greg775

I'll stop after this, but I want to ask you and then I'll stop: 1.) Are you in favor of the tank/rebuild? 2.) Assuming you say yes, this guy is a No. 10 draft pick and he's about to enter his age 24 season. He's no young pup. 3.) Do you want the high draft picks we signed to play for the team and lead the team to the WS a couple times? This guy passed our scouts' scrutiny, they drafted him, he's supposed to be the catcher of the future. Well, let this tank/rebuild play itself out. Play him next year A LOT. That's why I want to play Rutherford as well. We were told to support the tank; well, I wanna see the tank acquisitions play and succeed. This kid has been considered can't miss all his life. Now he's not can't miss? I'll listen for your answer then stop giving my takes. Let's just say I want to be put in the category: Collins starter/McCann super sub next year.

He's part of the tank/rebuild and is ready. I want him to start at catcher next year. McCann can help him and play 1-2 times a week. I know I said Hahn will never be fired cause of Eloy/Moncada, but he should at least be reprimanded if this No. 10 pick can't start next season and produce. No. 10 pick.

Why are we down on Collins now? He's a 10th overall draft pick? He has Carlton Fisk size. What has made him be out of the mix? He's supposed to be one of the studs in the rebuild at No. 10 pick overall. He's got the experience. He's more than old enough. Play him. Start him next year.

McCann is fine, but give the job to Collins next year. Why not?

It's baseball's fault. Game after game against the same teams. Sickening to play Minnie so often. Why should their fans care? They've already proven they are 10 times better than the Sox team. Why go to the game and pay $$ when you can watch it on TV? 19 games against Minnie. One big LOL to baseball. GIve us a balanced schedule!

As good as some of our young starting pitchers have been, they been equally bad on many nights. Good luck trying to figure out if these guys have what it takes. Sox are not going to finish above .500 next year with such inconsistent starting pitching and a leaky bullpen.

I thought the same thing. Do the Sox realize how embarrassing it is to tank and take a guy No. 10 in the first round and have him not even playing much in his age 24 season? Get the guy some at bats.

I don't know why people aren't excited about Collins? So many people on here want to lose and get top draft picks. This is the guy we got at No. 10. He looks like he's Carlton Fisk-like in stature at 6-3, 220. There should be a lot of expectations surrounding him and he should produce big time unless he's a busted draft pick. He's had four years in the minors. I'd rather him start than McCann to tell u the truth. Let him sink or swim. I bet he succeeds.

He turns 25 in February. Play him now. It'd be ridiculous to wait til his age 26 season to play his first full year. The Sox thought this guy was worthy of the No. 10 pick. Play him now and see if he's good or a bust.

I am not giving up on Collins. Eye test more than early stats. He looks like a prospect to me. Surely Collins has some supporters who are with me. 10th overall pick in 2016?? He better be good or the draft fans have some explainin' to do.

Puig: This year in 519 at bats ... 24 HRS (blah according to our many analytics peeps on here who don't like Avi or Jose); 77 RBI (very blah; meaningless stat but even for a meaningless stats has way too few RBIs to be considered anything much); OPS of .768 (little above league average); .317 OBP (little above league average), 17 stolen bases. I think that's impressive but stolen bases are not desired anymore. War: 1.2 (considering 2 is average player not good). Age: 29 in December. Consensus: You advanced statters should blast him all next season if we get him. He's average at best. Greg's faves: Avi is up to 1.9 WAR; Jose is 2.5. Isn't 2.5 getting close to being acceptable to the advanced stat aficionados?

OMG. This is quite the stretch. I just wish we'd trade Jose so I wouldn't have to defend him so much. At least there are two other staunch defenders of Jose along with me Not a bad take by Vile. This is what message boards are for. Throw out a take that's sort of wild but reasonable. Some of us have said for a long time the manager is at a disadvantage on the south side cause of his options. Some nights he has nothing but crap to put on the mound out of the bullpen. Let's face it life is all about making $$$, the most money you can. And with this payroll, the Sox have made soooooo much money during the tank.

Baseball is lucky to have so many loyal fans. The product right now is crap and franchises shouldn't be worth a minimum of $1 billion. To be fair, that last pitch was right over the plate just above the belt which is supposed to be a strike, but isn't as the umps for many many years call their own strike zone. Modern baseball 2019 is all about a hitter either hitting a home run or striking out and occasionally drawing some walks to keep that one advanced stat in their favor. I was talking to a former all-conference baseball player the other day, he's about 35. He said he can't watch MLB. Says it's simply unwatchable.

If that's true, they better do it. It's going to be annoying if our staff reeks again next season.

This is still a relatively new phenomenon with fans wanting to lose. Not sure what year the tank mentality started, but it used to be win or die trying every night.

Pitching staff needs a lot of work for this team to reach .500 next season. Is Coop the man to ask for what he needs and fix some current guys?

Sox are average team at home; miserable road club.

That was a strike by rule BTW. Letter high. I realize they don't call it, though.

Cordell screwed up. Stuff happens. Hopefully someday at this stage of the season I'll be furious at such a blunder. Now ... who cares? Just another loss. I don't even get mad at Sox-Cubs or Sox-Royals losses anymore. The front office got me used to it.

Well, that's sucky. The teams should still be playing, in theory.

I happen to be one of the posters who think he's OK. He's not that bad a player. If Robert and Madrigal start the year with the Sox we can afford to have a non all star at one of the positions. I'm sure the Sox would love to go cheap and stick him out there though there was that tweet from the reporter the other day saying Rick wanted a LH stud free agent bat in right which is fine too.

He's 2 for 61 which has to be the worst stretch for any non pitcher in baseball history. I mean nobody has gone 0 for 61 to start a season, that's for sure. 1 for 61? I doubt it. I wonder if any other team will give him a chance next year. I remember last year the guy hit 27 bombs.

But I stand by my statement that because he acquired such studs he's going to work as long as he wants in baseball front office(s) even if the team never hits .500 under his watch. You acquire players like that ... wow.

I may not explain myself well. Can I please ask you something: a.) Do you agree with my assertions about the players in the post above? That they are Stars? b.) Do you also agree we're not even a .500 team for next year as it stands now? c.) Finally: Do you agree Hahn is set for life merely for acquiring such stars as I suggested? Please answer all questions. Thanx. As an addendum, I suggest he's set for life for acquiring those once in a generation stars. I am confused, that's all, that such stars don't even guarantee a .500 team. Agree that's weird? I stand by saying the mere acquistion of those stars guarantees Hahn a job forever though. They are that good.

He defnitely is set for life acquiring Moncada and Eloy alone. They are superstars and Hahn brought them in. Eloy is 30 to 40 homers a year by just staying healthy and Moncada is overall phenomenal. With Abreu not slowing down and Anderson also a star and Gio looking for real and Robert a certain star, Hahn has to be considered a runaway success. Yes he's set for life as a GM. The weird question is with all this talent can he even get this team over .500? They have a lot of work to do to mold this into a .500 team much less win two WS before everybody leaves.