Dick Allen

QUOTE(RockRaines @ Mar 11, 2008 -> 09:42 AM) We would be lucky to get any player for Crede right now, I dont know how anyone is saying we should get a legit starter or prospect. He's not even the best 3B available on the market right now. Its ridiculous how much this board overrated Crede. We are going to be lucky to get a player that has even a slim chance at making the mlb roster. If the board overrated Crede, and I refuse to base how he will do this season on what he's done by March 10th after a few at bats and a prolonged absence, then what about KW risking $5.1 million on him? And his superstar to be replacement isn't exactly tearing it up. Why is a few at bats proof positive that Crede is washed up but the same results for Fields means nothing? All Fields has shown in the major leagues is an ability to hit homers. Nothing else yet. Crede sucks because of his OBP, well look at Fields.

QUOTE(Balta1701 @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 09:52 PM) So if they both suck in ST the rest of the way, who gets the job in the majors? The one who hasn't played ball in 10 months and is struggling after a surgery or the one who was at least decent for your team last year? I'd go with Crede and let Fields find his stroke in Charlotte. If he struggles and Fields hits in Charlotte, you make a change. I don't think it will come to that though. I really didn't think KW would risk the $5.1 million to give Crede away, but now I think by the end of spring training he will be gone unless Fields gets hurt, or unless he gets real hot and Fields plays his way on to the Knights. He'll say it would have be no fair to Fields and too much of a distraction.

QUOTE(Balta1701 @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 09:45 PM) The problem with that of course is that if it takes Joe an extra month or two to get back in to the swing of playing baseball again, then we've spent the first month or two of the season with a black hole in our lineup not named Juan Uribe, and killed off whatever last bit of trade value Crede might have had. You read what the scout said, he doesn't have any trade value now. Why bother giving him up for nothing? As bad as he's looked, its not like Josh Fields is thriving right now.

QUOTE(DBAH0 @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 08:24 PM) You hit the nail on the head there Tony. I think the Sox backed themselves into a situation with Danks and Floyd, where they both had to start in 08, and with Floyd out of options, Garland had to go. But really, I think we should have gotten more for JG. We should have asked for Willits as well, and he fills your leadoff needs at CF, and then you don't have to give up 3 spects for Swisher (well you still could, but he plays LF instead). Or you could have asked for a good spect on top of the deal maybe? I mean the Sox traded for Quentin and Richar, because they wanted to get younger players into the everyday lineup. Instead right now they're going with the same old with Uribe, and offensively that just ain't going to cut it. This ST so far, is starting to get frustrating for me. As bad as Uribe supposedly is offensively, his career OPS is just .002 lower than the big upgrade, Orlando Cabrera.

QUOTE(southsideirish71 @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 08:44 PM) Brooks Robinson Jr is not impressing anyone yet. Hot off the presses from Cheats blog. Last spring when Rowand hit .171 the scouts said his bat had slowed and he couldn't play CF. Now he's sitting on a $65 million contract. I think its a little harsh to judge a guy on March 10 when he has 22 ABs, and hasn't played baseball in 9 or 10 months.

QUOTE(southsideirish71 @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 05:39 PM) If he hits .300 with his all or nothing tazmanian devil swing I will be shocked. He will suck for most of the year, and then turn it on in September like he always does. It amazing how you think everyone sucks yet Uribe who pretty much has been a worthless hitter with a glove is magic to you. I like his talent, and while frustrated with his offensive results don't get carried away like others. Uribe's post ASB OPS was higher than Orlando Cabrera's. As inconsistent as Uribe is, his numbers at the end of the year are about as consistent as anybody's. Weak all around except for homers and rbis. I'm the negative guy, but I've also stuck up for several others including the closest thing to a HOFer on the current roster, Jim Thome who if you read this board, lost his power last year, and getting on at a .400 clip isn't good enough. As for the Sox line-up, I like AJ, I like Konerko, I like Crede, I'm not as high on Fields. Swisher is good. Dye is decent but probably not worth the money at this stage, I don't like Owens. I hate Floyd. I think Danks is going to take time. I've stuck up for Contreras since he was acquired. I'm not a Vazquez guy, but he was good last year. I don't think Jenks will have a long career, but he's effective. I think KW has made a lot of mistakes. The biggest since winning was identifying what it really was that won. It wasn't "Ozzie ball", the team hit 200 homers in 2005, and when they hit their 200th in 2006 they had scored the same amount of runs,it was pitching, and while he added Vazquez he made the bullpen, which is now more important than ever, the team's biggest weakness. He had to spend this year to fix it, hopefully it works. Linebrink wouldn't have been my first choice but it was something he had to because of his past decisions.

