Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal

Featured Replies

4 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:

fWAR, Stuff+, & age amongst that group:

  • Gray: 3.4 | 101 | 37

  • Martinez: 2.9 | 98 | 36

  • May: 2.8 | 102 | 29

  • King: 2.6 | 95 | 32

  • Mize: 2.3 | 88 | 30

  • Peralta: 1.9 | 97 | 31

  • Holmes: 1.8 (18 GS) | 96 | 34

  • Bubic: 1.0 (9 GS) | 95 | 29

  • Ray: 0.9 | 94 | 35

May is the youngest, has the highest Stuff+, and just posted the 3rd best fWAR out of this entire group. While I’d certainly take King & Peralta over him (though they will be at a higher price point), I’d no doubt take him over Martinez, Mize, Bubic, & Ray. Holmes would be a bit of a toss up for me though.

I guess factoring in what I think each could get paid as well (could be and probably completely off) and trying to guesstimate off that compares. Also handedness might be a factor on some since we may need a lefty if Kay gets bumped to the pen.

Edited by Bob Sacamano

  • Replies 300
  • Views 9.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

Posted Images

13 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:

fWAR, Stuff+, & age amongst that group:

  • Gray: 3.4 | 101 | 37

  • Martinez: 2.9 | 98 | 36

  • May: 2.8 | 102 | 29

  • King: 2.6 | 95 | 32

  • Mize: 2.3 | 88 | 30

  • Peralta: 1.9 | 97 | 31

  • Holmes: 1.8 (18 GS) | 96 | 34

  • Bubic: 1.0 (9 GS) | 95 | 29

  • Ray: 0.9 | 94 | 35

May is the youngest, has the highest Stuff+, and just posted the 3rd best fWAR out of this entire group. While I’d certainly take King & Peralta over him (though they will be at a higher price point), I’d no doubt take him over Martinez, Mize, Bubic, & Ray. Holmes would be a bit of a toss up for me though.

And like I said, don’t necessarily hate the signing, just want to see more. He’s fine as a 4 or 5 in my mind

1 hour ago, Bob Sacamano said:

I guess factoring in what I think each could get paid as well (could be and probably completely off) and trying to guesstimate off that compares. Also handedness might be a factor on some since we may need a lefty if Kay gets bumped to the pen.

Hence Taira

but only two weeks to close a deal with Thanksgiving looming as well

Edited by caulfield12

2 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said:

fWAR, Stuff+, & age amongst that group:

  • Gray: 3.4 | 101 | 37

  • Martinez: 2.9 | 98 | 36

  • May: 2.8 | 102 | 29

  • King: 2.6 | 95 | 32

  • Mize: 2.3 | 88 | 30

  • Peralta: 1.9 | 97 | 31

  • Holmes: 1.8 (18 GS) | 96 | 34

  • Bubic: 1.0 (9 GS) | 95 | 29

  • Ray: 0.9 | 94 | 35

May is the youngest, has the highest Stuff+, and just posted the 3rd best fWAR out of this entire group. While I’d certainly take King & Peralta over him (though they will be at a higher price point), I’d no doubt take him over Martinez, Mize, Bubic, & Ray. Holmes would be a bit of a toss up for me though.

The problem is that May hasn’t had a single really good season in recent history better than the other guys. It’s mostly projections, hope, and prayer with May. The other guys have actually done it before. Until it actually happens, May is just a #4/#5 guy that has trouble staying healthy.

If Getz also acquires a #1/#2 starter, fine. If not, May was a foolish signing.

Edited by WhiteSox2023

5 hours ago, WhiteSox2023 said:

The problem is that May hasn’t had a single really good season in recent history better than the other guys. It’s mostly projections, hope, and prayer with May. The other guys have actually done it before. Until it actually happens, May is just a #4/#5 guy that has trouble staying healthy.

If Getz also acquires a #1/#2 starter, fine. If not, May was a foolish signing.

He literally just out-performed most of those guys last year as the post above indicated. And again, 2.8 fWAR is #3 SP production and well worth a $17.5M salary. People are over-indexing on his ERA which is not predictive at all.

I agree that he can’t be the only addition. We 100% need another SP that can challenge Burke for the #1 spot in the rotation. Ideally that’s Peralta or King, with Taira as a riskier 3rd option. Anything less than that is a failure in roster building for a team with championship aspirations next year.

