QUOTE (Jeremy @ Aug 22, 2008 -> 01:18 AM)
I'd take Haeger over Broadway if we're not considering Richard. Charlie's arguably had the better season of the two down in Charlotte and if I were the GM, he'd fit more into our future plans (though I guess that could create concerns about needlessly using up an option). My only concern about going with Charlie is that he's pitched pretty terribly in August. People seem to like Broadway because he had a successful start this season. Based on the bulk of his work, we shouldn't expect that to continue, unless his stuff somehow translates extremely well to the major league level for some indecipherable reason.
Whisler doesn't excite me. The only thing he does very well is keep the ball in the park. His strikeout rates have always been alarmingly low.
I think Haeger uses an option anyways since hes on the 40 man roster. Also Broadway started off amazing this year and then struggled later. Haeger has been pretty consistently bad all year save for maybe a few week stretch.