QUOTE(southsideirish71 @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 05:31 PM) He was playing for a contract last year. How did that work out. Not really. If he hit .300 with 30 homers, he would of been paid $5 million this year. If he does it this season, some moron will give him a boatload of dough for several years.

QUOTE(Vance Law @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 05:19 PM) I agree with the first part regarding Quentin. I don't understand the second part. You don't think Richar will hit enough, but Uribe will? I like the idea of Uribe playing for a contract. He has a lot of talent.

QUOTE(NorthSideSox72 @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 04:41 PM) Just to throw a log on this fire... Crede is hitting .095 this spring. Its probably the long absence from seeing live pitching, more than anything else. But its not helping his trade value probably. Fields is hitting .105. Maybe they should just piss everyone off and get rid of both of them.

QUOTE(NorthSideSox72 @ Mar 10, 2008 -> 11:57 AM) This article in today's Trib has a few interest notes/surprises in it. Among them... --Uribe is a "slight favorite" for 2B --Richar's back is not healing well --Quentin "needs a major rebound to beat out Brian Anderson for the backup outfield spot" --Masset and Wassermann still competing for the last pen spot Anderson over Quentin? Seriously? Or is this just talk to boost BA's value? I still don't get the Masset/Wassermann thing. They are not remotely comparable pitchers. I think its much more down to MacD/Wassermann, with Masset a near-lock, since he's out of options. Quentin hasn't been 100% physically. If it truely was/is a competition for a roster spot, BA has beaten him out to this point.

QUOTE(Vance Law @ Mar 5, 2008 -> 01:33 AM) Sox didn't sustain an injury last season. They sustained 3 to the guys on the major league team who play 3rd base (Crede, Ozuna, and Cintron), and traded the other (Mackowiak) midseason when the season no longer mattered. This was more or less a moot point at third as Fields took over there as expected as plan B once Crede went down. Andy Gonzalez didn't see regular time until the very end of the season when Fields was being tried out in left. Any Guy who Disagrees: "Gonzalez was worthless out there. I should never have to see my Sox put that kind of crap player on the field." Me: "Yes you should. When the season no longer matters at all, when 3 potential 3rd basemen are down with injuries and a 4th is traded, when the starting 3rd baseman from AAA has been moved to left field, you should see the starting AAA shortstop (the 6th option down the list after Crede, Fields, Ozuna, Mackowiak, and Cintron) get some playing time." They may have been forced to put him on the field, but guys like Burgiose (sp) didn't get a shot at all, and apparently deserved one. There is no defending having him lead off. None. Andy played in 67 games. Cherry pick his top 4 offensive games where he went a combined 11-14 and he hit .137 the other 63. Add to that some less than stellar work with the leather and a case could be made a beer league is more his level.

QUOTE(gosox41 @ Mar 9, 2008 -> 05:12 PM) That's exactly what I meant. Thank you for the correction. Bob I think this board is underestimating what its going to take to pry Crede away from KW at least now. The White Sox don't like to risk many dollars and they guaranteed Crede $5.1 million when they could have simply let him walk away. I don't think they would risk $5.1 million in order to hopefully pick up an average prospect or 2. If Crede plays half a season and the Sox are out of it, then they might do a trade like that, but I would be shocked if it doesn't take some legitimate talent to get Crede right now.

QUOTE(Texsox @ Mar 9, 2008 -> 10:23 AM) Trade him while his value is high! I'll bet he will really appreciate that hometown discount he gave to stay a Sox. dumb ass. I've mention this before. Any team would have to be very careful trading guys who signed "hometown discount" contracts. If the Sox decided to trade Konerko, I think if they ever hoped to get these kind of contracts agreed to ever again, they would only be able to trade him to a team he found desirable thus making the urgency of trading him before his 5 and 10 rights kick in a moot point. Trade Konerko to a bad team or a place he doesn't want to be, and you will never get a player to sign a cheaper contract just to play in Chicago again.

Has there been a receiver in the last 25 years who was a bust with another team but then came to the Bears and flourished? I'm thinking Lloyd doesn't make the team.

QUOTE(lostfan @ Mar 6, 2008 -> 09:54 PM) I figured Quentin was eventually going to replace Dye in RF. /shrug If Quentin develops like they think, he will eventually. I don't think it will be this year though. Maybe they move Dye to LF next year.

