South Side Hit Men

They really ought to give Tony a breathalyzer before he is allowed to create a lineup. Grandal second? So by the off chance he reaches, he can just clog up the bases. He has a pitcheresque 6 runs total this season, and scored his first run last night since May 26.

The metric is the success of the major league team over time. Kenny finished with the most games over .500 and a World Series championship. No other Sox GM accomplished this the past century. Hahn is on the complete opposite end of the spectrum. Only Harry Grabiner finished more games under .500 (but with a better win percentage). Harry was saddled with losing nearly his entire Championship team in 1920, and also piloted the team through the cheap ass Comiskey Family Depression years. Grabiner actually built a multi-championship contender. Hahn just crows about one.

Vaughn never played 3B in college, only two emergency appearances with the Sox. Perhaps you are thinking of Burger, also such a stiff defensively, but who has played 3B throughout his career.

Not a great OF, but a HOF Gold Glover compared to Sheets and Vaughn. He’s only 26 and has been good except for this season. Wonder if something weird happened for them to just dump him like that. If the Sox were trying to win this season, they’d pick him up and option Sheets.

Grandal caught 32 games in 2020. He missed a lot of time in 2021. He has either been injured or horseshit this entire season. Catchers beyond 30, beyond a few exceptions (out of thousands in MLB history) drop off really quickly. Grandal's heavy playing time leading up to 2020 made it even more of a certainty his health would not hold up over four seasons. Hahn paid $73M for five great months, and seven injured and/or horseshit months. 29 other GMs didn't even bother to compete with this offer. Par for the Rick Hahn era.

So we are looking at 2025 to begin drawing conclusions on Nick "Mr. 3,000" Madrigal.

Dude

I believe most here believe Hahn should have acquired a starting RF over the past three seasons. But given what they have, and the health and performance of everyone: Grandal should catch or sit or hit the IL. He should not DH. If he regains his health, he should catch more games. Vaughn should DH, with perhaps 1 weekly home start in LF to give Eloy a rest & at 1B (at any park) to give Abreu rest. Eloy, Robert and either Engel/Pollock/Leury left to right on your screen, should be your OF the rest of the season, based on the shitty Hahn options. Send Sheets down and bring up / claim someone who can actually play RF/CF, or Burger to spell Moncada who could perhaps use rest to clear his head and perhaps get him back on track. As long as Vaughn is on the active roster, Sheets should not be on the active roster.

Tony said Vaughn did a heck of a job fielding last night, because he let balls drop, but kept the balls in front of him. This is something you would note about a 6 year old playing T-Ball, not a professional ballplayer.

"Heck of a job, Brownie."

David Jerry and Tony have remained friendly / friends over the years, but when he made the call to fire Hemond and hire Hawk, he wasn't going to interfere with Hawk's plans beyond his insistence Tony stay. David doesn't have the mindset of a Williams or Hahn, satisfied collecting paychecks for decades until Jerry passes. Also, over all these years, Jerry never sought to hire David, and David was perfectly happy with his opportunities and ownership looking to win it all, not shoot for just missing the playoffs and maximizing profits. Kenny was successful that one time because he won several consecutive coin flips turning Jerry's nickels and dimes into dollars in 2005. The only sustained White Sox success since the 1950s and 1960s were the 1990s teams built by the discarded Larry Himes on young players earning the minimum, and a few supporting veterans signed by Ron Schueler. Jerry only opened the wallet after 2005 and locking in substantial season ticket revenue for the next few years. The 2000 Playoff team was ranked 25th in payroll on Opening Day ($31.2M), Source: https://543tripleplay.blogspot.com/2011/02/last-thirty-one-years-of-payrolls-mlb.html

Didn't skip it. Hawk did the right thing in 1986 firing La Russa's ass. Hake shouldn't be held accountable Jerry and Tony are still alive and employed in the year 2022. Dave Dombrowski was never going to last under Jerry. Jerry never cared about qualifications. Cronyism and loyalty solely to Jerry are the primary two attributes he seeks. Inexperienced and unqualified candidates are the typical pool as a result.

The 2021 Kimbrel trade, Kimbrel Option Pick Up, and 2022 Kimbrel trade for Pollock should be grounds for Hahn's shitcanning this offseason. Parts 2 and 3 were completely avoidable for $1M. The fact that he took on an even more expensive contract (spread over two years) made it even worse. In terms of Vaughn, he is still on 24, and like most power hitters, I expect his power to increase as he reaches his peak 26-28 age seasons (2024-2026).

