1 hour ago1 hr 8 minutes ago, chitownsportsfan said:You're not compounding anything. Compounding the mistake would be allowing Castillo to pitch another 80 innings at a 5.2 ERA before DFAing him, eating the remaining 15 million, in July. That's what hahn would have done.Removing Castillo from the 26 man roster is worth Davis Martin 10/10 times. A 1 WAR 30 year old SP being "cost controlled" is meaningless. He's projected for 1.6 fWAR and an era around 4.5, and the Sox coaching staff saw him in the 2nd half last year, desperate for innings, and mostly said "nah, we're good". You gotta trust the coaches as well here imo. They've earned the benefit of the doubt after 2026 season.I agree. He compounded the Sir Anthony mistake by trading for Castillo, but ridding the team of him and JR of his contract for Davis Martin, to me is a no brainer, and makes a bad couple of moves at least a little better.
1 hour ago1 hr 22 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:Who do you think you would have to add to Benintendi to move him? Example: D-Backs deal away Ketel Marte finally, 2B opens up for Lawlar. Waldschmidt shifts over from LF to CF, Nootbar becomes the LF rather than projected DH and suddenly, they could use a LHH DH.Why not just sign Arozarena?
1 hour ago1 hr 2 minutes ago, caulfield12 said:Why not just sign Arozarena?Because Arozarena costs a multi-year deal, a draft pick and more than $15M AAV.
1 hour ago1 hr 1 hour ago, T R U said:Before anyone Getz too excited, it's important to remember that the last time they dumped someone's $20 million per year salary, they replaced it with a $20 million total salary.Im not sure this means they are about to go into the $20-30 million per year signing range, never mind the fact they have literally never signed someone to that type of deal in their history.Almost 22 years ago now...now adjust for inflatiion?Looked up his Sox contract to see if it was close to $20 / year."The Detroit Tigers snared the last remaining premier free agent of the offseason, agreeing to a five-year, $75 million contract (Benintendi deal!) with former White Sox outfielder Magglio Ordonez, a baseball source told The Associated Press on Saturday.Ordonez's deal could be worth up to $105 million over seven seasons."
1 hour ago1 hr 3 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:Because Arozarena costs a multi-year deal, a draft pick and more than $15M AAV.HappT.WardDubonVarshoGrishamthen would take any of those guys (even moving off CF) over trading for Benintendi and not getting any discount...since he's no longer an everyday LF anywayif Getz had that deal on the table from anyone, he would have been gone yesterday...especially after his CLE ALDS K fiasco Edited 1 hour ago1 hr by caulfield12
1 hour ago1 hr 3 minutes ago, caulfield12 said:HappT.WardDubonVarshoGrishamthen would take any of those guys (even moving off CF) over trading for Benintendi and not getting any discount...since he's no longer an everyday LF anywayif Getz had that deal on the table from anyone, he would have been gone yesterday...especially after his CLE ALDS K fiascoMan I never even suggested he did lol
1 hour ago1 hr 47 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:Who do you think you would have to add to Benintendi to move him? Example: D-Backs deal away Ketel Marte finally, 2B opens up for Lawlar. Waldschmidt shifts over from LF to CF, Nootbar becomes the LF rather than projected DH and suddenly, they could use a LHH DH.How about just releasing him? So they pay $15 mill in dead money - it's virtually dead even if he plays. Sox should have DFAd him 2 years ago - JR can deal with 1 zombie year.
1 hour ago1 hr 40 minutes ago, Dick Allen said:I agree. He compounded the Sir Anthony mistake by trading for Castillo, but ridding the team of him and JR of his contract for Davis Martin, to me is a no brainer, and makes a bad couple of moves at least a little better."He's fairly likeable."About like GRF.
1 hour ago1 hr 42 minutes ago, chitownsportsfan said:You're not compounding anything. Compounding the mistake would be allowing Castillo to pitch another 80 innings at a 5.2 ERA before DFAing him, eating the remaining 15 million, in July. That's what hahn would have done.Removing Castillo from the 26 man roster is worth Davis Martin 10/10 times. A 1 WAR 30 year old SP being "cost controlled" is meaningless. He's projected for 1.6 fWAR and an era around 4.5, and the Sox coaching staff saw him in the 2nd half last year, desperate for innings, and mostly said "nah, we're good". You gotta trust the coaches as well here imo. They've earned the benefit of the doubt after 2026 season.But again, it goes to my point that you can't look at this trade just as a stand alone. The White Sox need starting pitching. That is an objective fact, was true when the offseason started, and is still true today.They signed Dustin May, but got rid of Davis Martin. They both pitched a nearly identical 146 innings last year. Luis Castillo is absolutely terrible I'm very happy I don't have to watch him pitch next year for the Sox. He would have most likely gotten some starts early for the Sox, but can't imagine he would have lasted in the rotation long. So they still need starting pitching, and just not just depth. The logical conclusion is they made this move to do just that, but that is an unknown right now. You, me and anyone else outside of the building really don't know who they are targeting. Our hope is XYZ free agent, but we also don't know their budget for 2027. You also mention the coaches, and earning the benefit of the doubt. Getz didn't make the Castillo move at the deadline by himself. In fact, this was mentioned in the Castillo article the day after they made the trade:“I think that there’s going to be opportunity to perhaps tweak an arsenal or some of the delivery,” Getz added. He pointed to director of pitching Brian Bannister and pitching coach Zach Bove’s success with recent pitching additions like Jordan Hicks.All I'm saying is we know what we know, and I want to see what else happens before judging the move in totality.
