Look, Sheets could well be a dude. But realistically, again we are looking at a SSS in a rookie year. He's also a guy who is even worse defensively than Vaughn. Sure he could have figure it out and turned into prime Adam Dunn, but I also think TLR protected him and used him in a lot of favorable match ups during his time here, and it is likely we could be looking at some very real regression to the means as well. I would love to see him hit at a high level, but if I have the choice between Vaughn and Sheets, there is literally zero question in my mind the answer is Vaughn.