southsider2k5

Anderson!

Skolnik!

Stupid hitters scoring runs. I want to see lots of pitches!

Just like everyone predicted.

Man if Engel can even give us a mediocre bat in CF...

I mean if you have a realistic chance to win a WS, you really have to think about going for it, but if the Cubs don't go for it there, and never win one, who know what happens to that franchise.

Lol@ the guys watching and posting about the Cubs game in the Sox game thread.

And I think Jose Abreu is different based on his tool set and other similar players in recent history.

That is great to see.

Those deals are not out there. These types of players aren't getting that kind of trade value. The market isn't logical right now. RPs are overvalued and the 1B/DH types are undervalued. Go back and look at the trades over the last few years, you will not find the deal you are talking about.

Does anyone know who Kenny Williams has seen? We all know he is the final cross checker.

I could post the numbers that show most prospects post 0 WAR in their careers too. Also if anyone had been willing to pay that for Abreu, he would have been gone already. Your value idea for him is insanely high compared to what teams are willing to pay. We are not getting a top 25 prospect. That is insanity.

No. The window for any chance at that would have been if Boston would have been willing to give up players for salary relief. Without that, no.

It's all risk. Let's not pretend that just because we get "prospects" that they are going to somehow replace what we are giving up. What I see is in all the examples of hitters that do keep hitting into their mid and late 30's they seem to be bigger and stronger guys who primary tool is a big hit tool, while being strong enough to make those hits go for power. The tool that ages the least well is speed, and let's face it, that is nothing that Abreu needs to worry about. The guys I listed in previous posts as having defied those numbers are very similar to Abreu in the type of players that they are. It is also worth noting that while you are posting a league average number, just by a statistical nature, there are outliers to those. I really think Abreu profiles as the type of hitter who will hit into his mid to maybe even late 30's and is the kind of guy that a team should be OK with extending.

It is worth mentioning that since the Sox started 9-27, they have gone 7-6 in their last 13 games.

Handful? You are saying one. And you are using it as some sort of catch all to eliminate anyone who does hit later in their career. That isn't really "data".

The funny thing is if you add up all of Anderson's MiLB and MLB ABs, and compare them to Moncada's AB in Cuba/MiLB/MLB, they aren't that far apart.

There is a list of guys that have hit past 33. Even just in Chicago you can look at a guy like Paul Konerko. Frank Thomas had some huge seasons in his late 30's. Miguel Cabrera is continuing to hit. Victor Martinez is another name that comes to mind, as well as Chipper Jones. Carlos Beltran has continued to hit into his last 30's, as has Adrian Beltre.

Winning the World series for the 1st time in 108 years justifies the means.

He was a failed hitter who transitioned to pitching.

Remember when people didn't think Giolito would be a good offer?

Even Adam "Launch" Engel had two more hits. Dude has raised his OPS 77 points in the last 5 days. He even has an OPS over .700 for May.

You are quite literally stuck in the present. No sense of the future, and apparently have completely forgotten the past as well.

Just got back from Solo. Really enjoyed it, thought the casting of both Solo and Lando was really solid. Both worked hard to get mannerisms and the like down of Ford and Williams respectively.

Why? What of his skillset is going to be the issue? You can look around baseball and see similar styles of hitters who age into their middle to late 30's just fine.