Non-White Sox Off-Season Hot Stove

[tray]

IMO, Sosa is probably going to hit about 20 more HR than Meidroth and should hit for a higher BA.  

I might be wrong but that is my opinion from watching the WSox last year, 

If it was up to me, I'd take the extra 20HR and live with a few more errors.  A lot of teams put a premium on HRs , likely because HRs win a lot of games. 

To me, Meidroth is Madrigal 2.0, not a mighty mite like Pedroia, and for being a small player, he did not prove to be a very good base runner. Shriff loved the guy but I didn't, maybe because of the Madrigal experience.

[Lukakke Appling]

32 minutes ago, Johno said:

Can we push Sosa on them?

Kim was their starting SS, so I don’t imagine Sosa is of much interest. 

[Chicago White Sox]

9 minutes ago, tray said:

IMO, Sosa is probably going to hit about 20 more HR than Meidroth and should hit for a higher BA.  

I might be wrong but that is my opinion from watching the WSox last year, 

If it was up to me, I'd take the extra 20HR and live with a few more errors.  A lot of teams put a premium on HRs , likely because HRs win a lot of games. 

To me, Meidroth is Madrigal 2.0, not a mighty mite like Pedroia, and for being a small player, he did not prove to be a very good base runner. Shriff loved the guy but I didn't, maybe because of the Madrigal experience.

You are completely ignoring walks and OBP, which is another big edge for Chase over Sosa.  I also think the Madrigal comp is a very poor one.  Nick was tiny while Meidroth is fairly average height (neither offer much power).  Meidroth is also one of the most selective hitters in baseball and Nick was one of the most aggressive.

[Bob Sacamano]

Too bad we couldn’t combine the 2: Chenyn Sodroth

[Lukakke Appling]

26 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:

You are completely ignoring walks and OBP, which is another big edge for Chase over Sosa.  I also think the Madrigal comp is a very poor one.  Nick was tiny while Meidroth is fairly average height (neither offer much power).  Meidroth is also one of the most selective hitters in baseball and Nick was one of the most aggressive.

Meidroth also plays smart baseball, whereas Madrigal plays ….baseball?

[Lip Man 1]

17 minutes ago, Lukakke Appling said:

Meidroth also plays smart baseball, whereas Madrigal plays ….baseball?

And both are a lot 'baseball-smarter' than Sosa. That's for sure. 

[WhiteSox2023]

1 hour ago, Bob Sacamano said:

Too bad we couldn’t combine the 2: Chenyn Sodroth

I prefer Lenchase Meidrosa.

[tray]

3 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said:

You are completely ignoring walks and OBP, which is another big edge for Chase over Sosa.  I also think the Madrigal comp is a very poor one.  Nick was tiny while Meidroth is fairly average height (neither offer much power).  Meidroth is also one of the most selective hitters in baseball and Nick was one of the most aggressive.

Not sure that Meidroth is really 5'10" as listed in his bio, but whatever. He walks more but just from my memory of last years games, he was not a very good base runner. 20 more HR. I'll take that every day and every way. You can't make a 20 HR deficit up that easily with walks, dinks and dunks and smoke and mirrors.  But everyone has their set of favorite players and for some reason Sosa is not on many of them. He isn't a favorite of mine, but I am one who values the long ball and I just don't see where the WSox pick up 20HR  over what they expect from the rest of the line-up. And while Sosa sucks on D, once again, he led the team in HR last year.