JoeC

I laughed audibly. Then cried, knowing that one such example got traded to the Sox and crashed / burned.

Seemingly off-topic for this thread, but this is my primary beef with the "call up Colas" movement. Just because someone puts up good numbers in AAA (or, in his case, AA), it doesn't mean that he doesn't have significant holes in his game that will keep him from being a serviceable big league player. Again, I hope Project Birmingham is designed to address things like this and give players more practice time to work on those holes in their games.

I would argue that it's that Cleveland does a fantastic job of player development. Chase rates are but one result of that development process. They do a fantastic job developing the assets they have and getting the most out of their returns for existing assets when they do "sell." It's how an organization should be run.

Reading the board, sometimes it sounds like that would be a benefit if Moncada is shipped off somewhere. ...but yes - I agree. The team needs to stay healthy. All of these soft tissue lower body injuries are killing us.

Sure, we've got young guys who are hurt a lot, but we generally have an older roster. As of late July, the Sox had the fourth oldest roster in MLB (based on average age), while Cleveland had the youngest: https://www.statista.com/statistics/236223/major-league-baseball-clubs-by-average-age-of-players/ The major injuries were suffered by guys like Eloy and TA, but you can't ignore the fact that older players have a tendency to get hurt more, can you?

I think the two words you're looking for are "youth" and "depth."

Yeah an overreaction on my part admittedly, but it’s been a long two weeks for me.

The Naylor game was the first one that I felt like this team was in trouble. The team had just clawed back above .500, and I thought it was "OK - the team hit some April slumps, but we're back where we need to be now." ...then Naylor came up with the bases loaded.

4-2 now.

(bump)

Twins are imploding.

Naylor is... intense? Gets hit on the back toe on a breaking ball and yells a couple of very audible F Bombs. Guardians broadcast thinks it's intentional for some reason. Obviously if you're looking to make a statement, you send your 23-year-old rookie making his big league debut to hit him with a back-foot slider.

He must know that doing so would screw over the Sox.

Doing my part. Starting Quantrill on my fantasy team, thereby guaranteeing failure.

Thank you for the wonderful advice. I was in the middle of about 20 tasks and taking a crap, scrolling / reading on my iPhone when I posted that. Was thinking that on a board like this someone would take the time to post the numbers, which they graciously did.

Yep - saw that... thanks. Depressing.

I was hoping to see numbers.

I seriously wonder how much of that is Leury’s AB’s? I know others have been dismal, but I am curious to see the relative “contributions”

So, if they were us, a pretty tough schedule.

They didn’t just find him. They developed him.

I think Martin as the 6th starter is a reasonable plan for a contender.

You're looking at it right now if you're looking at their active roster

Always reminded me of Waluigi

I don't remember the Paniagua thing.... the only thing I remember him for is that his Anglicized name was Joe Bread-and-Water.