Thursday at 11:27 AM1 day https://www.fangraphs.com/players/dustin-may/19716/stats/pitching2.8 fWAR in 2026Projected at 2.0 Edited Thursday at 11:29 AM1 day by caulfield12
Thursday at 11:51 AM1 day Every time I see that guy throw a ball, I think his arm is gonna break off and fly out of the stadium.
Thursday at 12:05 PM1 day 15 minutes ago, Kyyle23 said:Every time I see that guy throw a ball, I think his arm is gonna break off and fly out of the stadium.Yeah it’s pretty cool.
Thursday at 01:39 PM1 day The risk isn’t worth the mediocre reward for May.They need someone more likely to provide stability and innings to the rotation.
Thursday at 01:48 PM1 day Eh I guess he’s in the tier I more expect them to ship in but man if you brought him in and only him that would be disappointing. There would have to be a bigger add
Thursday at 02:28 PM1 day 40 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:Eh I guess he’s in the tier I more expect them to ship in but man if you brought him in and only him that would be disappointing. There would have to be a bigger addIf this is the single “big” move to improve the rotation, it wouldn’t move the needle much. He would be an improvement over Kay at the backend of the rotation, but not much more than that. Edited Thursday at 02:29 PM1 day by WhiteSox2023
Thursday at 02:38 PM1 day 10 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:If this is the single “big” move to improve the rotation, it wouldn’t move the needle much. He would be an improvement over Kay at the backend of the rotation, but not much more than that.I’m not convinced he is even that much better than Kay to be honest with you.
Thursday at 02:41 PM1 day Sox fans: We are going to be spend big in free agency! We have a low payroll AND playoff money!Getz:
Thursday at 03:50 PM1 day 1 hour ago, ChiSoxFanMike said:I’m not convinced he is even that much better than Kay to be honest with you.I think May is better, but considering he is always an injury risk, I could see someone arguing that they would rather have Kay at a cheaper price. Edited Thursday at 03:50 PM1 day by WhiteSox2023
Thursday at 03:57 PM1 day Walks too many, but he's got some skill.But, we have somewhat of a backlog of pitchers like that.
Thursday at 03:59 PM1 day 1 hour ago, southsider2k5 said:Sox fans: We are going to be spend big in free agency! We have a low payroll AND playoff money!Getz: Kay and May and pray for rain! 🤣
Thursday at 05:09 PM1 day May works for the roles they seem to favor: guys who straddle the line between a low innings starter/multi-innings reliever. They may see it as a market inefficiency. Maybe he’s a starter/bulk guy, maybe he’s an innings eating reliever like Vasil and Newcomb the last two years. They would throw him in a mix with Sandlin, Schultz, McDougal, and both Smiths and see how it all works out. I don’t love it, but I don’t hate it. I fear 5 years of Peralta would be another Castillo times 5. May would be a half measure, but potentially useful.
Thursday at 05:15 PM1 day If you're interested in Dustin May, you might as well just re-sign Fedde. Just my 2 cents.
Thursday at 05:25 PM1 day 25 minutes ago, JoshPR said:I feel the Sox dumpster diving againRemember who still owns the team?
Thursday at 05:46 PM1 day 31 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:If you're interested in Dustin May, you might as well just re-sign Fedde. Just my 2 cents.but then you can't sell the optimism over the new flashy toy!
Thursday at 08:01 PM1 day I very much doubt May would be the big get of the offseason, so I don’t mind the interest. I’m skeptical there’s much more there than we’ve already seen from May though. Back end guy.
Thursday at 10:38 PM1 day 2 hours ago, Lukakke Appling said:I very much doubt May would be the big get of the offseason, so I don’t mind the interest. I’m skeptical there’s much more there than we’ve already seen from May though. Back end guy.For a back end sure. But knowing the Sox I don't have high hope. Hope they don't blow this one like the last rebuild
Thursday at 10:43 PM1 day 4 minutes ago, JoshPR said:For a back end sure. But knowing the Sox I don't have high hope. Hope they don't blow this one like the last rebuildIf Evan Phillips is worth $10 million plus, May will surely get $15 million, if not more.Ofc that's still a relative bargain compared to Cadtillo.
Thursday at 10:50 PM1 day 6 hours ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Kay and May and pray for rain! 🤣Kay & May and pray for RayRay
55 minutes ago55 min On 11/12/2026 at 5:39 AM, Snopek said:The risk isn’t worth the mediocre reward for May.They need someone more likely to provide stability and innings to the rotation.Well seems like they might go for pitching in the 2nd year after their TJ recovery. Sometimes that's a sweet spot for a big improvement or an injury filled year.I don't have anything to back that up but with with so many pitchers having TJS there's plenty out there who have improved and become very good pitchers
29 minutes ago29 min 25 minutes ago, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said:Well seems like they might go for pitching in the 2nd year after their TJ recovery. Sometimes that's a sweet spot for a big improvement or an injury filled year.I don't have anything to back that up but with with so many pitchers having TJS there's plenty out there who have improved and become very good pitchersotoh guys like Walker Buehler nowhere close to the pitcher he was pre injury...which was Top Ten in the majorsMay also hasn't been anywhere closehis velo also down 2-3 mph from peak
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.