All Activity
Past hour
-
White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
That’s code for “they offered me $52.5 million and I’d be a moron to not take that offer.”
-
Offseason
While Im right there with you so far he's outspent nearly every owner. 😉 It wont stay that way for long but it's possible he's among the top FA spenders until the lockout ends . Him and all the other owners have around 2 weeks left.
-
Offseason
No trades. Just throw money at someone. Plenty of payroll space open
-
White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
The primary difference between fWAR and bWAR is that fWAR uses FIP and bWAR uses ERA. FIP is more predictive of ERA, but that doesn't mean it is a better reflection of what has happened. Also, Mays FIP was an outlier among the predictive stats so that WAR value is pretty misleading. Saying he had similar seasons to others because of the fWAR is a reach. The issue with May too is that innings and health have almost always been an issue in his career. Calling May a #3 doesn't align with his profile and health history.
-
Offseason
- Offseason
He ain't the only one . Not saying I think he's a 5th but that seems to be the prevailing opinion here but also that's not a surprise. I think the Sox get another SP. Not sure who though. Thought a week they might get 2 MOR arms and try to get more out of them. But have been regularly posting about getting better than that. But Im not holding my breathe expecting another arm . Maybe 55-60 % chance but if nothing materializes before Dec 1 and you think its bad in here now it'll get much worse. But every off season has been like that so people clinging to their disaster predictions of the last 2 years isn't shocking. Everyone is PTSD'd to the point of no return.- RIP Lance Broadway
Fucking lame. Wonder what the cause was. This world sucks balls. I find myself becoming the typical old man who is perpetually shaking his fist at the sky complaining about how everything is going to s%*#.- Offseason
Not happening per Jesse Rogers- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
Yeah I know, that's why I said his poor quality of contact meant he isn't a strong candidate for positive BABIP regression. On the positive side his fastball shapes and changeup are all quality pitches, so limiting sweeper usage (or fixing it this offseason) could result in a good 3/4 starter.- This Day In Sox History 11/19...
Two factoids today: November 19, 1913 – After playing a number of games in the U.S. spreading and promoting baseball the White Sox and Giants boarded the liner R.M.S. Empress of Japan to cross the Pacific and start the world portion of their tour. They played in Japan, Hong Kong, China, the Philippines, Australia, Egypt, Ceylon, France, Italy, the Vatican and England where they played before King George V. The Sox avoided disaster twice on the trip as when crossing the Pacific they ran smack into a typhoon and then in Italy a 20-foot section of train track was removed for repair over a river. The engineer barely saw it in time and stopped just short of plunging into a 60-foot drop into the water which would have killed everyone on board. The Sox would sail home on the Lusitania, a ship that would be torpedoed in May 1915 during World War I. For the tour itself the Sox won 24 games, the Giants 20 and there were two ties. November 19, 1996 - The Sox shocked the baseball world when owner Jerry Reinsdorf announced that he had signed slugger Albert Belle to the largest contract in baseball history. Sox fans were torn between being happy the Sox spent money on a star and being worried because of Belle’s sullen, moody reputation. Other baseball owners were furious with Reinsdorf, feeling that he deliberately signed Belle to the large contract to pay them back for agreeing to settle the 1994 labor dispute. Reinsdorf would be removed from the labor relations board, the body that advised the commissioner in all labor matters, over it. Supposedly Reinsdorf asked Frank Thomas who he thought the Sox should sign, Belle or Barry Bonds and Thomas said Belle. Belle would put up some monster seasons with the Sox especially in 1998 when he hit .328 with 49 home runs, 48 doubles and 152 RBI’s. He had a clause in his Sox contract that said he had to be one of the three highest paid players in baseball and when the team wouldn’t agree to give him a raise because other players passed him in salary, they let him go as a free agent. He signed with Baltimore, had two more excellent seasons then had to retire because of a bad hip injury.Today
- Offseason
Lifetime habits are hard to break.- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
I feel like this is probably where the give and take took place. They changed the release point to try to save the elbow, but it doesn't work the same as it used to. Almost the exact same thing happened to Shane Smith last year, and we never heard from him again. Seems like it was a thing with both Hagen Smith and Schultz too. Their stuff dropped off, but they stayed healthy.- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
He changed his release point and his pitch mix up last year. What's interesting is that his sweeper was actually pretty good in 2025 with his old release point and he also threw it almost 40% of the time. It was his worst pitch in 2026. His 2025 reminds me of 2026 Erick Fedde actually. Except Fedde got much better results despite the shaky peripherals. Here's to hoping they can build up May's sweeper again like they did Fedde's last year.- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
Bonemer and Antonacci are trade chips. Even Vargas after this year, if they aren't going to re-sign him. Of course I wouldn't trade any of them. But if a trade must happen. make it for other young players. No young for old; no veteran starter. Rangers, e.g. already trying to get out of their silly trade for Gore.- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
I like FIP as a stat, but there are clearly pitchers who it does not account well for. I don't think you can say with a ton of confidence that the pitcher has no control over balls in play. That's kind of ridiculous. Soft contact on average will result in lower BAA than hard contact. I don't think that's some sort of rocket science. You can't just assume somebody will have league average BABIP or LOB% if they're making bad pitches. It's like that Patrick Mahomes meme where if you just adjust his TD% to league average, he's like Dak Prescott. Contact quality absolutely matters when judging pitchers and it is something they have some sort of control over. A lot of May's expected stats last year were closer to his actual ERA than FIP. Which makes me think he wasn't that unlucky. That being said, he did change up his arsenal last year and his peripherals did improve over 2025. Having 3 fastball shapes and throwing them all at around 20-25% each is something that you can have a lot of success with (see Schlittler). It's just that his other offerings were terrible last year. Maybe they think they can fix his sweeper.- An ominous future...
But...what is he supposed to say? I mean...prior to negotiations is he going to say the owners are flexible on the salary cap issue? Don't get me wrong...this could be a slugfest...but the owners are going to take the hardest line possible entering the talks.- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
I would just love to hear something more concrete than "luck" when May has been through two of the best pitching organizations in MLB and hasn't been able to get into a zone around his potential. I get the arm injury in the middle might have derailed things, but last year was the second year pitching after injury, which is when stuff is supposed to stabilize and rebound, but it didn't seem to happen. His TJS date was July 2023, so that stuff should be past.- An ominous future...
Billionaires vs. millionaires while the fans are the ones who will suffer. With the owners seemingly not wanting to budge on a salary cap and floor, I don't see baseball being played until summer, if at all.- RIP Lance Broadway
You know you don't have to do this in every thread, right? It's OK not to prove you're the smartest guy in the room all the time. Lead with RIP and then go hijack some other conversation with your data vomit.- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
The thing that scared me about Castillo when they traded for him was his home runs allowed last season.and he was coming to pitch at The Rate. If May is prone to giving up the long ball too...yikes- White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
Didn't see if this was posted yet - the high BABIP is also likely due to his hard hit % so I don't know if that's going to go down as much as Dylan thinks. The fastball, cutter and changeup all get good swing & miss, and the sinker is a quality pitch. Maybe he just needs to throw the sweeper less.- Offseason
While regression from either is definitely possible, the good news is they both seem to have a pretty stable base of guys who get you a lot of innings at a #2 to #3 SP status. The range of expected out comes has a MUCH higher floor.- Offseason
I'm well aware to not dream on Skubal but it sure would be nice to get Peralta or King- Offseason
I think the theme here is pretty clear. You are more likely to get success if you pay for proven success than if you pay for someone with spotty history but UPSIDE. While there are exceptions to anything, you are way more likely to get a front line starter, when paying an already front line starter. - Offseason