But in isolation, May is the type of high risk, high reward #3 SP we should be targeting. We have a fuckton of SP depth that can absorb innings in the event of injury, but need guys with ceiling who can provide higher quality ones. IMO, the OD rotation for next year should be as follows:

  1. <Peralta/King>

  2. Burke

  3. May

  4. Taylor

  5. Martin/Castillo

That has a chance to be a really good rotation if everything clicks. However, if Martin doesn’t reclaim his 1H 2026 form or if Castillo proves to be the turd we saw last year, then Schultz should be the next man up. That would give you a rotation with five high ceiling arms assuming they can get Schultz back to what he once was. And behind them you’d have plenty of options including Thorpe, Sandlin, Kay, & possibly McDougal in the event of injury or other need.

But none of it works without the anchor at the top of the rotation. And we can’t stop spending now because the trade market is not really an option as the farm system needs to be protected. Maybe that changes at mid season if Carlson can get his bat going, but for now, we don’t have the pieces outside of Bonemer to land said pitcher and he’s far too important to the 2027 plan.

2 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said:

He literally just out-performed most of those guys last year as the post above indicated. And again, 2.8 fWAR is #3 SP production and well worth a $17.5M salary. People are over-indexing on his ERA which is not predictive at all.

I agree that he can’t be the only addition. We 100% need another SP that can challenge Burke for the #1 spot in the rotation. Ideally that’s Peralta or King, with Taira as a riskier 3rd option. Anything less than that is a failure in roster building for a team with championship aspirations next year.

But in isolation, May is the type of high risk, high reward #3 SP we should be targeting. We have a fuckton of SP depth that can absorb innings in the event of injury, but need guys with ceiling who can provide higher quality ones. IMO, the OD rotation for next year should be as follows:

  1. <Peralta/King>

  2. Burke

  3. May

  4. Taylor

  5. Martin/Castillo

That has a chance to be a really good rotation if everything clicks. However, if Martin doesn’t reclaim his 1H 2026 form or if Castillo proves to be the turd we saw last year, then Schultz should be the next man up. That would give you a rotation with five high ceiling arms assuming they can get Schultz back to what he once was. And behind them you’d have plenty of options including Thorpe, Sandlin, Kay, & possibly McDougal in the event of injury or other need.

But none of it works without the anchor at the top of the rotation. And we can’t stop spending now because the trade market is not really an option as the farm system needs to be protected. Maybe that changes at mid season if Carlson can get his bat going, but for now, we don’t have the pieces outside of Bonemer to land said pitcher and he’s far too important to the 2027 plan.

Colson is your trade chip

33 minutes ago, fathom said:

Colson is your trade chip

You'd be selling low right now. Who plays shortstop in this scenario?

1 hour ago, fathom said:

Colson is your trade chip

They'd be stupid AF to trade Colson now. They aren't getting anything for him unless the perception is that the Sox really fucked him up.

Just now, southsider2k5 said:

They'd be stupid AF to trade Colson now. They aren't getting anything for him unless the perception is that the Sox really fucked him up.

And he's 100% healthy with the back/fundamental SS movement and swing mechanics.

4 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said:

He literally just out-performed most of those guys last year as the post above indicated. And again, 2.8 fWAR is #3 SP production and well worth a $17.5M salary. People are over-indexing on his ERA which is not predictive at all.

I agree that he can’t be the only addition. We 100% need another SP that can challenge Burke for the #1 spot in the rotation. Ideally that’s Peralta or King, with Taira as a riskier 3rd option. Anything less than that is a failure in roster building for a team with championship aspirations next year.

But in isolation, May is the type of high risk, high reward #3 SP we should be targeting. We have a fuckton of SP depth that can absorb innings in the event of injury, but need guys with ceiling who can provide higher quality ones. IMO, the OD rotation for next year should be as follows:

  1. <Peralta/King>

  2. Burke

  3. May

  4. Taylor

  5. Martin/Castillo

That has a chance to be a really good rotation if everything clicks. However, if Martin doesn’t reclaim his 1H 2026 form or if Castillo proves to be the turd we saw last year, then Schultz should be the next man up. That would give you a rotation with five high ceiling arms assuming they can get Schultz back to what he once was. And behind them you’d have plenty of options including Thorpe, Sandlin, Kay, & possibly McDougal in the event of injury or other need.