QUOTE(Tony82087 @ Mar 6, 2008 -> 09:43 PM) But Fathom's point, which I agree with, is if the Sox were clearly looking for an upgrade at SS(even before the re-signed Uribe they said they were), why weren't the Halos contacted to see if Cabrera was available. Did something happen in the landscape of baseball that suddenly made Cabrera obtainable? I have to imagine Cabrera was expendable for all of the off-season, as LAA knew what they were going to target in the off-season. I read a story the other day about the Edgar Renteria, basically slamming him. It mentioned the teams that gave up on him and how because his arm has lost a lot of zip, he has to play a few feet more shallow than most SS, so a lot of balls that most SS get will be hits against the Tigers. The article then mentioned what was rumored last summer that Renteria was very close to being traded for Garland. Considering the Cabrera/Garland trade was so similar it seems weird if KW didn't at least approach the Angels with it before he signed Uribe. Maybe he did, and at that time Cabrera was unavailable, or maybe he just figured he wasn't available. The Angels traded for Garland before until their ownership vetoed Darin Erstad as the return. (BTW, another lucky move for KW) so you had to figure they would have interest. We may never know, but it may not be KW's fault.

QUOTE(ptatc @ Mar 6, 2008 -> 09:17 PM) Look at all of the past world series winning teams and 9 out of 10 will have this type of batting order for the top four hitters. 1. Fast or pesky hitter 2. good bat handler 3. Good ave and power 4. best power guy. I shouldn't have started this again. Every spring I go on this rant because every body has their own ideas on how to build a team. People keep commenting on how Ozzie wants to bring the "Marlins" here but it's the same philosophy most teams use. Being around the game so long you see many things come and go but the typical lineup has remained constant for the most part. I think pesky is more important that fast in the leadoff spot. I know the White Sox are talking up Jerry Owens but lets face it, they were willing to go way over budget to replace him with Torii Hunter and gave up a lot to get Swisher to apparently play CF. KW went with the dramatics to say they specifically targeted Quentin, so he must be who they see eventually most of the time in LF. I really doubt another GM would try to get the fans of his team excited by saying they specifically targeted Jerry Owens, unless its mental care professionals seeing potential new business. I hope if the roster stays as is, that Swisher leads off.

QUOTE(southsider2k5 @ Mar 6, 2008 -> 03:16 PM) It must be that winning attitude and love of the organization Whatever, I want a guy who to stay and you want to get rid of him at any cost and I'm the one with the bad attitude. I actually do love the White Sox, but I just don't agree with everything they do.

QUOTE(southsider2k5 @ Mar 6, 2008 -> 02:36 PM) Good for Kenny. Deal from a position of strength. We don't have to deal Crede, nearly as bad as San Fransico needs him. Why do you rip me then when I say don't trade Crede for garbage?

I'm not a guy who thinks the farm system has to be ranked #1. It was at one time and probably helped KW get his current job. But I do think there has to be sufficient talent in the minors. There has to be guys who can step up in case of injury or poor performance. Everyone goes back and compares things to 2005. The White Sox used 6 starting pitchers in 2005. Its very rare that happens. There has to be someone on the farm you can call up and they can get people out, or call up and get a hit, and or catch and throw the ball, and know which base to throw to etc. Jenks was that guy in 2005. That really hasn't been the case most of KW's tenure and when injuries or poor performance call for a minor league call up, it doesn't look very promising this year either. Middle of the pack or slightly below with a couple of major league ready medicrity would be fine. I just don't see that right now.

QUOTE(NorthSideSox72 @ Mar 5, 2008 -> 08:09 PM) Ah, Mr. Cowley. Not surprised. It is ridiculous to speculate on guys and take their ERA as gospel on March 5th. Its Joe's speciality. Even MacDougal. While obviously everyone would rather he come in and shut guys down, his horrid start still means nothing.

Its hard to feel sorry for them when they will be vastly overpaid in the future. The average raise for arb eligible guys is over 100%, so screw them if they don't like it.

Its only taken Charlie Haeger 10 pitches to get through his last 3 innings. That's my guy.

QUOTE(Pants Rowland @ Mar 4, 2008 -> 03:52 PM) A neighbor of mine had a chance to speak to Stone off the record recently. The subject of the whole fiasco with Dusty came up and Stone's general opinion was that between Dusty, McPhail and Hendry, there weren't two testicles to go around. There is definitely not a lot of respect for Hendry there. People around baseball seem to love him. I suppose it helps that he has a ton of cash to work with and pay every free agent above list price. Maybe they made up. According to the Sun Times, Stone was having lunch with Hendry when Boyer called him about the job opening.

If anyone saw Eric Young on BBTN the other day, Singleton is desperately needed there warts and all.