Making your suggested adjustments renders WAR completely worthless. A 1B/DH is fungible and can be easily found and fielded for the ML minimum or something close, unless you are talking a 4-5 WAR player. No further proof is the fact more than half of the White Sox batter roster is composed of 1B/DH. I have been the most vocal on the board about the overpay over Grandal's deal since Day One (primary concern was length for a 30-something catcher, a length no other team considered matching). That said, he is just an injured player who like a half dozen other White Sox. As bad as Grandal has been, there are literally tens of thousands of single seasons played in the history of baseball that this version of Grandal is superior to. Adam Done can say that about 12 seasons across 150 years, whittled down further by the same player appearing twice (Great Depression era Jim Levey), and two more from the 19th century. There are only a few humans in the history of mankind who have played professional baseball worse than 2011 Adam Dunn. No favorable comparison of Dunn over any living or future White Sox should ever be uttered.

No, it's not even close, and what does the NYT have to do with anything? Adam Dunn had the 13th worst batter season in 152 years of baseball. Adam Dunn -2.9 fWAR 122 G vs. Yasmani "Elite" Grandal -0.6 fWAR 59 G Worst Batter Single Seasons in MLB History 1871-2022 (lowest fWAR each season): # Season Name Team G PA HR R RBI SB BB% K% ISO BABIP AVG OBP SLG wOBA xwOBA wRC+ BsR Off Def WAR 12345678910... Page size: 95443 items in 3182 pages 1 1933 Jim Levey SLB 141 567 2 43 36 4 4.6% 12.0% .045 .220 .195 .237 .240 .227 23 -1.7 -60.1 0.5 -4.0 2 1977 Jerry Royster ATL 140 491 6 64 28 28 7.7% 13.6% .072 .241 .216 .278 .288 .258 45 1.9 -31.1 -21.9 -3.8 3 1930 Tommy Thevenow PHI 156 624 0 57 78 1 3.7% 4.2% .040 .300 .286 .316 .326 .297 48 0.2 -51.0 -10.4 -3.6 4 2008 Ryan Doumit PIT 116 465 15 71 69 2 4.9% 11.8% .183 .333 .318 .357 .501 .369 123 -1.8 11.8 -60.4 -3.4 5 1931 Jim Levey SLB 139 540 5 53 38 13 6.5% 15.4% .076 .241 .209 .264 .285 .259 40 -1.0 -44.9 -8.4 -3.3 6 1886 Jim Lillie KCC 114 427 0 37 22 13 2.6% 18.7% .022 .217 .175 .197 .197 .190 31 0.1 -44.6 -10.0 -3.2 7 1985 George Wright TEX 109 395 2 21 18 4 6.3% 12.4% .052 .213 .190 .241 .242 .217 28 -2.1 -36.1 -7.7 -3.2 8 1899 Sport McAllister CLE 113 451 1 29 31 5 4.2% .060 .237 .273 .297 .275 57 -1.8 -29.7 -21.9 -3.2 9 1999 Cristian Guzman MIN 131 456 1 47 26 9 4.8% 19.7% .050 .282 .226 .267 .276 .247 34 -1.4 -41.3 -7.4 -3.1 10 1993 David McCarty MIN 98 371 2 36 21 2 5.1% 21.6% .071 .272 .214 .257 .286 .247 43 -2.0 -27.8 -14.7 -3.1 11 1997 Jose Guillen PIT 143 526 14 58 70 1 3.2% 16.7% .145 .298 .267 .300 .412 .312 82 -0.6 -12.9 -34.7 -3.1 12 2002 Neifi Perez KCR 145 585 3 65 37 8 3.4% 9.1% .067 .254 .236 .260 .303 .247 39 0.7 -43.6 -5.4 -2.9 13 2011 Adam Dunn CHW 122 496 11 36 42 0 15.1% 35.7% .118 .240 .159 .292 .277 .268 60 -5.4 -28.3 -15.5 -2.9

The World's Richest White Sox

Still don't understand the Hawk pick. Sure he screwed up five months of White Sox baseball. Rick Hahn is a few years away from destroying an entire generation of White Sox baseball.

No, it will cost Jerry or his estate money extra money down the road.

And it burns, burns, burns. Sox Ring of Fire Sox Ring of Fire

He has scored 6 runs, 4 not via his 2 HRs, in 209 ABs. That ratio of under 3 runs per 100 ABs has to be an all-time MLB record for a position player.

Let's face it, most 6 year old little league teams have a superior coaching staff, player fundamentals and baserunning, and employ better analytics.

This Cole Ragans isn't even available in the yahoo leagues. Marissa Mayer is such a b****.

Today we salute you, Mister turnin' two and your brother.

The Sox have a better Jackie Bradley, but Tony refuses to play him. Tony has only started Adam Engel 39 times last season (1.6 bWAR) and 48 this year (0.8 bWAR). There are only four White Sox hitters with a higher war (Abreu, Robert, Anderson and Harrison) this season. With all of the OF injuries and Sheets/Vaughn playing the corners, his defense alone would have won at least a few games for the Sox this season. Tony was starting Pollock over Engel in CF, which is completely ludicrous. Sheets' OPS + is only 9 points higher this season (92 vs. 83), and he ranks among the all time worst right fielders in the 120 + year history of The MLB.