17 hours ago17 hr 6 minutes ago, Whisox05 said:Seems like a good deal for the Twins if he does opt out.
16 hours ago16 hr 6 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:It's like having a star QB on his rookie dealWhere is our Jeffery Simmons damnit?!!
16 hours ago16 hr Yeah Jerry not willing to spend money that he ultimately won’t be responsible for paying in a few years is just crazy when you basically have a clean slate and all the room for payroll addition moving forward.
16 hours ago16 hr 13 minutes ago, HeGetzUs said:Yeah Jerry not willing to spend money that he ultimately won’t be responsible for paying in a few years is just crazy when you basically have a clean slate and all the room for payroll addition moving forward.Why are people surprised? The cheapest owner in all of sports continues to act super cheap. Nothing will change until Ishbia takes over
16 hours ago16 hr 7 hours ago, Whisox05 said:While I probably prefer King, I think Peralta is the guy we snag. Him and Vargas have apparently become fast friends and I think his rough 1H performance will keep the contract at Zach Wheeler levels or less.
15 hours ago15 hr 4 hours ago, WhiteSox2023 said:As of right now, May and Kay are pretty much what you just said on paper — 5th and 6th starters. The Sox are hoping they can turn May into a #2/#3 starter. Meanwhile, the Twins just spent $3 million more than the Sox and don’t need to hope that they signed a #1/#2 starter.In what world do 5th starters put up 2.8 fWAR?
15 hours ago15 hr 5 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:While I probably prefer King, I think Peralta is the guy we snag. Him and Vargas have apparently become fast friends and I think his rough 1H performance will keep the contract at Zach Wheeler levels or less.0% chance they sign either guy
15 hours ago15 hr 4 hours ago, fathom said:My issue with May is I see no upside. He’s going from great pitchers parks most of his career to GRF. His stuff was fine last year and still did poorly. I’ve watched him a lot and he misses over the plate with his sweeper so much.It’s weird you see no upside in a former top 25 prospect, who grades out very well from a stuff perspective, who is gaining strength after injuries detailed him for a period of time, who has only three full years of professional experience due to said injuries, and who has been acquired twice by strong pitching organizations for legitimate prospects. Like, the entire reason teams are excited about him and why he got this contract (primarily the 3rd year) is because of his ceiling. Whether he ever hits that ceiling remains to be seen, but the idea of a pitcher with his stuff and limited major league development not being capable of making adjustments to take a big leap is wild to me.
15 hours ago15 hr 1 hour ago, wegner said:Oh come the f*** on.....will they really get both of those guys??Fathom mocking every good free agent to the Cubs is an offseason constant
15 hours ago15 hr 15 minutes ago, Bad Hombre said:0% chance they sign either guyI’ll guarantee we sign one of them
15 hours ago15 hr 9 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:I’ll guarantee we sign one of themMan I’ll take that bet.Other than the obvious fit, vibes and feeling, why are you so confident? Edited 15 hours ago15 hr by Bob Sacamano
15 hours ago15 hr 2 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:Man I’ll take that betYou guys still haven’t paid up for Murakami!
15 hours ago15 hr 9 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:You guys still haven’t paid up for Murakami!I’ll gladly pay up lol Thank the other dumb teams that didn’t want him.I will say that I hope you’re right and I can have a helping of crow Edited 15 hours ago15 hr by Bob Sacamano
14 hours ago14 hr 44 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:I’ll guarantee we sign one of themHope you’re right 🤞
14 hours ago14 hr 34 minutes ago, Chisoxfn said:I want peralta or king or the pitcher from Japan. Peralta is my preference.I hate it but this deal and two 30 mil AAV others as a way to get above any salary floor would be fun. I hate the salary floor concept and hate it would take that to get ownership to spend, but as a fan of 2027 Sox it would probably be fun.
3 hours ago3 hr About two dozen teams watched Frankie Montas https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7790909/2026/11/17/mlb-pitcher-frankie-montas-free-agency/?source=athletic_thewindup_newsletter&campaign=21004929&userId=6062851
3 hours ago3 hr 6 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:I think it was Ken Rosenthal the other day when talking about our Sox signing May speaking to when you pay for potential....sometimes you pay a Zack Wheeler and you get a Zack Wheeler....on the other hand sometimes you pay a Frankie Montas and you get Frankie Montas
2 hours ago2 hr 13 minutes ago, wegner said:I think it was Ken Rosenthal the other day when talking about our Sox signing May speaking to when you pay for potential....sometimes you pay a Zack Wheeler and you get a Zack Wheeler....on the other hand sometimes you pay a Frankie Montas and you get Frankie MontasI think the theme here is pretty clear. You are more likely to get success if you pay for proven success than if you pay for someone with spotty history but UPSIDE. While there are exceptions to anything, you are way more likely to get a front line starter, when paying an already front line starter.
2 hours ago2 hr 7 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:I think the theme here is pretty clear. You are more likely to get success if you pay for proven success than if you pay for someone with spotty history but UPSIDE. While there are exceptions to anything, you are way more likely to get a front line starter, when paying an already front line starter.I'm well aware to not dream on Skubal but it sure would be nice to get Peralta or King
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, wegner said:I'm well aware to not dream on Skubal but it sure would be nice to get Peralta or KingWhile regression from either is definitely possible, the good news is they both seem to have a pretty stable base of guys who get you a lot of innings at a #2 to #3 SP status. The range of expected out comes has a MUCH higher floor.
58 minutes ago58 min 15 hours ago, HeGetzUs said:Yeah Jerry not willing to spend money that he ultimately won’t be responsible for paying in a few years is just crazy when you basically have a clean slate and all the room for payroll addition moving forward.Lifetime habits are hard to break.
30 minutes ago30 min 2 hours ago, wegner said:I'm well aware to not dream on Skubal but it sure would be nice to get Peralta or KingNot happening per Jesse Rogers
11 minutes ago11 min 15 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said:In what world do 5th starters put up 2.8 fWAR?He ain't the only one . Not saying I think he's a 5th but that seems to be the prevailing opinion here but also that's not a surprise. I' ll the Sox get another SP. Not sure who though. Thought they might get 2 MOR arms and try to get more out of them. But Im not holding my breathe expecting another arm . Maybe 55-60 % but if nothing materializes before Dec 1 and you think its bad in here now it'll get much worse. But every off season has been like that so people clinging to their disaster predictions of the last 2 years isn't shocking. Everyone is PTSD'd to the point of no return.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.