Timmy U

The blame for Shields is wishful thinking on the part of the front office. They got off to a blistering start, then they gave it all back similar to this year’s Mets. They chose to believe that they could somehow contend rather than looking at the evidence that the team just wasn’t that good. Even if Shields had been good, the trade would have been disastrous. The fact that he was bad is just the cherry on top. I remember that the details of the trade leaked out and Keith Law was like “Nooooo!” He had scouts from other orgs telling him that, were he eligible for the draft, He Who Shall Not Be Named would have been picked 1-1. We ought to hire those scouts.

Saw that someone posted Madrigal not playin in yesterday’s thread, so bumping it up.

The problem with the Sox in those years was they had like 5 good players and everyone else suuucked. I saw an article on ESPN back then asking seriously did the Sox have the worst collection of position players in history! Hard to sign enough free agents to make up for that, especially when players are aging faster and a lot of Free agents fall off a cliff right after you sign them ala Adam Dunn. You can’t seriously expect them to sign like 10 guys. Now they have committed to building some depth. Hopefully some of those guys turn out to be stars. If so, they’ll have enough quantity to build around them.

I like a ton of the guys we got, it’s just a 19 year old who’s gonna hit 25-30 homers in AA and can play shortstop? Pretty darn good player. Hooefully it’s the last of the really terrible moves they made trying to compete unrealistically.

If he sticks at short and Eloy is a left fielder? Kinda.

I agree. It’s Jimenez, Robert, and one of Gonzalez, Basabe, Adolfo, and Rutherford. Possibly 2 if the use the DH slot.

There are at least 3 OF jobs open, I guarantee Robert gets every chance in the world to win one of them. Also, he’s better in center than Gonzalez. That said, excellent problem to have.

Congrats to Cease. Worked hard to get this honor. You got to imagine it was going to be Robert before he got hurt, but well deserved for Basabe. Did a little of everything at W-S. Hope this gets him going at Birmingham, he’s really been slumping. Sinking suspicion that He Who Shall Not Be Named is going to be the best prospect involved in our various trades. Was a head scratcher at the time, but water under the bridge, I guess.

Hard to believe Moncada a) wants to move positions at all b) is going to be better than Robert at playin CF. That is assuming Robert can play for more than 3 weeks withou getting hurt.

First mistake I ever made.?

Right now, definitely Giolito for me. Also Delmonico. Love Yoan too, I am just holding out hope he doesn’t suck.

Doesn't look like him at the plate or anything, and doesn't have quite as much arm, but Gonzalez could be the second coming of Adam Eaton for the Sox, and that wouldn't be a bad thing.

Wow. Is Moncada sleeping with some umps’ wife? Never gets any calls.

Especially if you’re the 16 year old.

Sure, but now that ship has sailed, plus they must have worked the whole budget around full slot value. Still, looks like they got some value down lower. Pretty much the whole value of the draft is the first round so... I guess you gotta do what you gotta do.

Ha ha. It’s like The Producers. In mlb, you can make more money with a flop than with a hit.

Full slot?! Don’t they just have to pay full slot for pick 5? Hmm. Oh well. I wasn’t that big a fan, so obviously I’m going to nitpick. Would have been nice to get one more high school guy.

Tigers have lost 11 in a row to get right back into this thing. Thank god we have sucked against them head to head.

Fathom, you are correct, sir. I am just sick of watching mediocre retreads that we hope to trade. I don’t even want to watch him in Charlotte. When is Burdi supposed to be ready to see game action?

He’s another lefty, though.

I want Jose Ruiz or Ian Hamilton, or even Thyago Viera, but I am sure we’ll be seeing more Gregory Infante.

Oh that’s not fair. Our Lady of Lourdes couldn’t fix Rondon.

Joe West has been guessing all game.

Hopefully he’s fine, but he really has been hurt a lot. It seems like whenever he’s just about to get his timing back, he gets hurt again. Pretty frustrating

True. Ricky loves Omar. Can’t see why.