All Activity
Past hour
-
White Sox interested in Dustin May
Hava Nagoya!!!
-
White Sox interested in Dustin May
Sounds eerily similar to what we were ( mostly ) all saying this past deadline - we were disappointed then and I think we’ll be disappointed this offseason.
Today
-
White Sox interested in Dustin May
I don’t think Getz deserves any sort of preemptive excuses if he picks the wrong starting pitcher again. He already did it at the trade deadline with Castillo, so he already used his “get out of jail free” card when it comes to bad starter acquisitions. Also, I’m not sure how Sox fans potentially picking the wrong free agent starter means anything in this discussion. Getz gets paid the salary to be the GM of the White Sox and ideally make the best decisions when it comes to free agency. If a GM screws up too many decisions, they eventually lose their job. They don’t get to simply blame bad luck. May is just a guy that will be cheap due to injury concerns so many teams are trying to get a deal if he ends up staying healthy. He should definitely not be the primary starting pitcher target for the Sox in free agency. From what I have seen, the majority on this board have talked about King being the ideal target.
-
Offseason
it doesn't really make sense for anybody to trade colson given his alignment with the sox' commitment to defense first up the middle and with the hitting philosophy for colson just trying to hit bombs first, everything else will come, hopefully, or it never does and he's just an avg regular. colson and peters and chase and teal (not that they probably even need it outside Colson) will have a long leash with the bat in 2027 as long as the glove is there. We have a strong team on paper, stronger given some key additions. This is a very exciting offseason for so many reasons. Let us hope the owners don't f*** it up.
-
Offseason
Not necessarily, both could be true. He totally could prefer to pitch close to home (I'm sure most if not all players would), but if none of those teams offer him anything close, he'd be an idiot to not take the best deal - especially if there is a large gap between them. Honestly don't think we even need to entertain him coming back, that ship sailed IMO.
-
“The 78” + "The Railyard" = the future of the Sox and Fire
Sunk cost fallacy.
-
White Sox interested in Dustin May
The problem with this thread is that we're dealing with a lot of pitchers who can boom or bust. No one will go on record saying who the Sox should sign besides Skubal. Most here would probably think the Sox end up with 2 arms they can get a bargain on, 3-4-5 spot guys. I will guarantee 1 thing. Among the Free Agents who we put a tier below Skubal , (Michael King, Peralta , Gray) There will be a couple pitchers who will have a pretty good year in that next tier where there's like 10 guys . Any GM's dilemma is to get lucky and end up picking a guy who stays healthy and pitches better than expected. No one knows who those guys will be .Might as well pick names out of a hat. Dustin May has like 10 teams interested in him hoping to hit that sweet spot of a big improvement in season 3 after Tommy John surgery without him falling aapart. We all seem to think we know who not to get but no one is willing to put themselves in Getz's shoes and say who to actually get and still keep the discussion real enough to think, yeah, thats possible.
-
Offseason
Meaning they are paying low prices for him, not high ones.
-
Offseason
he just played 153 games after being healthy the prior year after the soft tissue issue in spring. the injury history is mostly fan perception at this point, and they'd be buying low, not high.
-
Offseason
Well then his Caul's point doesn't really matter.
Yesterday
-
Offseason
“If you're a team that has a lot of bat-to-ball skills, you can handle a little bit of swing-and-miss,” the executive said. “If you have a lot of swing-and-miss, you might be a little more averse to bringing on somebody like that. We’ve certainly seen guys adapt to our game here, which gives you reason to be more optimistic about the next guy translating to success.” mlb.com on bringing Japanese hitters like Murakami Sato and Okamoto to the States
-
Offseason
Probably the only team that gave him what he wanted. Money talks.
-
Offseason
Probably had no other similar options. Or wanted to erase Boston Marathon/Red Sox City Connect Massacre day game memories.
-
Offseason
Didn’t he SIGN with the Red Sox?
-
“The 78” + "The Railyard" = the future of the Sox and Fire
Warren is still involved? Why?
-
Offseason
Three he must prefers the West Coast...family roots and all.
-
Offseason
- Will Venable wins AL Manager of the Year
bullpen usage was my qualm with him heading into this season, and a little bit throughout, but he made a lot of really smart, novel decisions with the staff that resulted in postseason wins. players buy what he is selling. there is a consistent logic to his in-game decision making. He is fair and gives players room to make mistakes We’ve got a really good coach and he just seems like a good person too.- 2026 MILB Catch-All
- Offseason
As much as I loved Lucas while he was here, two things quickly come to mind. #1, he has had a terrible injury history since leaving. #2, we made a pretty big scene with him over $50,000 that I doubt he has forgotten.- Offseason
He would feel good as a non-roster invitee.- Protected List...
The big difference between the two is that Bergolla can play ss and is a plus defender at 2b. Nishida is fringey at 2b and okay in the of. As a utility player Bergolla is easier to carry. Then again, no one knows much about Bergolla’s health. May be a reason not to pick him- Protected List...
There is definitely roster slop if the Sox feel there is a marginal difference between some of these guys. Even a guy like Bergolla is someone who I would be surprised to get picked. He has zero power, and hasn't really shown a top flight hit tool or steal tool to make up for it. Nishida and Bergolla look at lot alike. .296 .363 .352 .715- Offseason
Again, I can't help but think Colson's trade value is pretty small right now. The slumps and injury history have to be red flags for a lot of orgs. I can't see anyone buying high on him.- Offseason
I'd be good with the Sox signing one top end pitcher: Peralta or King (I'd prefer Peralta). Or heck even Sonny Gray. He probably has a higher flop probability, but he'd be less of a commitment in years. We have several guys who really done with AAA that can fill that last spot: Sandlin, Shultz, Thorpe. Maybe Castillo can pull it together. And still have Kay, who was perfectly fine as a 5th starter in 2026. - Will Venable wins AL Manager of the Year