1 hour ago1 hr 31 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:Because Arozarena costs a multi-year deal, a draft pick and more than $15M AAV.But is that draft pick was tied to last cba and does that get carried when they have a new one if thats still part of the qualifying offer deal.?
1 hour ago1 hr 10 minutes ago, GreenSox said:How about just releasing him? So they pay $15 mill in dead money - it's virtually dead even if he plays. Sox should have DFAd him 2 years ago - JR can deal with 1 zombie year.I don't disagree...but it's Jerry
1 hour ago1 hr Just now, Whisox05 said:But is that draft pick was tied to last cba and does that get carried when they have a new one if thats still part of the qualifying offer deal.?Yes. It would have to be. Changes like that would go into effect next offseason
1 hour ago1 hr But this offseason counts for 2027 which has nothing to it currently 1 minute ago, Bob Sacamano said:Yes. It would have to be. Changes like that would go into effect next offseason
1 hour ago1 hr 34 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:Because Arozarena costs a multi-year deal, a draft pick and more than $15M AAV.Feels like whatever deal he signs will be a clunker.
1 hour ago1 hr Just now, Lukakke Appling said:Feels like whatever deal he signs will be a clunker.Yep. I don't want him. Edited 1 hour ago1 hr by Bob Sacamano
1 hour ago1 hr 1 minute ago, Whisox05 said:But this offseason counts for 2027 which has nothing to it currentlyI'm not sure I understand. Players were offered the QO under the current parameters. That would have to be grandfathered in to the first season post-new CBA agreement. Draft pick compensation isn't going to change in the middle of the offseason. Edited 1 hour ago1 hr by Bob Sacamano
1 hour ago1 hr 2 minutes ago, Lukakke Appling said:Feels like whatever deal he signs will be a clunker.Can't be any worse than where Santander is at now.If you don't sign the Top 10-15 FA's, you're playing in the White Sox pool.That means rejecting Peralta and King for their flaws.Heck, it's easy to pick apart Skubal getting $40-45 million per year, too.He was very very very good but not quite as elite last season after returning from injury and does have a lot of wear and tear with those workloads.It was even a concern to some about signing the reliable to take 30+ starts year after year Dylan Cease. Fortinately, his worst case scenario shoulder injury seems to have been avoided. Edited 58 minutes ago58 min by caulfield12
57 minutes ago57 min 2 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:I'm not sure I understand. Players were offered the QO under the current parameters. That would have to be grandfathered in to the first season post-new CBA agreement. Draft pick compensation isn't going to change in the middle of the offseason.Under the current MLB Collective Bargaining Agreement (expiring December 1, 2026), teams receive draft pick compensation primarily when a player they extend a Qualifying Offer (QO) to rejects it and signs elsewhere, while Competitive Balance Draft picks provide extra selections to smaller-market and lower-revenue clubs. Both MLB and the MLBPA have proposed eliminating QO draft pick compensation in negotiations for the next CBA.
55 minutes ago55 min 1 minute ago, Whisox05 said:Under the current MLB Collective Bargaining Agreement (expiring December 1, 2026), teams receive draft pick compensation primarily when a player they extend a Qualifying Offer (QO) to rejects it and signs elsewhere, while Competitive Balance Draft picks provide extra selections to smaller-market and lower-revenue clubs. Both MLB and the MLBPA have proposed eliminating QO draft pick compensation in negotiations for the next CBA.Idk I don't think that will take immediate effect. That will apply to next offseason and forward.
53 minutes ago53 min Just now, Bob Sacamano said:Idk I don't think that will take immediate effect. That will apply to next offseason and forward.The cba that has the draft pick compensation ends dec 1st. This current offseason counts for 2027 and has no cba for guidance
53 minutes ago53 min I find it funny that the people who hate this trade keep saying "We need pitching and gave up two arms" as if the problem was that the Sox's literally couldn't find enough guys to fill a roster. It would be like if someone had a poorly furnished apartment, needed a good couch in the living room, a dining room table, etc. Are you going to get pissed off that they tossed the beanbag chair and folding card table to make room for the new stuff?
52 minutes ago52 min Just now, Whisox05 said:The cba that has the draft pick compensation ends dec 1st. This current offseason counts for 2027 and has no cba for guidanceI'm saying they can agree to keep the status quo through the remainder of this offseason (whoever is even left to sign that has a QO attached). The compensation that's already been agreed to isn't going to change in the middle of an offseason. Edited 52 minutes ago52 min by Bob Sacamano
51 minutes ago51 min 12 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:I'm not sure I understand. Players were offered the QO under the current parameters. That would have to be grandfathered in to the first season post-new CBA agreement.is there gonna be a grace period on the floor too? sounds like there might be. fucking sucks we get relevant just as the cba expires. as sox fans, figures.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.