgers-would...ris-sale-talks/

The Dodgers would include Urias in a Sale deal

 

http://nypost.com/2016/07/25/dodgers-would...ris-sale-talks/

If they could get this type of pitcher and a couple of top position players, they really need to consider that deal

Silly RedSox fans...

 

@REDSOXNATI0N Sale in my opinion is not good enough to trade benintendi, unless it's an MVP caliber pitcher- untouchable

Silly RedSox fans...

 

Lol

Silly RedSox fans...

 

 

Basically the only player worthy of this guy is Kershaw and that's with LA eating the contract

Basically the only player worthy of this guy is Kershaw and that's with LA eating the contract

Funny thing is Kershaw has a clause in his contract where he immediately becomes a free agent if traded, ruining a lot of his value for other teams.

Funny thing is Kershaw has a clause in his contract where he immediately becomes a free agent if traded, ruining a lot of his value for other teams.

Veterans on multi year contracts used to have the right to demand a trade after a season if they got traded.

God Red Sox fans are the worst.

 

 

Urias starts the Sale package. De Leon, Bellinger and 3 more.

Edited July 26, 20169 yr by SouthSideSale

Easy pal lol, I definitely want Moncada too. I'm just throwing the hypothetical out there of if Boston takes Moncada off the table are they even in the running? Would a package like the 1 I threw out even get them in the door compared to what other teams will offer? Or is it Moncada or don't even answer Boston's call?

I wasn't trying to be disrespectful to you. Just more towards the notion that Sale wouldn't net their top prospect like some say. Not really you just most Red Sox fans.

Edited July 26, 20169 yr by SouthSideSale

God Red Sox fans are the worst.

 

 

Urias starts the Sale package. De Leon, Bellinger and 3 more.

Wonder if this Urias stuff was leaked by us to try getting Boston to move on Monacada?

Wonder if this Urias stuff was leaked by us to try getting Boston to move on Monacada?

Wouldn't surprise me. It's all a poker game right now.

Seeing as they have Bogaerts at short for a while and Pedroia locked up for the next 5 years at second, isn't this the type of deal you'd move Moncada in? To get a front of the rotation arm locked up for next 3+ years?

Seeing as they have Bogaerts at short for a while and Pedroia locked up for the next 5 years at second, isn't this the type of deal you'd move Moncada in? To get a front of the rotation arm locked up for next 3+ years?

They'll never find a better trade target than Sale.

Love the Boston fan who proposed Sale for Price!!! LOLOLOL

They'll never find a better trade target than Sale.

 

I know so they should be open-minded to dealing Moncada. I guess they could always move him to third though (unless they dealt with us and kept Devers).

Edited July 26, 20169 yr by soxfan2014

It's assumed by a lot of BoSox fans that Moncada plays 3B.

 

Rabbit heard anything in the last day or so? what are the chances you think sale or Q is moved by sunday?