But none of it works without the anchor at the top of the rotation. And we can’t stop spending now because the trade market is not really an option as the farm system needs to be protected. Maybe that changes at mid season if Carlson can get his bat going, but for now, we don’t have the pieces outside of Bonemer to land said pitcher and he’s far too important to the 2027 plan.

You keep going back to this one stat, so I started looking around. While his fWAR is 2.8, his bWAR was 0.4.

Looking deeper, he got a career low in ground balls (high in flyballs), his BABIP was .318, his soft contact rate was also a career low. Of his pitches, his sinker was also at a career low, and he seems to try to replace that with a slider/cutter/change output.

His hard hit rate plus HR rates exploded.

In a simple sense, his pitch mix changed a lot, and he got his A LOT harder.

From the numbers, I think fWAR has to be looking more at the predictive stuff, versus the output stuff, as that would explain a lot of a 2.4 WAR difference. Most of his expected and predicted numbers liked his final output better than his bottom line actually did. Having one of the best defensive teams in MLB behind him in Milwaukee, plus a good defensive team in STL, you can't explain away the difference in his FIP and actual ERA as a defense behind him hurting him kind of fluke, so I am not sure what the causes him to miss his expected numbers by a full run that will be fixed by being a White Sox next year. Milwaukee has also become a pitching factory and couldn't do anything for him.

I also wonder if as an act to try to preserve his health, they are taking the heavy sinker away from May, and are moving him more towards side to side moving pitches which isn't working as well so far (at least).

More than anything I want to hear someone say in detail, what about next year is actually going to push him towards his expected numbers, other than just his expected numbers getting repeated.

Didn't see if this was posted yet - the high BABIP is also likely due to his hard hit % so I don't know if that's going to go down as much as Dylan thinks. The fastball, cutter and changeup all get good swing & miss, and the sinker is a quality pitch. Maybe he just needs to throw the sweeper less.

49 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:

You keep going back to this one stat, so I started looking around. While his fWAR is 2.8, his bWAR was 0.4.

Looking deeper, he got a career low in ground balls (high in flyballs), his BABIP was .318, his soft contact rate was also a career low. Of his pitches, his sinker was also at a career low, and he seems to try to replace that with a slider/cutter/change output.

His hard hit rate plus HR rates exploded.

In a simple sense, his pitch mix changed a lot, and he got his A LOT harder.

From the numbers, I think fWAR has to be looking more at the predictive stuff, versus the output stuff, as that would explain a lot of a 2.4 WAR difference. Most of his expected and predicted numbers liked his final output better than his bottom line actually did. Having one of the best defensive teams in MLB behind him in Milwaukee, plus a good defensive team in STL, you can't explain away the difference in his FIP and actual ERA as a defense behind him hurting him kind of fluke, so I am not sure what the causes him to miss his expected numbers by a full run that will be fixed by being a White Sox next year. Milwaukee has also become a pitching factory and couldn't do anything for him.

I also wonder if as an act to try to preserve his health, they are taking the heavy sinker away from May, and are moving him more towards side to side moving pitches which isn't working as well so far (at least).

More than anything I want to hear someone say in detail, what about next year is actually going to push him towards his expected numbers, other than just his expected numbers getting repeated.

The thing that scared me about Castillo when they traded for him was his home runs allowed last season.and he was coming to pitch at The Rate. If May is prone to giving up the long ball too...yikes

12 minutes ago, wegner said:

The thing that scared me about Castillo when they traded for him was his home runs allowed last season.and he was coming to pitch at The Rate. If May is prone to giving up the long ball too...yikes

I would just love to hear something more concrete than "luck" when May has been through two of the best pitching organizations in MLB and hasn't been able to get into a zone around his potential. I get the arm injury in the middle might have derailed things, but last year was the second year pitching after injury, which is when stuff is supposed to stabilize and rebound, but it didn't seem to happen. His TJS date was July 2023, so that stuff should be past.

47 minutes ago, almagest said:

Didn't see if this was posted yet - the high BABIP is also likely due to his hard hit % so I don't know if that's going to go down as much as Dylan thinks. The fastball, cutter and changeup all get good swing & miss, and the sinker is a quality pitch. Maybe he just needs to throw the sweeper less.

