February 3, 20215 yr 24 minutes ago, aeichhor said: Really think anderson is too low The disrespect is real. TA is 2nd in wRC+ for shortstops in 2019 and 2020, only behind Xander Bogaerts. @Look at Ray Ray RunR had a stroke reading this list. Edited February 3, 20215 yr by ron883
February 3, 20215 yr Bichette has played 75 games across 2 years. He has been impressive no doubt, but I'm not putting him above TA across a full season yet.
February 3, 20215 yr 1 minute ago, Kyyle23 said: Story is a good player, but the -best- shortstop in the league? Come on Anderson would hit .400 on the Rockies
February 3, 20215 yr Just now, fathom said: Anderson would hit .400 on the Rockies I mean, Lindor, Anderson and Tatis would all light that park up. Turner too
February 3, 20215 yr 2 hours ago, ron883 said: The disrespect is real. TA is 2nd in wRC+ for shortstops in 2019 and 2020, only behind Xander Bogaerts. @Look at Ray Ray RunR had a stroke reading this list. Yeah but who gives a shit
February 3, 20215 yr 23 minutes ago, fathom said: Anderson would hit .400 on the Rockies I was thinking the exact same thing. Imagine TA hitting in that ballpark. Goodness.
February 3, 20215 yr 3 minutes ago, Vulture said: Yeah but who gives a shit Everybody cares to some extent about rankings, otherwise we wouldn't be talking about them.
February 3, 20215 yr I think the TV channels know and understandably make these lists controversial. I believe that TA was their controversy as well as Story. They want people to talk about the list to drive attention to their lists. That said my list would be: (and my list is predicated of who I'd most want starting this year only for the White Sox as SS: 1 - Lindor 2 - Bogaerts 3 - Tim Anderson 4 - Tatis Jr. (he's almost in TA category from a few years ago that i keep waiting for his underlying stats to catch up (ala baez), but think he's just that good) 5 - Turner 6 - Story 7 - Bichette 8 - Gleyber 9 - Correa 10 - Baez Next up - Wander Franco/Seager/Semien
February 3, 20215 yr 24 minutes ago, BrianAnderson said: I think the TV channels know and understandably make these lists controversial. I believe that TA was their controversy as well as Story. They want people to talk about the list to drive attention to their lists. That said my list would be: (and my list is predicated of who I'd most want starting this year only for the White Sox as SS: 1 - Lindor 2 - Bogaerts 3 - Tim Anderson 4 - Tatis Jr. (he's almost in TA category from a few years ago that i keep waiting for his underlying stats to catch up (ala baez), but think he's just that good) 5 - Turner 6 - Story 7 - Bichette 8 - Gleyber 9 - Correa 10 - Baez Next up - Wander Franco/Seager/Semien 1. Tatis Jr 2. Lindor 3. Turner 4. Bogaerts 5. Story 6. ANDERSON 7. Seager 8. Baez 9. Torres 10. Bichette
February 3, 20215 yr 20 hours ago, ron883 said: The disrespect is real. TA is 2nd in wRC+ for shortstops in 2019 and 2020, only behind Xander Bogaerts. @Look at Ray Ray RunR had a stroke reading this list. Let them sleep Ron, let them sleep.
February 10, 20215 yr MLB.com is stupid. They put Arozarena as the #100 player.. But the #34 prospect.. How can that make any sense hahahah! so 33 other minor leagues would be top 100s?! lol
February 10, 20215 yr 2 minutes ago, Squirmin' for Yermin said: MLB.com is stupid. They put Arozarena as the #100 player.. But the #34 prospect.. How can that make any sense hahahah! so 33 other minor leagues would be top 100s?! lol Different teams do different rankings.
February 11, 20215 yr Robert 94, Moncada 90, Lynn 75.... to be continued. Have to figure the Sox have a chance for at least 4 more amongst Hendriks, Giolito, Abreu , Anderson, Eloy ,Keuchel
February 11, 20215 yr 1 hour ago, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said: Robert 94, Moncada 90, Lynn 75.... to be continued. Have to figure the Sox have a chance for at least 4 more amongst Hendriks, Giolito, Abreu , Anderson, Eloy ,Keuchel Keuchel was listed as one of the "just missed" players before they started, but I'm very confident in the rest of those guys being included
February 11, 20215 yr 6 hours ago, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said: Robert 94, Moncada 90, Lynn 75.... to be continued. Have to figure the Sox have a chance for at least 4 more amongst Hendriks, Giolito, Abreu , Anderson, Eloy ,Keuchel Grandal will for sure make the list.
February 11, 20215 yr 2 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said: Grandal will for sure make the list. I knew I forgot someone.
February 11, 20215 yr On 2/3/2021 at 11:25 AM, BrianAnderson said: I think the TV channels know and understandably make these lists controversial. I believe that TA was their controversy as well as Story. They want people to talk about the list to drive attention to their lists. That said my list would be: (and my list is predicated of who I'd most want starting this year only for the White Sox as SS: 1 - Lindor 2 - Bogaerts 3 - Tim Anderson 4 - Tatis Jr. (he's almost in TA category from a few years ago that i keep waiting for his underlying stats to catch up (ala baez), but think he's just that good) 5 - Turner 6 - Story 7 - Bichette 8 - Gleyber 9 - Correa 10 - Baez Next up - Wander Franco/Seager/Semien Tatis might be the best player in baseball, so yeah he isn't the 4th best SS. Not 1 GM would take Bogaerts over him for the next 3 years.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.