May 25, 20223 yr Neither Moncada and Grandal are hitting there weight. I went to the game last night and noticed that the Red Sox 3rd baseman is playing in the shortstop position when these 2 come up to bat. All they would have to do to get on base would simply bunt down the 3rd baseline. Is it beneath them to do that?. They would get on base every time as long as the 3rd baseman was playing at short.
May 25, 20223 yr 2 minutes ago, WBWSF said: Neither Moncada and Grandal are hitting there weight. I went to the game last night and noticed that the Red Sox 3rd baseman is playing in the shortstop position when these 2 come up to bat. All they would have to do to get on base would simply bunt down the 3rd baseline. Is it beneath them to do that?. They would get on base every time as long as the 3rd baseman was playing at short. Moncada bunted for a double on Sunday.
May 25, 20223 yr Moncada bunted for a double a few games ago. Feel like nothing could hurt at this point with the way these two are playing. Though with Grandal's sub-Konerko speed he still wouldn't beat the throw.
May 25, 20223 yr Someone should remind both Moncada and Grandal that it would help the team if they were to get a hit once in a while.
May 25, 20223 yr 17 minutes ago, Spumoni said: Moncada bunted for a double a few games ago. Feel like nothing could hurt at this point with the way these two are playing. Though with Grandal's sub-Konerko speed he still wouldn't beat the throw. Yas is too busy resting the bat on his shoulder to lay down a bunt.
May 25, 20223 yr 23 minutes ago, Dick Allen said: Moncada bunted for a double on Sunday. He should keep bunting if they are going to give it to him.
May 25, 20223 yr Appears to me that Moncada isn't completely healthy. I don't know what is wrong with Grandal.
May 25, 20223 yr 34 minutes ago, Jerry McNertney said: Someone should remind both Moncada and Grandal that it would help the team if they were to get a hit once in a while. If only someone had thought of that.
May 25, 20223 yr 36 minutes ago, Jerry McNertney said: Someone should remind *the whole lineup* that it would help the team if they were to get a hit once in a while. FIFY
May 25, 20223 yr We've reached the point where if Grandal is not catching, he should not be in the lineup taking ABs at DH or 1B.
May 25, 20223 yr 8 minutes ago, HOFHurt35 said: We've reached the point where if Grandal is not catching, he should not be in the lineup taking ABs at DH or 1B. He’s ahead of only two qualified hitters in OPS, Trent Grisham and Marcus Semien. Avi Garcia isn’t very far off.
May 25, 20223 yr 12 minutes ago, HOFHurt35 said: We've reached the point where if Grandal is not catching, he should not be in the lineup taking ABs at DH or 1B. Remember how we started the year being told that his bat was so important that he'd be DHing more often so we can keep him in the lineup, and now he's becoming a liability at DH? Woops.
May 25, 20223 yr Can someone who is better than me at looking this stuff up post the production we have from LHH this year? Moncada and Grandal are both essential parts of giving us a balanced lineup against RHP, as they both switch hit. Their production has been dog shit. Sheets is also dog shit. Reese McGuire and Leury also hit from the left hand side of plate...also dog shit. Our production from LHH plate appearances has to be complete dog shit.
May 25, 20223 yr Moncada I can kind of understand as he is almost still in spring training for all practical purposes. The rest? No idea.
May 25, 20223 yr Just now, southsider2k5 said: Moncada I can kind of understand as he is almost still in spring training for all practical purposes. The rest? No idea. It's a fair point but there always seems to be an excuse for Moncada. He has a nice floor in terms of WAR because of his defense and ability to draw walks. But he is just not a consistent hitter, he doesn't have consistent power production, and has a career 28 stolen bases for a guy that was supposed to be a base stealer based on his ability to do it in the minors. Moncada has had an underwhelming career compared to his expectations. it's a shame we didn't manage to land Devers/Kopech from Boston for Sale.
May 25, 20223 yr Just now, KrankinSox said: It's a fair point but there always seems to be an excuse for Moncada. He has a nice floor in terms of WAR because of his defense and ability to draw walks. But he is just not a consistent hitter, he doesn't have consistent power production, and has a career 28 stolen bases for a guy that was supposed to be a base stealer based on his ability to do it in the minors. Moncada has had an underwhelming career compared to his expectations. it's a shame we didn't manage to land Devers/Kopech from Boston for Sale. The Sox original ask was Moncada, Kopech and Devers. Boston talked them into a couple of tier 2 players instead of Devers to get the deal done.
May 25, 20223 yr Just now, southsider2k5 said: The Sox original ask was Moncada, Kopech and Devers. Boston talked them into a couple of tier 2 players instead of Devers to get the deal done. Should have asked for Devers, Kopech, and better tier 2 players than we got. Also, that's not really the focus of my post. Moncada is a disappointment in many facets of the game. He isn't a complete bust but he is just not an exciting player and with the exception of 2019, is not all that impressive at all.
May 25, 20223 yr Just now, KrankinSox said: Should have asked for Devers, Kopech, and better tier 2 players than we got. Also, that's not really the focus of my post. Moncada is a disappointment in many facets of the game. He isn't a complete bust but he is just not an exciting player and with the exception of 2019, is not all that impressive at all. I'd like to add that I hope I'm proven wrong. Maybe the excuses for Yoan are legit. 2020 was a weird year with short schedule and him getting covid. 2021 he was pretty good, not great, but solid enough. This year he did get injured. Maybe he turns it around and becomes 2019 Yoan again. I'm not optimistic at all that it will happen but god damn I'd love to see it. We need it.
May 25, 20223 yr 2 minutes ago, KrankinSox said: Should have asked for Devers, Kopech, and better tier 2 players than we got. Also, that's not really the focus of my post. Moncada is a disappointment in many facets of the game. He isn't a complete bust but he is just not an exciting player and with the exception of 2019, is not all that impressive at all. I am also not willing to believe that Devers would have developed the same in Chicago as he did in Boston.
May 25, 20223 yr Just now, southsider2k5 said: I am also not willing to believe that Devers would have developed the same in Chicago as he did in Boston. That's an unknown. It's a fair point but no way to know for sure. And if that is the case, then this org needs a massive overhaul.
May 25, 20223 yr 1 minute ago, KrankinSox said: That's an unknown. It's a fair point but no way to know for sure. And if that is the case, then this org needs a massive overhaul. That's exactly what this team needs, starting with JR.
May 25, 20223 yr 5 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said: I am also not willing to believe that Devers would have developed the same in Chicago as he did in Boston. With the White Sox player development issues it’s silly to assume Devers becomes the same player here. The chances are just as likely IMO that if Devers came in the Sale trade the same dudes would be pining for Moncada instead.
May 25, 20223 yr I am a big Grandal guy, but I am at a loss. He's truly been awful and his 22 play is simply not defendable. At this point, at the very least, he needs to be dropped down to the bottom third of the order. I am also not opposed to getting Perez up here and see what he can do a couple times a week. McGuire is fine back up, but he's not the answer. Definitely don't think we should be running Grandal out at DH much at all once Eloy returns.
May 25, 20223 yr 27 minutes ago, ChiSox59 said: I am a big Grandal guy, but I am at a loss. He's truly been awful and his 22 play is simply not defendable. At this point, at the very least, he needs to be dropped down to the bottom third of the order. I am also not opposed to getting Perez up here and see what he can do a couple times a week. McGuire is fine back up, but he's not the answer. Definitely don't think we should be running Grandal out at DH much at all once Eloy returns. this is where I am at. totally killing the team at the 5 spot or wherever else he lands. he needs to be hitting 7th
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.