I like FIP as a stat, but there are clearly pitchers who it does not account well for. I don't think you can say with a ton of confidence that the pitcher has no control over balls in play. That's kind of ridiculous. Soft contact on average will result in lower BAA than hard contact. I don't think that's some sort of rocket science. You can't just assume somebody will have league average BABIP or LOB% if they're making bad pitches. It's like that Patrick Mahomes meme where if you just adjust his TD% to league average, he's like Dak Prescott. Contact quality absolutely matters when judging pitchers and it is something they have some sort of control over. A lot of May's expected stats last year were closer to his actual ERA than FIP. Which makes me think he wasn't that unlucky.

That being said, he did change up his arsenal last year and his peripherals did improve over 2025. Having 3 fastball shapes and throwing them all at around 20-25% each is something that you can have a lot of success with (see Schlittler). It's just that his other offerings were terrible last year. Maybe they think they can fix his sweeper.

3 hours ago, fathom said:

Colson is your trade chip

Bonemer and Antonacci are trade chips. Even Vargas after this year, if they aren't going to re-sign him. Of course I wouldn't trade any of them.
But if a trade must happen. make it for other young players. No young for old; no veteran starter. Rangers, e.g. already trying to get out of their silly trade for Gore.

1 hour ago, southsider2k5 said:

You keep going back to this one stat, so I started looking around. While his fWAR is 2.8, his bWAR was 0.4.

Looking deeper, he got a career low in ground balls (high in flyballs), his BABIP was .318, his soft contact rate was also a career low. Of his pitches, his sinker was also at a career low, and he seems to try to replace that with a slider/cutter/change output.

His hard hit rate plus HR rates exploded.

In a simple sense, his pitch mix changed a lot, and he got his A LOT harder.

From the numbers, I think fWAR has to be looking more at the predictive stuff, versus the output stuff, as that would explain a lot of a 2.4 WAR difference. Most of his expected and predicted numbers liked his final output better than his bottom line actually did. Having one of the best defensive teams in MLB behind him in Milwaukee, plus a good defensive team in STL, you can't explain away the difference in his FIP and actual ERA as a defense behind him hurting him kind of fluke, so I am not sure what the causes him to miss his expected numbers by a full run that will be fixed by being a White Sox next year. Milwaukee has also become a pitching factory and couldn't do anything for him.

I also wonder if as an act to try to preserve his health, they are taking the heavy sinker away from May, and are moving him more towards side to side moving pitches which isn't working as well so far (at least).

More than anything I want to hear someone say in detail, what about next year is actually going to push him towards his expected numbers, other than just his expected numbers getting repeated.

He changed his release point and his pitch mix up last year. What's interesting is that his sweeper was actually pretty good in 2025 with his old release point and he also threw it almost 40% of the time. It was his worst pitch in 2026. His 2025 reminds me of 2026 Erick Fedde actually. Except Fedde got much better results despite the shaky peripherals. Here's to hoping they can build up May's sweeper again like they did Fedde's last year.

1 minute ago, chw42 said:

He changed his release point and his pitch mix up last year. What's interesting is that his sweeper was actually pretty good in 2025 with his old release point and he also threw it almost 40% of the time. It was his worst pitch in 2026. His 2025 reminds me of 2026 Erick Fedde actually. Except Fedde got much better results despite the shaky peripherals. Here's to hoping they can build up May's sweeper again like they did Fedde's last year.

I feel like this is probably where the give and take took place. They changed the release point to try to save the elbow, but it doesn't work the same as it used to. Almost the exact same thing happened to Shane Smith last year, and we never heard from him again. Seems like it was a thing with both Hagen Smith and Schultz too. Their stuff dropped off, but they stayed healthy.

55 minutes ago, chw42 said:

I like FIP as a stat, but there are clearly pitchers who it does not account well for. I don't think you can say with a ton of confidence that the pitcher has no control over balls in play. That's kind of ridiculous. Soft contact on average will result in lower BAA than hard contact. I don't think that's some sort of rocket science. You can't just assume somebody will have league average BABIP or LOB% if they're making bad pitches. It's like that Patrick Mahomes meme where if you just adjust his TD% to league average, he's like Dak Prescott. Contact quality absolutely matters when judging pitchers and it is something they have some sort of control over. A lot of May's expected stats last year were closer to his actual ERA than FIP. Which makes me think he wasn't that unlucky.

