QUOTE (HickoryHuskers @ Sep 28, 2011 -> 07:18 AM)
I don't see a scenario where 1) and 2) both happen. If you trade both Danks and Quentin, then you're pretty much giving up on winning in 2012, in which case it makes no sense to re-sign Mark.
I think it's more likely that either all three stay or all three are gone. Frankly, I'd be upset if KW chooses any path in between those extremes.
I don't necessarily agree with this. I think they can trade Danks and Quentin, and possibly Floyd, and still want Buehrle back. They might not win the division next year, and probably won't, but what if Peavy starts 32 games, Sale shows he's a future ace, Buehrle is Buehrle, and Humber and another starter are good enough?
And what if a new hitting coach can get Beckham on track? Morel continues to improve? De Aza shows he's a major league player? Viciedo is just as good or better than Quentin, and actually stays healthy? Dunn and Rios return to their averages?
Baseball is a crazy game. Stuff happens when you least expect it. They can field a team that can compete if everything goes right. And that can include Buehrle.