That being said, he did change up his arsenal last year and his peripherals did improve over 2025. Having 3 fastball shapes and throwing them all at around 20-25% each is something that you can have a lot of success with (see Schlittler). It's just that his other offerings were terrible last year. Maybe they think they can fix his sweeper.

Yeah I know, that's why I said his poor quality of contact meant he isn't a strong candidate for positive BABIP regression. On the positive side his fastball shapes and changeup are all quality pitches, so limiting sweeper usage (or fixing it this offseason) could result in a good 3/4 starter.

3 hours ago, southsider2k5 said:

You keep going back to this one stat, so I started looking around. While his fWAR is 2.8, his bWAR was 0.4.

Looking deeper, he got a career low in ground balls (high in flyballs), his BABIP was .318, his soft contact rate was also a career low. Of his pitches, his sinker was also at a career low, and he seems to try to replace that with a slider/cutter/change output.

His hard hit rate plus HR rates exploded.

In a simple sense, his pitch mix changed a lot, and he got his A LOT harder.

From the numbers, I think fWAR has to be looking more at the predictive stuff, versus the output stuff, as that would explain a lot of a 2.4 WAR difference. Most of his expected and predicted numbers liked his final output better than his bottom line actually did. Having one of the best defensive teams in MLB behind him in Milwaukee, plus a good defensive team in STL, you can't explain away the difference in his FIP and actual ERA as a defense behind him hurting him kind of fluke, so I am not sure what the causes him to miss his expected numbers by a full run that will be fixed by being a White Sox next year. Milwaukee has also become a pitching factory and couldn't do anything for him.

I also wonder if as an act to try to preserve his health, they are taking the heavy sinker away from May, and are moving him more towards side to side moving pitches which isn't working as well so far (at least).

More than anything I want to hear someone say in detail, what about next year is actually going to push him towards his expected numbers, other than just his expected numbers getting repeated.

The primary difference between fWAR and bWAR is that fWAR uses FIP and bWAR uses ERA.

FIP is more predictive of ERA, but that doesn't mean it is a better reflection of what has happened. Also, Mays FIP was an outlier among the predictive stats so that WAR value is pretty misleading. Saying he had similar seasons to others because of the fWAR is a reach.

The issue with May too is that innings and health have almost always been an issue in his career.

Calling May a #3 doesn't align with his profile and health history.

46 minutes ago, Whisox05 said:

That’s code for “they offered me $52.5 million and I’d be a moron to not take that offer.”

7 minutes ago, ChiSoxFanMike said:

That’s code for “they offered me $52.5 million and I’d be a moron to not take that offer.”

Or you know...he liked the team? Not posssible though

26 minutes ago, Baron said:

Or you know...he liked the team? Not posssible though

Sure, that could be the case. But the dude just scored generational wealth after finally staying healthy for 278 innings over two seasons in which he still wasn’t all that effective. He had earned around $20 million up to this point in his career. Of course he Randy Marsh’ed in his pants signing this contract that almost tripled his career earnings thus far.

Let’s be real, if another team had offered him 3 / $60 million, do you think he’d be a White Sox?

Edited by WhiteSox2023

5 hours ago, Y2Jimmy0 said:

You'd be selling low right now. Who plays shortstop in this scenario?

Couple things. We all tend to assume Colson’s value is just in a dip or a valley. But there’s also a chance it does not get better or even declines. The other thing is, if anything, this system’s strength is the depth at that position. If Colson can be used in a package for pitching, a temporary solution can be found until the cavalry arrives. And FWIW, I would not want to temporarily move Miedroth, but there’s that too.

Edited by Chick Mercedes

9 minutes ago, Chick Mercedes said:

Couple things. We all tend to assume Colson’s value is just in a dip or a valley. But there’s also a chance it does not get better or even declines. The other thing is, if anything, this system’s strength is the depth at that position. If Colson can be used in a package for pitching, a temporary solution can be found until the cavalry arrives. And FWIW, I would not want to temporarily move Miedroth, but there’s that too.

Who is going to pay full price for Colson Montgomery when they just watched what we watched last year?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 4

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.